Thank you for all the input!! Â Here's what we ended up doing:
Â
-Girls arrived at 4:30, and they played for abut 30 minutes.
-I set up the T-shirts and decorating items (thanks Schmikol!), and they made their t-shirts while the potatoes finished baking.
-For supper, we had loaded baked potatoes (butter, salt, pepper, sour cream, cheese, turkey bacon, and steamed broccoli).
-After supper, we had cake and ice cream, sang Happy Birthday, and DD opened her gifts.
-DH and I put the littles to bed, and the girls got their PJs on and set up their sleeping bags.
-DH set up a horse movie for them (The Silver Stallion), and they enjoyed some popcorn and hot chocolate while they watched it.
-We sent them down to DD's room after the movie, and they laughed and talked until about midnight. Â
-In the morning, we made GF pancakes, scrambled eggs, and a fruit salad. Â The girls enjoyed playing together until the parents picked them up at 11:30.
Â
I would say overall the party was a success. Â There was one girl who will not be invited back to our house, but even with all of her stuff, DD said she had a great time, and very much enjoyed herself. Â As birthday parties go, it was pretty easy and inexpensive for me, too.
Â
Â
Â
Â
Â
Â
Â
Â