Mothering › Forums › Health › Vaccinations › Measles in Utah
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Measles in Utah - Page 3

post #41 of 54

Turquesa, thanks for the article.  It's amazing what they were able to find.  I don't see much in the article about what techniques they used.  Do you know any more about that?

post #42 of 54

oops... double post

post #43 of 54
Well, SLCC finally contacted me through Email, a little slow on the punch if they are trying to prevent deadly diseases from spreading its way past the 10 day incubation stage if this happened on the 11th.
Edited by KayCSmommy - 4/27/11 at 8:48pm
post #44 of 54
Thread Starter 

I go to SLCC as well, and I got an email YESTERDAY warning me that I was possibly exposed on April 11th. Well, thanks for the heads up 2 weeks later! He he. The email was really frantic and poorly written, as if someone was in pure panic mode writing it.

I'm not afraid of DS getting measles and was secretly hoping he would be exposed so I wouldn't have to think about it ever again. 

I wish we could know the vax status of ALL cases. grrr.

post #45 of 54
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMJ View Post

Turquesa, thanks for the article.  It's amazing what they were able to find.  I don't see much in the article about what techniques they used.  Do you know any more about that?


 

I've been fishing for the link and can't find it.  There are a lot of news stories about it, but I can't find the specific one that talked about how they contacted different county health departments and collected the data (I believe through Freedom of Information laws)  Health Departments vary state by state with how much data they're willing to spill.  Some are cooperative, others cite (ahem!) "privacy" concerns.

post #46 of 54

Please let me know if you find out.  There is something fishy going on around here.  An unvaxed family gets the measles (3 cases).  They pass it on to 2 more unvaxed people and 1 vaxed person, and it sounds to me like the vaxed kids spread it from there to other vaxed people, but the health department stops telling us what's going on.  I don't know much about getting the information, but the public has a right to know what is going on.

post #47 of 54
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by JMJ View Post

Please let me know if you find out.  There is something fishy going on around here.  An unvaxed family gets the measles (3 cases).  They pass it on to 2 more unvaxed people and 1 vaxed person, and it sounds to me like the vaxed kids spread it from there to other vaxed people, but the health department stops telling us what's going on.  I don't know much about getting the information, but the public has a right to know what is going on.


I agree, it's weird. 

 

post #48 of 54

I doubt there is any sort of conspiracy going on.  The public for sure has a right to know how affective the vaccine is, but they do not necessarily have the right to know any individuals private medical information, nor, I believe, does the health department have a right to share that information - wouldn't it would fall under HIPPA?  With such a small number of cases, even not naming names when telling vaccination status is still basically telling everyone who knows who the latest person to come down with Meales is whether or not that individual was vaccinated.  

 

My guess would be that the first family gave permission for the information to be released and later families did not.  Or problems arose as a result of releasing the information and so the stopped doing it so as not to anger other families or when some lawyer came along and pointed out that it was a privacy violation. 

 

The CDC puts out a report every year on the number of measles cases and how man were vaccinated or unvaccinated.  From a larger report like that, it is far more difficult to determine the vaccination status of any particular individual who was known to have measles, unless it was the same for all, so not so much of a privacy violation.  Whether or not information about individual cases and vaccination is released to the media now, I do expect that the report will come out  eventually revealing that information for the entire year just as it usually does. 

post #49 of 54



 

Quote:
Originally Posted by mamakah View Post

I go to SLCC as well, and I got an email YESTERDAY warning me that I was possibly exposed on April 11th. Well, thanks for the heads up 2 weeks later! He he. The email was really frantic and poorly written, as if someone was in pure panic mode writing it.

I'm not afraid of DS getting measles and was secretly hoping he would be exposed so I wouldn't have to think about it ever again. 

I wish we could know the vax status of ALL cases. grrr.



 I had posted the letter they sent out to us, but got into trouble and had to take it off.... I agree though

I was secretly hoping that my son would get it too, the lab school for SLCC (my son attends) has had several cases of Chicken Pox, and my son never gets them!! That is my luck!!

post #50 of 54



 

Quote:
Originally Posted by JMJ View Post

Please let me know if you find out.  There is something fishy going on around here.  An unvaxed family gets the measles (3 cases).  They pass it on to 2 more unvaxed people and 1 vaxed person, and it sounds to me like the vaxed kids spread it from there to other vaxed people, but the health department stops telling us what's going on.  I don't know much about getting the information, but the public has a right to know what is going on.



 I read on one of the websites I was looking at that all 9 cases were unvaxed. I am not sure which one it was because I was looking at so many...

post #51 of 54
Quote:
Originally Posted by KayCSmommy View Post


 I read on one of the websites I was looking at that all 9 cases were unvaxed. I am not sure which one it was because I was looking at so many...



Let me know if you find it again.  The KSL article I posted said that case 6 was vaxed, and a commenter on the SLTribune claimed to be the father of case 6 who he said is vaxed, and the grandfather of a vaxed (1 shot, but up to date) toddler who was confirmed to have the measles.

post #52 of 54

I found another article in the Salt Lake Trib this morning about how they want tighter laws on vaccinating children

http://www.sltrib.com/sltrib/opinion/51714627-82/teachers-health-utah-april.html.csp#disqus_thread

 

I hope that the uproar of this measles scare dies down, I was afraid that this may cause parents who are normally oblivous that there are people like us out there that do not believe in vaccinating our children pressure the goverment to get rid of the Philospocial exemptions.

post #53 of 54

I would like to know more about this issue, since my kids go to school in the Granite School District and the school called me to let me know that if the outbreak reaches our school, my kids will not be allowed to go to school. I don't see what the big deal is - I had the measles and rubella when I was about 7 years old, and it wasn't any worse than the chicken pox. My only memories of it were that I itched and that I was really annoyed that my mom wouldn't let me go outside . . . I guess my kids are a danger to the vaxed kids at school? Hmmm . . .

post #54 of 54

Anjis, I believe that excluding unvaxed kids in the case of an outbreak is part of the agreement that parents have to sign for vax exemptions.  Even though we don't think we need to be protected from getting measles, the schools do, and they want to protect us in spite of ourselves.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Vaccinations
Mothering › Forums › Health › Vaccinations › Measles in Utah