Toolip- yes, my charts are always very clear. No guesswork. That's why this is so weird.
JMJ- Probably 95% of my infertile time, I have creamy cm, including during spotting ending AF. Sticky & dry are rare, and not present in about half of my cycles. I know that's really weird, and when I was first learning about NFP I worried there was something wrong with me. But it's just what I'm used to now.
My pre-O temps usually range from 96.9-97.6, so it's just that they were so high this cycle it threw everything off. Had I not temped til day 12 or so, I would definitely assume I had O'ed. I even took an HPT cd8 or so, because my temps were still so high. I dunno. It's looking like I probably wont know until AF. What's another week or so? :)