Here's my situation: everyone around me--my parents, my pediatrician, even my husband--is trying to pressure me to "sleep train" my 6-month-old daughter in Cry-It-Out style for my own good... and I'm such a sleep-deprived mess I'm having trouble organizing a firm clear persuasive response. It doesn't help that I'm not having much success with any of my own "no-cry" methods! Any tools or ideas for fighting back?
Here's the background:
When DD was a newborn, I was able to use the "she's just a newborn" card to ignore any suggestions that she be allowed to cry, and I managed to get my husband mostly on board with me. I've always responded to any crying as instantly as possible by nursing, rocking or otherwise comforting her, and she almost never cries when I'm caring for her. She cries more often when my husband or mother watch her (cause she hates bottles) but they always held her when she was crying.
Plus, we weren't having any real sleep conflicts. By 9 weeks she was sleeping through the night on her own (and we cosleep--half the night she's in the crib right next to the bed and the other half she's in the bed snuggled with me.) Even when I returned to work at 12 weeks she only woke once or twice at night to nurse, so I always got at least a 4-hour sleep stretch.
Fast-forward to the present. Starting around five months, she started waking 3 times per night, then 4, then... every hour sometimes. And often crying, not just waking up and moving around quietly like before. I'd try to comfort her and put my arm around her and soothe her back to sleep, but only long bouts of nursing or rocking would actually do anything. And even after nursing, she'd often wake and cry again in another hour.
Meanwhile, my life fell apart otherwise--at work I went from being a high-performing star to being such a zombie that I got reprimanded by my manager several times (and especially now that my husband has just been laid off, I REALLY need that job!). All I did on evenings and weekends was lie in bed and nurse/nap with the baby.
And everyone started saying "you are hurting yourself and you're going to get ill by insisting that she only nurse at night and that she can't CIO"...
Since she was drooling and gumming everything, I figured it was teething. So I took her to the pediatrician with my mother in tow to make sure it wasn't a medical issue keeping her up...
And my otherwise great pediatrician informed us that the problem was that baby didn't NEED to nurse so often, but just WANTED to, so we needed to start sleep-training her via Cry It Out.
And then my otherwise great therapist (I have OCD and see a cognitive behavioural therapist) insisted that the pediatrician was right...
And then my parents and husband took this as validation of their views...
And I tried to talk to friends and coworkers who otherwise seemed to be very AP-style--babywearing, breastfeeding nurturing types... and discovered they all used the Ferber method.
And yeah, now it's just a mess. My parents are not people who believe that any articles I send them on why CIO is bad/harmful are valid ("you just put too much trust in books"). My husband unfortunately has read some articles promoting Cry It Out and has friends who swear by it.
And I've been trying techniques from the No Cry Sleep Solution but having no luck whatsover... mostly because I'm so sleep deprived I can't seem to get organized enough to try them:
- I've tried repeatedly to pull her off the breast just before she falls asleep... but she latches right back on and nurses until she's asleep.
- I've got a daily bedtime routine for her, but due to my work schedule, we can't start it until 8:30 p.m. and sometimes even later (9 p.m.)
- I've tried as much as possible to let her nap in the crib, but she often ends up sleeping in my arms, in my husband's arms, in her wrap, in the stroller... (we are big babywearers, my mother included).
The only thing that's been working at all to help me function is handing the baby off to my mother (she lives with us) or husband for the first four or five hours of the night, and letting them give her a little pumped milk if she wakes up... then cosleeping and nursing her every time she wakes for the rest of the night. But this makes my hubby and mom tired and cranky, too. And just makes them pressure me to try CIO even more.
... ok, see how disorganized my thoughts are due to sleep deprivation?! Help?















