ME Airflows vs. GEN-Y Simplicity?

[letileon]

So, I'm trying to find a great cover for my flats. My son has chubby thighs and is long. I have recently tried the ME Airflows and I like them generally. He is on the smallest waist setting and the middle leg setting in a Medium. I'm wondering if anyone has tried both ME and GEN-Y simplicity and has any thoughts. Are they the same thing (they look the same)? Is one better for chunky thighs than the other? Generally weighing in would be appreciated, thanks ;)

[ursaminor]

I use both.  I love the simplicity covers, tho.  Dont get me wrong, the MEAF are nice bulletproof covers, but the binding is rather ruff and they only have 2 waist snap settings on either side.  The simplicity covers are so soft, stretchier, and I really like the fit.  I will definitely be buying more of those in the future.  HTH.

[chel]

just want to say the ME has 3 snap settings at the waist, atleast on the med setting.

i loved my me airflow.  used with both my kids.  my 14m 20lb dd2 is still in the med.

i agree it is hard to try new covers when you have a good one you like.

for me i tried a blueberry coverall and didn't like the bulk and no air vents

Originally Posted by ursaminor 

I use both.  I love the simplicity covers, tho.  Dont get me wrong, the MEAF are nice bulletproof covers, but the binding is rather ruff and they only have 2 waist snap settings on either side.  The simplicity covers are so soft, stretchier, and I really like the fit.  I will definitely be buying more of those in the future.  HTH.

[ursaminor]

I meant to say ME has 2 snaps on each side for the waist (and 3 snaps either side for leg adjustments), and Gen-Y has 3 snaps either side for waist and thigh settings.