or Connect
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Archives › Pregnancy and Birth Archives › Due Date Clubs 2009 - 2012 › February 2011 › PSA- Avoid nipple shield without informed consent!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

PSA- Avoid nipple shield without informed consent!

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 
Please try to avoid a nipple shield! I had no information about them or their function prior to today. On Monday just before leaving the hospital the LC came in and put one on me and said that “fixed” the problem. The thing is, it is a tool, not a fix. Like all tools it is good that it is available but it is overused and can damage supply and cause nipple confusion. I wasn’t informed so I want to help others avoid the awful day we had if I can. My girl refused my breast without the shield and it took lots of screaming sobs on her part, iron will and a few tears on my part, but we are relearning together…she was only on the shield for 36 hours! So be informed when you choose…if you need it awesome but if not do avoid it...

post #2 of 8

I SO agree...and unfortunately, they hand them out like candy :0/   They have their purpose when necessary and I'm thankful they help in those rare situations.

post #3 of 8

hug2.gifjenne--- sounds like a rough time... but it sounds like you made it over another hump! thanks for sharing!

post #4 of 8

I agree its best to avoid. My second I used one to get her from bottle back to breast since she refused to latch on without one. Luckily I was blessed that she willingly went back to breast within 24 hours, she just had to realize she could get her food straight from the source.

post #5 of 8

Sorry you went through that! I agree they aren't very good. Nipple shields are basically a bandaid and don't really do anything. Very few women actually need one. Glad you both are sticking with it and relearning together! hug2.gif

post #6 of 8

For the most part I would recommend avoiding them as well. However, they have their time and place. My first child was severely tongue tied and it wasn't caught at birth. I ended up with infections and bloody cracked nipples, would nurse gripping something with an iron fist and tears rolling down my face trying not to scream. Once we finally got her tongue clipped at day 17, there was so much damage the only way I could continue to nurse and allow my nipples to heal was to use a shield. I have scarring to this day.

I found when I was weaning her from using them that it seemed to work well to start with the shield on and then once she got nursing good I would quickly pop it off and get my nipple in there. Took a little practice and convincing for her, but we made it.

post #7 of 8

I agree!!!!! I had trouble getting my first baby to latch so the nurse said "You have flat nipples. Use this." I used the nipple shield and she latched and I thought it was great. Until the second day or so... and then it was a nightmare. It hurt. I figured out I DIDN'T have flat nipples (I was young and clueless) and the stress of trying to get her to latch without the shield was too much for me at the time. I was overwhelmed by other things going on at the time and I ended up just pumping for two months and then switching to formula :(


My second latched beautifully and had no trouble whatsoever.


Flat nipples my @$$. The dumb shield caused a lot of problems for me (although I guess you could argue that my lack of self-education caused the problem as well...).

post #8 of 8



LCs like to hand those out because, "if its hurting, your not doing it right".  What a crock that little gem is.  I wish I had NEVER gotten one EVER with DS1.  Killed my suppply (because who knew I was going to be one of the lucky few with supply issues no matter what I did)

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: February 2011
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Archives › Pregnancy and Birth Archives › Due Date Clubs 2009 - 2012 › February 2011 › PSA- Avoid nipple shield without informed consent!