So, we've made the decision not to tell family or friends our name choices, but I feel like I want input still. I feel 100% certain for our boy first name, it just feels "right" (which is one of the reasons I think baby is a boy), and fairly certain on the middle name... but tonight's the first time we've come up with a girl name we like or think would work really at all.
I do have some weird "rules"- for the first name, I don't want the name to be in the top 50 for recent years, I'd like it to be Biblical, and I don't want a name that can be shortened. For the middle name, we will use a family name. Our son's name is Noah Wallace (I didn't realize when I named him that Noah was as popular as it was, I have never known anyone named Noah so I thought it was far less common than it was!) and our daughter's name is Faith Marie.
If this baby's a boy, we like the name Paul Robert. The thing that would be neat about using Robert as the middle name is that our son is named after my grandpa, Wallace, and my daughter is named after my grandma, Marie, and my grandparents' last name is/was Robertson, so in a derivative sort of way, all three kids would be named after the same set of grandparents.
If the baby's a girl, the name we came up with tonight is Esther Claire. Claire is a family name on my husband's side.
What do people think of these names? Do they go with our other kids' names? Do they sound good/first and middle names flow well? Are they too "old fashioned"?