Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › Where did he get that??? "Great job, mommy!"
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Where did he get that??? "Great job, mommy!"

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 

Ever since I read Unconditional Parenting when DS was about 6 months old, I've tried to follow the basic premise of the book - it really resonated with me, and it was relatively easy to parent our easy-going child this way.  One thing I made an effort not to do was rely on "Good job" all the time.  At the beginning, it was amazing how often I was saying it, but it was a pretty easy habit to break, and now I don't think I say it much at all.  I try to say more useful phrases, like "Thank you, that was so helpful to mommy", or "Look at that, you did it by yourself", or anything that is just a bit more observational.  Anyways, it's not a big deal, but it was an easy thing to change.  DH didn't get it at the beginning, but I don't hear him saying it to DS either.

 

So imagine my surprise when we're out grocery shopping, and I hear a loud "Great job, mommy!" as I'm putting veggies in a bag, or "Good job, mommy!" when I clean something up at home.  Where did DS get this from???  It's kinda funny, considering we specifically made an effort not to say it!  He's not in preschool, so he's not hearing it there.  He does have a babysitter occasionally, but I mentioned to her early on that we tried not to rely on saying good job all the time, and I've never heard her say it to him.  At this point, I'm not even sure if it's worth mentioning again to her, and she's not with him all that often (a few hours a week).

 

Anyways, it's not really big deal - I mostly just find it ironic lol.gif  Any other unconditional parents have this happen?

post #2 of 5

People do it to kids everywhere.  Strangers do it to them.  My guess is that the babysitter does it, even though you told her not to, and she might not even notice she's doing it.  It comes very naturally to people.  I wouldn't worry about it though.  I think UP is more about the parents and their kids than babysitters and strangers and someone else's kids.  Kind of a minor issue otherwise IMO.

post #3 of 5
Thread Starter 

Oh, I agree - not a big deal at all, and only one small aspect of UP.  I just thought it was so funny, to have made this effort not to say good job to DS and then to have him turn around and say it to me all the time!  Funny how things work out redface.gif

post #4 of 5

Yeah, my older dd went through a stage where she did it after she started goign to preschool.  (Gee, I wonder where she picked it up? LOL)  But it went away.  It was a good reminder to me of how silly all those "good jobs" are.

post #5 of 5

Yep, y 3 yo also says this to me and DP. He also gives me frequent admonitions "use your inside voice, mommy" when I get mad and start yelling. 

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gentle Discipline
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Gentle Discipline › Where did he get that??? "Great job, mommy!"