Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Child-Led Weaning › Closet extended nurser or are you open about it?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Closet extended nurser or are you open about it? - Page 2

post #21 of 32

I nursed DS1 to 4 1/2, and DS2 just weaned a few weeks ago at 4+ years. I didn't hide, but didn't go out of my way to share, either. I didn't nurse in public after age 2 1/2 or so, but if the subject came up, I was fine letting people know my son still nursed. Some people thought I was crazy, some were supportive. shrug.gif I can't think of anyone who made me feel bad about our choice to my face, but based on snippets I've heard, I know there was some talking about it behind my back. Ah, well. What can you do? ;)

 

As for my pediatrician, he was totally supportive. Up until age 2 1/2 or so, he loved to remind me how much my risk for breast cancer was reduced by my choice to EBF. After that, he would point out that there were really no studies that showed a nutritional or immune benefit to an older toddler or preschool from nursing, but that it wasn't harmful, either, and we should continue as long as we were both comfortable. I think that was his way of giving me an out if it wasn't working for me anymore, you know?  

post #22 of 32

I don't talk about it much especially with people who aren't close. There are a very few people who know -- some in my local AP group, a good friend, and that's about it. Relatives, aquaintances, etc. don't know and I haven't talked with them about it much. But then ds is almost eight. I think we went sort of underground around 3 but I think it was much more underground by 5 or so. Nobody needs to know since he only nurses at night these days.

post #23 of 32

In the closet at 3.25yo.  Id be embarrassed if everyone knew I was still nursing my 3 yo who is now in preschool (although inside I'm super pleased and proud to have gone this long!)

In my family thats not normal (their normal is to either all formula or BF for a few weeks or maybe few months tops) although fortunately I come from a really polite family who have never said anything rude to me about it yet.

The only bad comments I have gotten so far have been from DH unfortunately he is no longer on board and feels it is not normal and that our son will grow up to have psychological problems.

Of course that just makes me want to nurse him forever to prove him wrong

post #24 of 32
Quote:
Originally Posted by SubliminalDarkness View Post

I don't hide it, but I don't go out of my way to make it known, either. Some people know. Some people don't, because there's no reason that they would. 



This is me as well. Some of my family and friends know (mainly anyone with whom we have spent an overnight in the recent past) but I don't have occasion or need to mention it to most people.

 

Part of it is that although I'm confident it's a good decision for DS, so I wouldn't really have trouble talking about it, I don't particularly want to spend my energy educating anyone at this point.

 

Most of my friends and family know I nursed him to age 3 and some, so they already know my stance on the issue.

post #25 of 32

I'm still nursing my almost 6 yo (she will be 6 in April), and aside from 1 or 2 close friends (of mine and hers, lol) no one knows. I think 4 was kind of the point at which I stopped feeling comfortable talking about it with people in my life, as I know very few people who nursed past 3.

post #26 of 32

When i went to the docter for a mammogram [or something like that] she asked why i didn't have the mamogramm for 6 years,

I said, because i'm nursing 5 years now.

She then asked how many children i have, I said

; eh, 1...

and then she looked very ehh, surprised...

just wanted to tell this :-)

 

It depends on the people you know I guess.. 

some people are open minded and you can tell them.

some people aren't, I don't tell those people then..

 

good luck!

 

 

 

post #27 of 32

My DD is just about 2.5 and I think she has pretty much weaned :-(.  I am 22 weeks pg currently.  She was down to only nursing once a day before bed, then every few days, once a week, etc.  I was pretty much doing the "don't ask, don't refuse" thing, and she stopped asking very often.  Occasionally, in early pg, when she was still nursing before her nap too, I would distract her or tell her we'd nurse later, before night time, because I felt so sick and was unfortunately getting the "ick" feeling a lot from nursing. Then after she had not nursed for about 3 weeks, she asked one night and we started, but the pain so was excrutiating and unexpected I actually screamed.  Of course it scared her, and I tried to explain it wasn't her fault, etc, but we just couldn't continue.  That was a little over a month ago and she has not asked since and I feel so sad that this was probably our last experience nursing. :-(  But then again, my breast pain this pg seems to be super bad and I just don't know if I could do it.  Anyhow....long intro, but that is where we are at. 

As for closet or public, it definitely depended on the company we were in, after about 18 mth or so.  Around my mom or close friends, no problem, they knew.  Around other family or not as close friends, definitely not, and they probably had no idea I had continued. And sometimes when it would come up I often found myself saying things like "well, she only nurses once a day" or the like, and then I'd kick myself later, wondering why I couldn't be more confidant about it. I guess I just wasn't up for the confrontation, and really, it isn't anyone's business.  I was lucky in that she rarely asked to nurse in public when she was older. Signing helped too....she learned to sign fairly early on and sometimes she'd sign, and I could whisper to her "later", or "when we get home" if I was uncomfortable.  Now I would be proud to tell anyone who asked that we nursed for almost 2.5 years. Funny how when you are doing it though, you are kind of protective of who knows. Seems that is common from the posts.

 

I am lucky in that my DH is very supportive. In fact he is all scared now that she doesn't BF and wants to put her on some sort of multi vitamin, even though she is a very good eater. He also wanted to see the 2 sibligns nurse together I think. Maybe it's odd, but I actually felt quite a bit of pressure from DH throughout the nursing relationship - he always wanted me to nurse more, not less!  In the early days, if she was fussing in the slightest he'd say "shouldn't you be nursing her" even if she had just finished a short time ago, etc. There were times when I even argued with him that he was not the one having to be up all night, etc!  But now he is the one who goes to her if she ever wakes in the night, and I think he treasures this part of their relationship so much that it has all worked out well. She calls for "daddy" now at night which is very sweet, and I feel like that might be a good thing considering I will soon be attending to the baby at night.

And from reading other posts....maybe she will want to nurse again when she sees the baby nursing?!  who knows!  I really don't know how I will handle that.  I told myself when I got pg than I would take her lead, and was prepared to tandem if that's what she wanrted, but now I must confess I am kind of glad she seems to be done, and slightly terrified at the thought of nursing 2 at once. But even having said that, I have cried a few times at the thought of her being done, and it being my fault for scaring her away.

 

I don't think my doc knows we BF for so long, and if she did she probably just wouldn't say anything. My midwife now knows and was very supportive....in fact I was almost embarrassed to tell her she seems to have weaned!  We moms always have something to be guilty about, don't we?

 

Good for all of your EBF'ing out there. It is such a wonderful gift for our children. Sorry for such a long post... I guess I needed to get a few things off my chest, so to speak!  thanks.

post #28 of 32

My 3.5 year old doesnt really ask to nurse outside of the house, but if he does I dont normally nurse in public any more.  Would I if he got hurt and needed the comfort for that?  You bet.

I dont really talk about it with people that are not for extended breastfeeding.  I dont hide it either. 

I have found over time that extended nursing makes many uncomfortable because it brings to focus their own decision to not nurse longer.  This is not true for all, but for many.  

post #29 of 32
With the exception of the great-grandmothers and near strangers, I guess i dont hide the fact that one of my twins (almost 4.5) is nursing about once a day. I did stop nursing in the general public about a year ago because it just didn't feel like the best place to nurse, but I'll nurse in front of family and friends. I just don't see it as anything to hide from people because it feels so perfectly natural and right. Anyone can see that my kids have magic in their steps so I just nurse with pride and let their extraordinary little selves speak to our parenting choices. I never feel questioned or scrutinized about my nursing choices and after breastfeeding twins on one lactating breast, I guess I've only felt praised by those around me when it comes to nursing.

Just to throw it out there, I nursed until I was almost 5, as did my younger siblings. Thanks Mom!
post #30 of 32
Quote:
Originally Posted by DoubleLove View Post

With the exception of the great-grandmothers and near strangers, I guess i dont hide the fact that one of my twins (almost 4.5) is nursing about once a day. I did stop nursing in the general public about a year ago because it just didn't feel like the best place to nurse, but I'll nurse in front of family and friends. I just don't see it as anything to hide from people because it feels so perfectly natural and right. Anyone can see that my kids have magic in their steps so I just nurse with pride and let their extraordinary little selves speak to our parenting choices. I never feel questioned or scrutinized about my nursing choices and after breastfeeding twins on one lactating breast, I guess I've only felt praised by those around me when it comes to nursing.

Just to throw it out there, I nursed until I was almost 5, as did my younger siblings. Thanks Mom!


You are so lucky!!! My mom nursed us for the "obligatory" 6 weeks. Then went back to work and to formula. Bleck.

 



Quote:
Originally Posted by AtYourCervices View Post

Nobody IRL knows that my 4 y/o DD still nurses. Not even my husband. He thinks she weaned a year ago when she turned 3. It's a non-issue. However, a few months ago DD got hurt and was crying. I was holding her and she pulled down my shirt and started nursing. My husband stared for a few seconds then said "We don't want her to start THAT back up again." I remained silent. DD nurses anywhere from twice a day to once every few days.


I wanted to ask, HOW do you hide it from your dh?

 

 

As far as me, I am not sure if I am CLW, b/c I am not sure..... But I am nursing my 3 yo. EBF yep, but CLW, not sure. I am almost ready for him to wean..........BUT.................. Anyway, not trying to highjack.

post #31 of 32

My first post here shy.gif I'm so happy to have found a community where I'm not treated like a circus freak for being AP and CLW.

My younger daughter turned 5 in November and older daughter is 7, YDD is still nursing. No one else knows about it. My parents are totally accepting and very supportive of CLW, but it just has never come up, so I'm not sure if they think I've weaned my kids or not. It's something we do, not anyone else's business. I've never been asked directly whether I still do, and when the topic comes up in public I just stay quiet.

I tell my daughters that it's a private matter, like changing your clothes or taking a bath or using the bathroom, and it's not something we talk to other people about, and they seemed to just take that at face value.


Edited by Delicate - 2/3/11 at 4:00pm
post #32 of 32

I'm no longer BFing, but did until DD was 2.5. I mostly stopped talking about it when she was around 18 months, except with one or two friends who were also still BFing at that stage (or planning to be).

 

A lot of DH's family was surprised I was still BFing when DD was 4 months, and utterly shocked that I was still BFing at 10 months, so, yeah...not my favourite topic of conversation with them.

 

I also wish I could have owned it a bit more, but I have to admit that the judgmental comments did get to me.

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by ar2974 View Post


Yep.  Lots of people think I'm nuts.  I couldn't care less.  I have a newborn and I mentioned to the pediatrician that I had a 4 1/2 year old who was still nursing.  He started saying, "well, in my opinion...." and then stopped and said, "I'm sure you don't care what I think and didn't ask anyhow so I will stop now".



Ha! ROTFLMAO.gif

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Child-Led Weaning
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Child-Led Weaning › Closet extended nurser or are you open about it?