I had a terrific experience with Kelli Johnson, and if I'm fortunate enough to have a third child will go back to her. One of my very dear friends is apprenticing with her right now, and another friend is also apprenticing with her-I don't know if those are the only students she has right now.
I was very happy with Kelli...she's not the right match for everyone though...I know, for example, that one of my friends was very unhappy in her care, and that's why it's great to have options. I know a number of my friends have used Diane Albright (All Bright Beginnings) for homebirths-her office is in Altamonte Springs. Kaleen Richards, from Heart2Heart in Sanford has also opened her own practice, part of which is homebirth-she's a CNM I think, which may affect the regulations governing who she can take on as a client and what her limitations are-licensure for CNMs is different. I don't remember the name of her practice though-Tree of Life is ringing a bell, but I don't know for sure. I don't know if Robyn Mattox (who took over the Birthing Cottage from Alice Pilay and then changed it's name) does homebirth-she's in Winter Park, but that may be a birth center only option. She's Inspiration Midwifery, I think. I don't think I know anyone who has birthed with Karen Bove, but she's another option in the area for a homebirth..
You have a couple of local options for homebirth. I hope you can find someone who is the right match for you.