Help me choose fabric for a slipcover?

[Coconut Chronicles]

I have this chair from Ikea. It's currently in a corner of our bedroom and needs to be slip covered in the worst way. I'm having trouble choosing between 4 fabrics. DH is no help because when I asked him he just shrugged and told me "whatever you want"

Our bedroom is painted Benjamin Moore's "Nantucket Gray" which is this really calm neutral grey with just a hint of moss in it. This is our bedspread.

So here's a pic of the chair in our bedroom: CLICK and here's a pic of the four fabrics on the chair (I've put the names in notes on the pic): CLICK

Close ups of the fabrics:

One
Two
Three
Four

Sooooo which one do you like best?

[Purple Sage]

I like the first one the best.

[sophiesgrandma]

I love #3!

[sunnysandiegan]

Personally, I wouldn't use any of those fabrics. I'd want an accent color. Or I'd leave it as is and drape a throw or place a small pillow for a color pop.

It is hard to see the colors of everything on a computer screen and grays are hard to match. As far as I can tell, the stripe would go the best with your walls and carpet.