Mothering › Mothering Discussion Forums › Breastfeeding › Breastfeeding Beyond Infancy › 12 month old nursing almost exclusively, doc threatening FTT
New Posts  All Forums:
 

12 month old nursing almost exclusively, doc threatening FTT

post #1 of 42
Thread Starter 
So.

Help.

My daughter turned 12 months old on September 25. She does not really eat solid foods. She takes many tastes but never enough that I could even remotely call it a meal. She just nurses from the breast. Day and night. She poops every day, sometimes more than once and pees. I always thought she was getting enough.

At 10 months old, I had her tested for anemia. She was indeed anemic (8.9 hemo). After 2 months on Floravital, her hemo is 12.5. So no anemia anymore.

At her 10 month appointment, doc was satisfied with her growth. SHe's always been small, a peanut and gained slowly. But she was following her own curve and her head size and height were growing well too.

Yesterday, she had her 12 month visit. She only gained like 3-4 ounces since 10 months. Now, from 10 months on she became mobile, crawling, pulling up, etc. The doctor didn't seem to care about that, he freaked out. He told me I needed to start pumping ALL my breastmilk so I can keep track of how many ounces she is getting. WHAT? She's never had a bottle and I don't pump....I don't respond well to my pump. I tried to explain this but he was rolling his eyes. I got furious and started yelling. THis guy does NOT believe in extended BF, and is ill informed about BF, to be kind. I switched to a new doc who was nice but never returned my phone calls and left on a month long vacation when I needed her tested for anemia. That's why I went back to this guy.

Her head was growing fine still, and I'm not sure about height but I think it is OK too. Honestly there was a lot of defensiveness on my part and the whole thing is kind of a blur (except for the great hemo test, that was nice).

I am starting EI occupational therapy with her on October 5th to get her more interested in solids. (Ei agreed to take us on but said she was borderline during her eval. Every other area was fine, btw.) She loves to play with solids and she'll take tastes off my fingers but she never likes it enough to want to eat them herself. The good news is she likes rich foods, like goat cheese, gravy, mashed potatoes, etc. The bad news is she doesn't love them enough to start chowing down.

I don't know, I was upset to see she barely gained at all in 2 months, but given mobility and a week long trip to Florida where we all traipsed around Walt Disney World in 100 degree heat for a week, I was not horribly shocked, I guess. She just poops a lot and always seems OK, hunger wise. She's too busy getting into things these days. But I want to do what's right here. Ped wants me to cut back drastically on BM and give her solids like 6 times a day. He says I need to be tough here. I think he's misinformed. But I am also scared and so tired of dealing with small babies (my son is a peanut too, but he was eating solids well at a year).

She is about 17 pounds at a year, for those interested. Tiny, but she doesn't look unhealthy at all. She even has a fat roll of each thigh. I dunno. I'm doing the best I can and I am sick of exclusive BF too but how can I deny her the only calories she's getting?
post #2 of 42
your ped is out of line. your baby sounds fine. my DD1 weighed 17 at a year. DD2 weighs 21. just keep offering stuff. MY dd1 still dont really eat anything and she is 3.5 weighs 28 lbs. your lo is pooping more than once a day? good. then she is getting enough.

to get my kids to eat anything, i had to be eating it first then offer bites off my fork or spoon.


can you go for a second opinion at the other doctor?

it is perfectly normal for there to be little to no gain between 10 and 12 months or whenever the crawling and pulling up and cruising thing starts. they expend a lot of energy learning that. it is like when adults go to aerobics classes. only they wanna do it 24/7 lol.

oh and FTT looks way worse than that. your baby wouldnt have fat rolls. my DD1 was real skinny but still had body fat you could pinch.

some kids dont eat to fill up really until 15 mo even. until then it is just play for my kids. my 12 mo DD2 hardly eats either.
post #3 of 42
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by LionessMom View Post
your ped is out of line. your baby sounds fine. my DD1 weighed 17 at a year. DD2 weighs 21. just keep offering stuff. MY dd1 still dont really eat anything and she is 3.5 weighs 28 lbs. your lo is pooping more than once a day? good. then she is getting enough.

to get my kids to eat anything, i had to be eating it first then offer bites off my fork or spoon.


can you go for a second opinion at the other doctor?

it is perfectly normal for there to be little to no gain between 10 and 12 months or whenever the crawling and pulling up and cruising thing starts. they expend a lot of energy learning that. it is like when adults go to aerobics classes. only they wanna do it 24/7 lol.
THank you. You were in my DDC, I think. I think you are right, I just really need support. None of my nursing friends think this guy is remotely correct. And I can't believe he just dismissed the mobility factor.

She doesn't poop more than once EVERY day, but she does usually poop once a day. YEsterday was a 2 pooper (right before the appointment, too, could have used those extra ounces) and Saturday she was ill with a small cold and pooped 4 times. Usually though, it is once a day, maybe randomly skipping a day here and there.

He asked me in astonishment how I kept track of how much she was eating. I said through poops and pees and just watching her hunger cues. He is so uninformed it INFURIATES me.

I guess I can go get a second opinion with the guy I switched over to but I am so tired of peds.

I will keep offering. Yesterday she enjoyed many bites of creamy macaroni sauce (spit out the noodles, though). But when she's done, what I am supposed to do? Force her? I already tried that at 10 months. DISASTER. I let her play until she was covered in mac and cheese. Today I am trying yogurt again.

I am just still so mad. I wondered about supply, but I still feel letdown. I hear her swallowing. Everything is EXACTLY the same as it was at 10 months (when he said she was growing fine) except she started crawling, pulling up and just generally getting into things. That is ALL that is different.
post #4 of 42
No advice Regarding the doctor but I have to say, my 4 year old DD was 17 pounds at a year too. She's now 34 lb and super active and very smart. She doesn't eat a whole lot but she's fine.

One of my favourite articles about this was written by Dr. Jay Gordon. He says look at the baby, not the scale. Here's the link to his article. It made me feel a lot better.
post #5 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pandme View Post
THank you. You were in my DDC, I think. I think you are right, I just really need support.
oct? 2009? you "look" familiar

i would have fired that doctor right to his face. i seriously would have said something not so nice and then said "you're fired". but i dont reccomend that. maybe someone can give you info to give him if you go back to him. info about breastfed babies and growth, like the WHO bf baby growth chart and an article about increasing mobility etc.
post #6 of 42
Thread Starter 
Thanks for the article.

Here is a pic of DD at 11 months.

http://s75.photobucket.com/albums/i3...=1285773553780


Big? No. (Well, she's got a big head like dad and big brother). But she doesn't look underfed or ill to me.
post #7 of 42
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by LionessMom View Post
oct? 2009? you "look" familiar

i would have fired that doctor right to his face. i seriously would have said something not so nice and then said "you're fired". but i dont reccomend that. maybe someone can give you info to give him if you go back to him. info about breastfed babies and growth, like the WHO bf baby growth chart and an article about increasing mobility etc.
I think I did say "You don't know what you are talking about, how many babies have you nursed?" I was really angry. Everything lightened when the hemo test was done. I think he expected her to be anemic still and was all ready to order a full blood draw to see what was wrong with her.
post #8 of 42
Awww. She's adorable! I think we were all in that DDC together. Gracie loves food, but is still BF for most of her nutrition. I think you realize he is misinformed. IF you otherwise like the guy, just smile and nod and say waht he wants to hear... like we women do with most men...
post #9 of 42
Thread Starter 
But he said "Most of the time, FTT has no cause." I took that to mean he thinks she's FTT. I just really don't want to go back to him again, he is about as clueless about extended BF as it gets.

Friends who see him say he's fine if you are "by the book" (as in the What to Expect type book) but the minute you deviate, it's a problem. My friend's super smart son didn't talk at age 2 but had over 100 signs. (He talks great now at 3.5). This doctor was all "Why would you want to teach him signs?" He's a terrible ped.
post #10 of 42
My dd was mainly breastfed until closer to two. She is very healthy.... It left me wondering if she might have had some sensitivities and somehow was "bright enough" not to touch the stuff until her body could handle it.
post #11 of 42
Personally, I'd run from that doc and find another one.

Not being interested in solids at a year isn't really a big deal. Mine finally started eating food around a year, and will eat anything in front of her now. She's hardly gained anything since about 9 months, but she was really chunky before then, and slimmed down when she got more mobile. Just like my son did, who is 5 and has been in the 25th percentile for height and weight since he was 1.

A pump won't tell you how much your baby is taking in. It will only tell you how much you are able to pump.

You don't have to take your baby to a pediatrician. You can use a family doctor or naturopath. You also don't have to do well-child visits unless you feel they are necessary (I totally skip these with DD, but take DS to his because it's once a year and we like our ped.).

Pooping every day is a great sign. Your doc is a UAV and personally, I would consider filing a complaint with the office supervisor and maybe even the AAP, LOL. A medical professional whose job it is to care for children should be more informed about breastfeeding, that is, the normal way a baby is fed. It makes me livid that breastfeeding is such a foreign concept to many American pediatricians, and I think the AAP should make some changes.
post #12 of 42
Can you find yet another pedi? A breastfeeding friendly pedi?

Breastmilk is awesome! There's no need to try to force her to eat solids. DS doesn't really enjoy them yet either (he has oral aversions do to a super sensitive gag reflex) so I give him plenty of things to chew on that expose him to different textures- rice rusks, plain organic cherrios, organic cereal bars, cold fruit, etc. According to our (very pro-breastfeeding) pedi, it's not about actually eating solids at this point, it's about exposure.
post #13 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pandme View Post
Thanks for the article.

Here is a pic of DD at 11 months.

http://s75.photobucket.com/albums/i3...=1285773553780


Big? No. (Well, she's got a big head like dad and big brother). But she doesn't look underfed or ill to me.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pandme View Post
I think I did say "You don't know what you are talking about, how many babies have you nursed?" I was really angry. Everything lightened when the hemo test was done. I think he expected her to be anemic still and was all ready to order a full blood draw to see what was wrong with her.
she looks great! just like my baby looks and mine weighs a lot more.

i wouldnt go back personally.

do you drink milk? does your baby spit up a lot? or used to when littler? does baby poo dipes look forthy or mucuousy? if so then you could quit dairy. some babes are sensitive to it in the milk and makes absorption of other stuff harder. cant remember specifics though.
post #14 of 42
Just wanted to chime in. My DD was 17.5 lbs at a year and her doctor was completely unconcerned. She has zero problems with anemia, and they did prick her at her year WBV to check. She does eat a pretty good amount of solids, though.

She just went thru a big growth spurt and from what our home scale says she is about 19 lbs at 14 months. At this rate (assuming she doesn't level off again) she will likely be 20 lbs at 15 months, which according to the WHO growth charts is right around the 25th %ile.

As long as she is meeting all of her other milestones I would not worry. My doctor had me fill out a milestone quiz at her 1 yr. visit and she was right on or ahead for everything. I asked the doctor about Lily being so small and she was unconcerned based on her anemia test and the fact that she had just learned to walk.
post #15 of 42
Thread Starter 
I know I don't have to do WBVs (we stopped with my son at around 15 or 18 months because of this type of weight issue except he was eating solids well) but I felt like in this case it was warranted because I just felt at 10 months she was probably anemic and wanted it tested. My new doc was on a month long vacation and is a family doctor so wouldn't have done a hemo test in his office anyway. He would have probably sent me in for a full blood draw. Anyway, this guy did the quick and easy one and I just needed to see someone that minute and he filled the need. And my instinct was right, she was anemic. The only reason I went back to him was the follow up hemo test, otherwise, I would never have gone back to him. He is not a good fit at ALL.

I just wish I liked the new doc more or felt he would at least return phone calls. THe funny thing is, he was highly recommended.
post #16 of 42
I'm so sorry mama. What a total quack .

Here you go, calories and fat content in breastmilk versus solid food.
http://www.kellymom.com/nutrition/vi...dcalories.html

I would tally up what the amount of calories and fat would be in a typical one year old's diet, and then compare that to what she is taking in. I would maybe borrow/rent an acurate (to the oz.) scale, and weigh her before and after a good feeding, then document it. You could work with a LC to do this and sign off on it. Because frankly, someone like him could do something really stupid and report this. Not that it would hold water, but it could really make your life miserable if he believes your DD is FTT as a result of breastfeeding.

And I would absolutely never go back to that guy if I had a choice. Get some rec's from your local LLL perhaps on BF friendly docs.

Hugs, I hope it all works out!
post #17 of 42
I would definitely say "adios" to this ped. My son didn't eat much in the way of solids until he was at least a year old and even then it wasn't much.

It sounds like you are doing everything right! You seem more knowledgeable than the ped on this.
post #18 of 42
Thread Starter 
How should I do this? EI already has this guy's name as my ped, should I switch it to the other (non-phonecall returning) doc? I feel like we should a checkup with him too just to get him in the loop? Or maybe try to get someone completely new?

Keeping a tally of her nursing would be a lot easier if she didn't nurse so much and so unpredictably throughout the day. We don't really have scheduled sessions, so I never know what's going to be a good session and what's just a quick nip. THis is the way we've always done it and it always worked until now, of course.
post #19 of 42
Quote:
Originally Posted by Pandme View Post
I know I don't have to do WBVs (we stopped with my son at around 15 or 18 months because of this type of weight issue except he was eating solids well) but I felt like in this case it was warranted because I just felt at 10 months she was probably anemic and wanted it tested. My new doc was on a month long vacation and is a family doctor so wouldn't have done a hemo test in his office anyway. He would have probably sent me in for a full blood draw. Anyway, this guy did the quick and easy one and I just needed to see someone that minute and he filled the need. And my instinct was right, she was anemic. The only reason I went back to him was the follow up hemo test, otherwise, I would never have gone back to him. He is not a good fit at ALL.

I just wish I liked the new doc more or felt he would at least return phone calls. THe funny thing is, he was highly recommended.
My DD was more anemic than yours (around 6 IIRC) because she was a preemie, but I had our ped. put a standing order for a blood draw in the computer so I could just bring her to the lab instead of his office.

Doctors can be so hit-or-miss. I love our ped. and we've been going to him since my son was born, and then at about a year, he starts telling me that we should CIO my daughter, and that he did with all his kids.
post #20 of 42
He clearly knows NOTHING about breastfeeding AT ALL. Get the bf growth charts off of kellymom.com, have him replot everything on those charts. I highly doubt he's using those charts, chances are he's using the charts based on OVERWEIGHT babies.

And I really wouldn't push her to eat solids. Eating a lot of solids at this age is NOT a biologically normal thing. It came with the invention of formula. Not with the introduction of the human species. In other places where babies are truly fed on their OWN terms (both solids and bf) most babes will eat VERY few solids before the first year and a half to two years. DS didn't start eating 5-10 times a WEEK until he was 15 months old. As in, he would usually eat about once a day...sometimes twice, sometimes not at all. He's incredibly healthy. When baby NEEDS more than just your milk, your baby will let you know. It's EXTREMELY unlikely for a child who is nursing on demand and allowed to eat solids at their own pace to not eat enough.

Your ped is a UAV, to be frank. Unfortunately he sounds like the type that you probably won't ever get through to. But the most important thing is that YOU know your baby is trusting her own body and that her body knows what to do!!!
New Posts  All Forums:
 
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Breastfeeding Beyond Infancy
Mothering › Mothering Discussion Forums › Breastfeeding › Breastfeeding Beyond Infancy › 12 month old nursing almost exclusively, doc threatening FTT