Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Unsolicited parenting advice from last night
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Unsolicited parenting advice from last night

post #1 of 17
Thread Starter 

I am not upset by it or anything, I just wanted to share it. My daughter was at orchestra practice. There was a woman there who I had visited with before. The practice is at a church, even though it is not related to the church. It is a city orchestra and that is just where they hold practices. So I was visiting with this woman who I had known casually over the last couple years as our daughters are in this orchestra. I know her so casually that I did not know her name and I only remembered that she home schooled because I saw her daughter's doing their school work, so not really a relationship there. In the course of the conversation, I mentioned that I am returning to home schooling the next year. But I am a little worried about college admission and such. That is when she started to tell me that I should reconsider letting my daughter go to college. Basically, it seems that she feels a woman needs to live at home until she marries and then her husband can take care of her. She needs to learn how to run a household and not be exposed to the things that she will be exposed to at college. I wimped out on that and just said "my husband wants her to go to college." Anyway, I know this is how some people raise their children and that is fine. I respect other's rights to their religious beliefs but that is definitely not how I intend to raise mine.

 

Then the next bit of advice was, during all this, my 19 month old was running back and forth. Realize, the kids there practicing were on the stage but the parents and other kids were just milling around talking to each other and such. My 1 yr old would run to the bottom step, step on it, step back off it, and run back to me. But at one point, he went up 3 steps so I picked him up out of fear that he would keep going and run over to his sister in the orchestra. Like any other 1 yr old would do, he objected and tried to arch his back and let out complaints about it (but he cannot talk yet so it was babble) and I walked him to the back of the room..which was a huge room. We are not talking a small space, we are talking an auditorium for at least 1000 people. The same woman from above told me I need to spank him and if I don't, I will regret it when he is older because he will be out of control. Ok..he was not interrupting anyone. All the older people (adults and kids) were talking to each other. Why is it that my 1 yr old cannot say anything? He was not out of control, he was just complaining in baby babble. He was also arching his back trying to get back down, but I was not having any trouble holding him. He was not wailing or being disruptive or anything. I really do not like people who think children are meant to be seen but not heard, but seem to even in the seeing, want the small children to hold perfectly still. I almost said back "we don't hit our children, we have other ways to deal with our children" but knew it would be pointless.

 

Anyway, I just excused myself as the orchestra let out then and my daughter was walking toward me. So, just wanted to share what happened. No big deal, but I am sure I am not the only person to get such "helpful" advice from others.

post #2 of 17
haha. That's when I silently roll my eyes and think "I'm glad I'm raising my kids and not you" orngtongue.gif
post #3 of 17

Wow sounds like she was just chock full of advice...;0) 


 

 

post #4 of 17

yikes, I feel sorry for her kids. I can't imagine being a teen girl and being told to have no life until some man married me and made babies with me so I could start spanking them.

 

I think I'd jump out a window.

post #5 of 17

Yikes. That woman is not doing her daughter any favors by leaving her completely unable to work for a living if she needs to someday.

post #6 of 17
Quote:
Originally Posted by swd12422 View Post

Yikes. That woman is not doing her daughter any favors by leaving her completely unable to work for a living if she needs to someday.


I agree. I haven't had to work in 15 years but my degree is in a field that would "re-certify" me with just a little brush-up education.


Many years ago I was nanny. I met another nanny from a Mormon family and they would tell my friend they would pay for a wedding, not for college. So she'd work a while, move out.. go to college.. end up broke... move back home, work some more.. save up and repeat. I was always appalled that her parents wouldn't even let her live with them while she was going to school. And she never finished. It was just too tough for her that way.
post #7 of 17

is it wrong that I hope that woman's daughter is a closet feminist who also becomes a high-powered (AND high profile) career woman?

 

 

 

post #8 of 17

My daughter's best friend's parents were the same way.  "Women will grow up to be wives and Mothers, and nothing else" 

 

But, their first daughter got a full ride scholarship to a school in Colorado, and their middle dd (best friend) got a partial scholarship to a local college, and then she got a job and has been saving money.  She wants to be a teacher.  

 

Their parents love them more than life it'self, and now they think college is the best place for women.  LOL  

post #9 of 17
Quote:
Originally Posted by JessBB View Post

is it wrong that I hope that woman's daughter is a closet feminist who also becomes a high-powered (AND high profile) career woman?

 

 

 


ROTFLMAO.gif
post #10 of 17

Hi Lisa, you know after the comment about spanking your baby, I think I would have to say something.  Perhaps just a simple "Wow, we sure have different parenting philosophy's"  Just enough to let her know that you don't feel the same way.  That way she is free to ask you more if she wants to; but she can realize that you don't agree with hitting your child. 

post #11 of 17

She said you should spank your child for protesting a little? Actually, from how you described it I bet he was explaining, "But mom, I wasn't going to go farther! I just wanted to climb a little higher!!!!!"


 

post #12 of 17
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by AFWife View Post

She said you should spank your child for protesting a little? Actually, from how you described it I bet he was explaining, "But mom, I wasn't going to go farther! I just wanted to climb a little higher!!!!!"


 


LOL..yes...he has explained a lot to me lately! He is soo cute!

 

She is actually older..I don't know how old, but her youngest was a teen. She is a really conservative Christian home schooler which I take to mean a certain mindset I have seen somewhat. I guess she just assumed I was too because I said we were returning to home schooling. I don't know. But I do not subscribe to her thinking. I am a Christian. But I am a Christian who is fine is my son is the SAHD and my daughter has a power career. (I just hope they both stop to smell the roses and not just work through their lives so much that they do not enjoy it).

 

post #13 of 17

My mother was a homemaker when we were young.  But when my father got sick, she went back to work as a teacher, a job that could support our family and was made possible by her college degree. 


When my mother was widowed with her two youngest still at home and ages 1 and 3, she certainly appreciated her

 

ability to work  at a well paid position. 

post #14 of 17


This sounds like the "Stay-at-Home Daughter" movement.

Quote:
Originally Posted by Lisa1970 View Post

I am not upset by it or anything, I just wanted to share it. My daughter was at orchestra practice. There was a woman there who I had visited with before. The practice is at a church, even though it is not related to the church. It is a city orchestra and that is just where they hold practices. So I was visiting with this woman who I had known casually over the last couple years as our daughters are in this orchestra. I know her so casually that I did not know her name and I only remembered that she home schooled because I saw her daughter's doing their school work, so not really a relationship there. In the course of the conversation, I mentioned that I am returning to home schooling the next year. But I am a little worried about college admission and such. That is when she started to tell me that I should reconsider letting my daughter go to college. Basically, it seems that she feels a woman needs to live at home until she marries and then her husband can take care of her. She needs to learn how to run a household and not be exposed to the things that she will be exposed to at college. I wimped out on that and just said "my husband wants her to go to college." Anyway, I know this is how some people raise their children and that is fine. I respect other's rights to their religious beliefs but that is definitely not how I intend to raise mine.

post #15 of 17
Thread Starter 

That is very interesting, thank you for sharing.
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by pammysue View Post


This sounds like the "Stay-at-Home Daughter" movement.



 

post #16 of 17

I was just going to post the same thing.  It is big around here in one particular town. Many people have been accusing the community of being a cult.

 

A few other blogs:

http://strivingtoserveathome.blogspot.com/2010/05/stay-at-home-daughter-graduation.html

 

http://www.likeawarmcupofcoffee.com/home/2010/06/a-stay-at-home-daughter-responds-to-what-if-a-woman-doesnt-get-married-etc/
 

Quote:
Originally Posted by pammysue View Post


This sounds like the "Stay-at-Home Daughter" movement.



 

post #17 of 17
Quote:
Originally Posted by pammysue View Post


This sounds like the "Stay-at-Home Daughter" movement.


That's actually pretty interesting.  It's not really for us, but I like it, and can see the point to it.  I don't disagree with it at all...I just don't think I'd ever fall into that.   What if your daughter never gets married?  She should stay at home?  Forever?  Clearly whoever created this idea has never seen my daughter's room... I'm ready to be rid of the clutter and mess.

 

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Parenting
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Unsolicited parenting advice from last night