I had a piece of placenta raw right after birth and a raw piece each day for the next two days. I was waiting on it being encapsulated so after that I switched to taking pills. I'll answer your questions one at a time.
Why did you decide on it? I think it's totally natural to consume your placenta. All other mammals do it and I believe it to be beneficial for health purposes. Going into it, I expected it to help with postpartum bleeding and baby blues.
What did it help with? I think it help with my energy level and healing. Physically I felt really great after this birth. My small tear healed very quickly and I felt like my uterus went back to place faster this time.
Are you surprised with what it helped with? Not really. I was expecting it could help with just about everything after birth.
Was it worth it? Yes. Partly because it wasn't hard to do. I didn't do it.

My mom offered to encapsulate it for me so she brought it home and did all the work. But she actually really enjoyed doing it.
Would you do it again? To be perfectly honest, I couldn't really tell if it helped for the baby blues or the bleeding. I still bleed for about 5 weeks, although I'd say the bleeding was lighter all together. I actually experience MORE baby blues this time than with my first. But that could be attributed to having a 4 year old to care for as well, so it's hard to say if the placenta helped or not. There were days that felt it was actually making it worse. It's possible, since along with all of it's healing powers it's also packed full of hormones and everyone will react to those hormones differently. But with all of that said, yes I would do it again. I feel like it had some noticeable benefits and I'm sure it had benefits that went unnoticed as well.
When did you start taking the pills? I started on day 3. That is when my mom was done making them. The placenta has to dehydrate for 6 hours so you won't be able to start until day 2 at the earliest. That is why I also consumed a piece raw right after birth. It went down really easy and was virtually flavorless. We cut small pieces and put them in the freezer so on day 1 and 2 I had a piece to swallow as well. The pills actually were more flavored then the raw pieces I swallowed. The pills have a very irony taste and quite a strong aftertaste. To be honest, I didn't even taste the raw piece. I just swallowed it with a glass of wine. (P.S. the pills are also said to work better with a glass of wine.)
Did you make them yourself? No, my mom did. You can make them from raw or cooked placenta. She did my raw. She dehydrated it for 6 hours and then ground it up by hand as to not interfere with the integrity of the natural energy. (Some people don't like to introduce electronic energy to the placenta by using grinders).
How often did you take the pills? Two pills at a time 3 times a day for the first 3 weeks postpartum. As often as needed after that. I'm now taking two pills once a day before bedtime. I decided to take them before bed so that any hormone shift is lost in sleep, yet I'm still getting the physical benefits provided. I have plenty of pills left.
#1 thing it helped with? Healing. It also just felt good to be
doing something productive. Something that I knew was healthy for me.
And for your last question, I usually just ask people why they think it's so weird. I just explain the health benefits and add in that mammals have been doing it for decades. I'm sure somewhere along the lines of evolution humans stopped consuming their own placentas. Probably when we learned how to cook a steak for the postpartum mother instead.

But that doesn't mean that it isn't still beneficial. It may not be
necessary like it used to be, but it can't hurt, right?
I do have one funny story to share as well. My DP is in a band and his guitarist is a long time friend of ours (we'll call him J). He was over visiting shortly before my little guy was born. We had the birth tub set up and the house prepared for our home birth. J was talking to me about the upcoming birth and asking questions. J asked me, "So are you planning on eating your placenta or anything?" Surprised by his openness I replied, "Actually, yes, my mom is planning on encapsulating it for me so I can take it in pill form." The look of discuss on this mans face was priceless.

He quickly said, "WHAT!!! I was joking!!! Ewe, ewe, ewe......I was totally joking.....don't tell me those things!!!" I laughed and told him he should expect it from me, and don't ask if you don't want to know.
