Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Extreme Separation Anxiety
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Extreme Separation Anxiety

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 

So my dd will be two next month. She's always been a mama's girl, preferring me strongly to everyone else, but in the past few months it's gotten out of hand. I can not leave the room. To make it worse, when I leave her with dh, she says "I don't want Papa. I don't like Papa" etc. It's breaking his heart. But what's worse is that he is losing patience with her. He has become so frustrated with it that he is saying things like "Well I don't like you either." :( He is a really good guy, he's just had enough of it. He always comes back and tries to hug her ands say sorry when something like that slips. She screams uncontrollably every.single.time they are alone together, even for thirty seconds.I can't do anything without her without major stress for the whole family. It's driving us all batty. 

 

It seems to get worse after we've been out of town (the kids and I go back to our home state every few months for a week-ten days-ish) Our last trip was almost three weeks ago and she has not warmed up at all to DH. It is breaking his heart and it is driving me crazy. 

 

FWIW, she is ok with him when I am in the room.  But as soon as I am gone, she screams like she is in pain. He is not great at  comforting her through this because she slaps at him etc and does not want him to hold her. It's just a mess. :( 

 

Has anyone been through this? Or know how to help this situation? 

Thanks 

post #2 of 5

Hi Mama,

We went through a mild version of this with DD1 when she was around 2.  She was going through some other stuff, but a few things helped her.  #1- I acted like I wanted to be with her 24 hours a day, even if I didn't.  She was fighting about me pulling away from her.  If I acted like I wanted to be with her 24/7 then it reassured her to a large degree.  #2) I would sit in the room with my DH and DD sometimes, but not interact with either of them at all.... let him do all the communicating, comforting, providing, etc., while I was there for physical support.  After a bit, they started to get along great.

Did you breastfeed your DD?  Recently wean?  Sometimes kiddos get upset when they've weaned and their main source of a connection with mama has disappeared but hasn't been replaced with anything else.

Good luck, I know it's tough,

~maddymama

post #3 of 5
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by maddymama View Post

 

Did you breastfeed your DD?  Recently wean?  Sometimes kiddos get upset when they've weaned and their main source of a connection with mama has disappeared but hasn't been replaced with anything else.

Good luck, I know it's tough,

~maddymama

Thanks for replying. 

She is still breastfed, no weaning in sight. She has always been like this to a degree, but it has really gotten out of hand the last few months. 

 

I keep thinking back to the first weeks of her life when DH and I decided to tag team the kiddos at night, he would deal with DS and I would deal with DD and that pattern has stayed ever since. I kind of wonder if we created this problem way back then. Sigh. 

 

post #4 of 5

We also have had a version of this, and my dd is 2 as well.

 

What has really worked for us is for me to help DH identify things/activities that we know usually distracts dd or makes her happy. For awhile it was bubbles.  Then it was anything to do with water.  I also had to help DH not use this thing all.the.time but only in times of great distress on dd's part.  Doing this helped soften the times when I wasn't around and they got to the edge of the cliff of "If dd goes off, she's NOT calming down, not for a loooong time".  I helped DH develop his ways of dealing with her to hopefully not even approach that cliff, but if they got to the edge at least to have last resorts to avoid going over it.

 

Also, We just instituted really regular intervals when dd and DH are alone.  It's at least for a full day on weekends, and usually for a couple hours at night because I work late those nights.  OP how often is your dh alone with your dd, and how long are those intervals?

 

It can be REALLY HARD at first to have these longer stretches, but your dh kinda has to train and prepare for it in terms of doing everything he can to not lose patience.  Your dd is going to fight it, and try to lash out at him most likely, but he's got to have a mantra going in his head non-stop like "She's acting 2 but she really does love me.  She's acting 2 but she really does love me.  She's acting 2 but she really does love me."  This can maybe help him stay calmer when she lashes out.

 

It's kinda like a marathon at first, but in our case more and more dd was comfy and then even happy with dh.  Lately, I'll be walking out the door and she'll glance up and say "Bye bye mommy" and give a hug and kiss if I ask for it (I always ask for it!).  Or if they're going out, I'll walk her to the door and point out something for her to look at "Ooh look at all the leaves!  Ooh look how the car looks wet - can you see yourself in the reflection?" and get her to go out the door and before she knows it dh has scooped her into his car and they're off, usually without a complaint.  This morning she woke up grumpy but she even let dh hold her standing next to me while I was making breakfast  - usually if grumpy she'd cry until he handed her to me.

 

Last thing: it really takes work on your dh's part to try try try to remember that this is a phase, but how you both handle it can really affect how long and how bad it lasts, and also some of her views in the future.  Much as your dh is really just trying to make a point with "Fine, i don't like you either", that is really going down a bad role in terms of how the relationship may progress and what seeds get planted with dd.

 

I so relate though.  One of the reasons I most want a 2nd child (well aside from just really loving the idea of 2 kids and wanting dd to have a playmate) is to have the chance to do everything I can to encourage that child to be totally Dad-focused!  I would love a 2nd child who's like "Where's Daddy?  I want Daddy!" all the time, though I know that's a long shot, especially with breastfeeding.  But we've already agreed that a 2nd child will be put to bed by daddy (along with dd now) on a regular basis from the beginning, and I'm not going to wait as long as with dd to introduce bottles so dh can feed dc#2 as early as possible.

 

Last thing, when your dd says "I don't like daddy!", even though I know she's only 2, do you ever go to her and say "Honey, your daddy loves you and is a really great daddy.  It hurts him when you say that.  It makes him sad."  Just something to plant the seed with her that saying that is hurtful.  OR, me, when dd is crying/screeching because she wants me or doesn't want daddy, I usually say "Honey, I know you're upset and you want ________, but I just can't give it to you right now.  Crying isn't going to change it." and I go on with what I need to do and let her cry.  She almost always either calms a few seconds later, or she has a full on fit and then calms.  But I let her do it, because that's reality: we can not always give her everything she wants right when she wants it, and I see her increasingly able to handle it better and better the more consistent we are about saying "I hear you, I want you to be happy, but this is all I can do right now.  Crying will not change it."  It's working better for daddy too.

 

Good luck!

post #5 of 5
Thread Starter 

Thank you for all the tips. :) 

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Parenting
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Extreme Separation Anxiety