I second Dr Broker! Dr. Bertuna is also quite good, though young and less experienced. I heard she is good about backing off and letting women labor. The problem with River Rose is that you get who is on call. I loathed Dr. Clark, he spends too much time with his horses and it shows in the examining room, I didn't even know a pelvic exam could happen so fast! Clark is known around town as being a C Section pusher and brags about how fast he can do one. Ramey also has a bad reputation...
I know people who were happy with Chan and Coats, they are both very reserved about giving C Sections from what I have heard...
If you want another midwife option, there is one out of West Virginia who facilitated my daughters birth (there are many very good local midwives in athens but they are underground because they don't want to lose their nursing licenses). Angelita Nixon is the WV one:
http://anmidwife.com/
She is very professional, and can help you bill through your insurance. They were talking about getting someone local to do the Athens births but through her administrator, which is what I did, but it was very unofficial.
Wow they are letting a midwife deliver in a hospital? How civilized!! Which hospital? I would have loved the option of a compromise with my first but I was too afraid to get stuck with horse Csection man (who somehow I got stuck with for EVERY prenatal visit, even though I am Broekers patient) so I did a homebirth instead of hospital and delivered in 3.5 hours. I had a wonderful experience, I would be interested in knowing more about the CNM-attended birth though... do share what you find out :-)
Follow Mothering