Thank you, that's good to know. I am so NOT artistic so it's one of the subjects I struggle with. I am actually using Seton Art 1 this year (technically doing K) because I was looking for craft projects that follow the liturgical year, although we haven't done all of them. I also did some of the art projects in Who Am I? (which we blew through...we were done by January except for a handful of lessons I was saving for Lent/Easter, in hindsight I should have started him with 1st grade religion). But like you, I'm looking for something that teaches a progression of art, so I appreciate the feedback!
If you liked Seton Art 1, you'll probably like CHC's A Year With God as it's a lot of the same, but more projects for older kiddos. We have both and do a little from each.
I'm still on the hunt for a good art program as my dd REALLY likes art and is pretty good at it for being 4.5yo.