or Connect
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Mom › Parenting › Gifts I would not use, would you say something before hand?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Gifts I would not use, would you say something before hand?

post #1 of 43
Thread Starter 

There is something I think I likely will get as gifts, but no way would I use. I don't NEED anything and in the past, I have always smiled and been nice if I got something I would not use or did not like (which really, does not happen often). 

 

Here is the thing, I have had a fair number of boys. EVERYONE else in my family and my dh's has had girls. Since they are girl only parents, they seem to put outfits on their children that might stuff like "I'm a princess" or "girls rule, boys drool." I have also seen "I'm a hottie" on a baby thing. NO WAY would I allow my daughter to wear those things. We have a rule, if we do not want our child to say it in real life, we won't have her wear it. 

 

I figure if anyone gives me things that say that (this baby is a girl!) then I can smile and be nice and give it to charity later. That has always seemed the right way to handle it. But, I am wondering if I am wrong in how I would handle that, if I should perhaps tell people early on that we will not allow our daughter to wear things like that. I know I see things like that on my nieces all the time. The major part of me feels like a gift is a gift (I do not even register) and that I should just be happy and smile and know its the thought that counts regardless.

 

What do you think?

post #2 of 43

My DH and I also have a rule that states no wording across the fanny of any pants or shorts. Period. I hate seeing little girls with "Hottie" on their behinds.

 

My response woudl be "Since this baby cant read, I would appreciate bears and frogs instead. I dont want too put too much pressure on early literacy" and smile like your joking.

 

 

 

post #3 of 43

Well, I'm a very upfront and rather confrontational person, so take that into consideration.  I also don't really care about etiquette.  Anyway, when I was pregnant with ds I said, "no vehicles, no Disney, no sports, nothing that says 'BOY' on it, nothing with the words mommy or daddy"  And we didn't get that stuff (well not much of it).  I didn't tell EVERYONE, like I didn't tell my co-workers, but I told my family and my close friends.  

post #4 of 43

If this baby is a girl, I'll be pretty vocal about preferences like that.  HOWever....there aren't currently any baby girls in our immediate family yet, so I don't have to worry so much about offending anyone.  In your situation, I might not be so outspoken.

post #5 of 43

That's a tough one. There's some really obnoxious baby girl clothes out there. If it were me, I probably wouldn't say anything. Most people put gift receipts in, especially with clothing. Then I would just exchange them. If you want to get passive-aggressive about it, you could give them the gift of the book Cinderella Ate My Daughter. I just heard an interview with the author a while back (I haven't read the book) and she was talking about exactly the sort of clothes (and other products) you've mentioned. 

post #6 of 43

I'd just smile and nod and then donate or return the gift. If there are other parents in your family who dress their girls in those kinds of clothes I think it would be taken as insulting or judgmental if you told them that you will not dress your DD in those clothes. It's more gracious to just accept the gift and then dispose of it however you wish.

post #7 of 43

Honestly, I think you are overthinking things.  Just because they put that stuff on their kids doesn't automatically mean they will give it to you. 

 

Also, especially since this is your first girl, it's likely that you will get A LOT of girl clothes.  People love to buy girls clothes.  Of all kinds-frills, lace, cutesy words, pink, purple, princesses etc etc etc.  And, as a result, parents are often stuck with clothes that their kids never get the chance to wear, or that they only wear once.  Because of that, for the most part, no one thinks twice about parents taking stuff back or taking it to goodwill or whatever. 

 

And, you know, even when parents don't have philosophies about what their kids won't be wearing ( ie "no Disney" or "nothing pink" or whatever.) there are times that a parent is gifted an outfit for their kid that they just don't like.  That knit jumper that grandma picked up at the garage sale for $1 that is obviously from 20 years ago that even though it's in good condition just makes you cringe (yes, experience)  Or, that specialty boutique outfit in brown and pink paisely that is just super trendy and was way expensive but really in no way fits ANYTHING that you might like (also experience.)  And, you just take it back or take it to goodwill, or just shove it in the back of the drawer and never put it in the kid.  Nine times out of ten, unless it's some family herloom or something that has really special meaning to the gift giver, it's really just not that big of a deal. 

 

I think saying something ahead of time is going to make a bigger deal out of it than it has to be.  If I bought my niece something with Disney Princesses on it, and I never saw her in it, it's likely I wouldn't even notice, and even if I did, I am not going to say anything.  BUT, if my brother came to me and said something like-Hey, we know you love Disney Princesses but we don't believe in the commercialism that represents so please stick to wooden toys (or whatever variation thereof,) I would be somewhat offended, irritated, and would be regularly rolling my eyes behind his back. 

post #8 of 43

It is never polite to tell people what types of gifts they can't give to you or or your kids. It's rude and presumptious. Just accept the gift and thank them then get rid of it or just don't have the baby wear it.

post #9 of 43
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lisa1970 View Post
I figure if anyone gives me things that say that (this baby is a girl!) then I can smile and be nice and give it to charity later. That has always seemed the right way to handle it.



nod.gif that's still the way to handle it. There's just no graceful way to tell people (especially if they haven't asked) that you don't care for their taste in clothing for girls! If they ask what kinds of things you want, you can say "I really like Hanna Andersson/Carter's/whatever brand you like" stuff. If you see them often, they'll notice that you don't put your daughter in those clothes and may change. Or not. But once they give the gift, it's not their place to ask what you've done with it.

post #10 of 43
Thread Starter 

There is one thing I could say that would probably head off the shirts that say these things....our babies have had skin problems and cannot wear polyester. Currently, our 18 month old has such horrible eczema that we are getting little sleep as he wakes at night crying from the itching. Maybe if I just show the eczema and comment that he cannot wear polyester...just like the other children..maybe they will get it. I, myself, break out when I wear polyester so now I just never wear it.

post #11 of 43

OP I think you have to stick with your present philosophy on gifts.  Say "thank you" and later return (if there's a gift receipt) or donate.  Also, if you are out shopping with one of these relatives, or if you see one of their girls wearing something you actually would like to dress your dd in you can make a point of making positive comments about the clothes/stuff you do like (to give a hint that may or may not be taken).   Anything more than that would be too pushy and/or offensive (implying they dress their dds in an inappropriate way) IMO.

post #12 of 43
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lisa1970 View Post

There is one thing I could say that would probably head off the shirts that say these things....our babies have had skin problems and cannot wear polyester. Currently, our 18 month old has such horrible eczema that we are getting little sleep as he wakes at night crying from the itching. Maybe if I just show the eczema and comment that he cannot wear polyester...just like the other children..maybe they will get it. I, myself, break out when I wear polyester so now I just never wear it.



They come in cotton too.

post #13 of 43
Quote:
Originally Posted by Lisa1970 View Post

T

 

I figure if anyone gives me things that say that (this baby is a girl!) then I can smile and be nice and give it to charity later. That has always seemed the right way to handle it. But, I am wondering if I am wrong in how I would handle that, if I should perhaps tell people early on that we will not allow our daughter to wear things like that. I know I see things like that on my nieces all the time. The major part of me feels like a gift is a gift (I do not even register) and that I should just be happy and smile and know its the thought that counts regardless.

 

 



 



Quote:
Originally Posted by LynnS6 View Post





nod.gif that's still the way to handle it. There's just no graceful way to tell people (especially if they haven't asked) that you don't care for their taste in clothing for girls! If they ask what kinds of things you want, you can say "I really like Hanna Andersson/Carter's/whatever brand you like" stuff. If you see them often, they'll notice that you don't put your daughter in those clothes and may change. Or not. But once they give the gift, it's not their place to ask what you've done with it.


Ditto this response to your initial reaction.

 



Quote:
Originally Posted by Shaki View Post

I'd just smile and nod and then donate or return the gift. If there are other parents in your family who dress their girls in those kinds of clothes I think it would be taken as insulting or judgmental if you told them that you will not dress your DD in those clothes. It's more gracious to just accept the gift and then dispose of it however you wish.



Yes, this too.

 

 

When our girls were born, I make some suggestions to close family that we did not want matchy-matchy for the twins (girls) and couched it in the fact that I worried about telling them apart.

 

By now, *almost* anyone knows that we dont do anything but basics (no rude sayings,no characters, no on-the- butt writing, no tween styles,no skimpiness, no bikinis, etc) for our 5 yr olds. My MIL complains that it makes it 'hard' to find clothes, but still complies. Other gifts we get at this age are mostly toys or books- which we have yet to have concerns with. We keep a running Amazon list, which gives suggestions--- helps make sure that they have an idea of what the girls like ( science, crafts, board games, etc).

 

BUT, when they were small--- I said nothing to friends/coworkers, etc....and yes, we got some matchy outfits. It was fine. Yes, we got some clothes I did not use or want to use. I donated them or took to resale shop. (and wrote a thank you note for thinking of the girls, but no mention of donation).

 

 

BTW: their girl cousins DO wear clothes that DH and I do not approve of. We dont say anything to their parents about clothing styles--- so it is possible they may/may not agree with ours. So far though, the gifts they have given us have been appropriate so I know they took what 'we' liked in consideration instead of what their DDs wear.  If people know of your boys clothing style, hopefully you will be pleasantly surprised that people will try to get something you like instead of what they would choose- KWIM?

post #14 of 43

There is only one person I would feel comfortable enough to tell our preferences to, and that person would also expect honesty and it isn't a big deal.  Maybe two.  

If people were nice enough to take their time to pick out and give gifts I would accept happily and thank everyone for their kindness.  Then later donate things that aren't wanted and I would not tell them. 

I have one relative who I donate near everything they have ever given me or my family, this has been going for years.  But I always am grateful for their thoughtfulness and tell them thanks in person or write thank you cards.  It really is the thought that counts.  

post #15 of 43

I would accept the gift, and be nice, then not use it, donate it, or exchange it.

 

But, hopefully most people would already know how you feel about it before hand.  My daughter was a dancer, and the school sold dance shorts with the name of the studio across the bum.  I happily let her wear that.  But, if they said "dancer", or "Jazz hands" or "Hot stuff", I said "no", and all my friends and family knew I felt like that... I wasn't even overbearing about it. I'd just mentioned it occasionally.  A few times, when she was older she got something from one of HER friends that said something inappropriate on it.  But, by that time, even she wouldn't wear them.  

 

Around Easter, my daycare boys seem to show up with T-shirts that say "Chick Magnet"... but, it's a picture of a baby chicken and a giant magnet.   I think that's cute.

post #16 of 43

To me a gift is just that-a gift.  It is not for me to dictate. In the case of receiving something I don't care for I choose to be gracious and to follow up with a sincere thank you note, usually one that doesn't mention the gift specifically but more about how much I appreciate their thoughtfulness/kindness. 

 

 

post #17 of 43


 

Quote:
Originally Posted by HollyBearsMom View Post

To me a gift is just that-a gift.  It is not for me to dictate. In the case of receiving something I don't care for I choose to be gracious and to follow up with a sincere thank you note, usually one that doesn't mention the gift specifically but more about how much I appreciate their thoughtfulness/kindness. 

 

 



Exactly. To do anything else shows ingratitude.

post #18 of 43
Quote:
Originally Posted by philomom View Post
Exactly. To do anything else shows ingratitude.


Eh, I just wanted to put out there that, personally,  if *I'm* buying gifts for someone, I really would appreciate and happily receive guidance and feedback.  I find the idea of someone politely accepting something they hate and then donating it far more offensive than the idea of someone mentioning to me (before or after) that they like/don't like x y z.  shrug.gif

 

But again, in the OP's situation, it's difficult to convey "I think what your kids wear is hideous and won't let my daughter wear anything like that" politely lol.gif

post #19 of 43

I agree with this.  Just take it and say thank you and give it away or something.

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by Shaki View Post

I'd just smile and nod and then donate or return the gift. If there are other parents in your family who dress their girls in those kinds of clothes I think it would be taken as insulting or judgmental if you told them that you will not dress your DD in those clothes. It's more gracious to just accept the gift and then dispose of it however you wish.



 

post #20 of 43
I would continue with your present method of graciously accepting & then donating to charity for the most part, BUT if there are close family/friends who will likely be regularly giving gifts to you/your child, then I would at least let them know. It doesn't have to be a big announcement or anything, just a casual/joking/venting/whatever worked into your conversations... but I know I'd hate to continually give someone gifts they can't or won't use.

One of my friends casually said something about not wanting her girl to wear all pink. She wasn't dropping hints or anything, just mentioning it, but when it came time to find a gift for her baby, I was really glad to know about the pink thing and selected the clothing very carefully...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Parenting
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Mom › Parenting › Gifts I would not use, would you say something before hand?