Kolbe vs Seton

[4JMJ]

We are considering enrolling and trying to compare the 2 programs. Does anyone have experience with either of these? We will be teaching multiple grades (1st, 3rd and 5th). Any feedback, good or bad, would be greatly appreciated!
Thanks!
ETA - We are also considering Mother of Divine Grace, if anyone has feedback about that program it would be great!

[frugalmama]

I like the few Seton items I've seen, but I've not seen any Kolbe texts.

We use CHC and LOVE it. No enrollment makes it much cheaper too.

[4JMJ]

Thanks! We have used some CHC items in the past and enjoyed them. So going with them totally is another option we are considering (nothing like giving us too many choices, haha!) I'm struggling with whether we need the advisor/grading piece. Part of me thinks it's a good thing and another thinks it's not necessary right now!

[jlpumkin]

Well after considering all of them we settled on Seton this year. I love MODG but $$ wise it's not the best option for us. Seton is working out for us really well. Initially it was a bit overwhelming but once I relaxed and found out groove w/i the program we are doing much better.

Last year we did Sonlight. Totally different. So adjusting to more school at home has probably been a big part of our adjustment too. I love love love that I have no question whatsoever that my child is getting a top notch education. It's challenging and she loves it. But she is a workbook kid.