Hi Penguintrax,
I asked the same question over a year ago and here are the responses I got:
http://www.mothering.com/discussions...threadid=34680
A lot of the tips were really good, but I especially appreciated and followed NaturalMamma's recommendations about how she interviewed therapists.
I agree with muse that gut feel is an important aspect. I interviewed about 6-8 people on the phone and then met with 2. The first woman I met was okay, but when I met the second therapist, I knew almost instantly that things "clicked" with her.
How I found my therapist was by word of mouth. I posted on Mothering and on a couple of local mom's email groups I belong to. It was a little hard to post that I was looking for a therapist, as I was worried people might judge me for it. But in the end no one did - some people even really appreciated my admitting I needed one - and I got in touch with an awesome therapist that I'd never have known about.
The therapist I chose isn't on my insurance's "preferred provider" list, but I still get reimbursed 70%. We can sort of afford it, so I feel it is absolutely worth it to go to her even though she costs more. Also, my therapist doesn't do this, but some providers charge a higher rate for patients with insurance (as opposed to 100% cash payments) and then waive some or all of the "remainder" owed by the patient if they can get the insurance to pay 70% or 80%.
Good luck, hope you find someone great! After you dig through the muck, therapy can actually be fun!
Carol