I just made these a few weeks ago for the first time.
I grew up with my grandma making them... she calls them 'salt dills'.
Â
I added fresh dill, garlic cloves, and mustard seeds. They were delicious. I used the small pickling cukes, so I don't know how the larger ones would work. though i agree with the others - i don't think they'd be as firm.
Â
Thanks for the tip on giving the cucumbers an ice bath before going in the jar. I'll try that next time.