Quote:
Originally Posted by
jul511riv 
Yep. I got a "so, is a congratulations appropriate?" from a family member, after announcing that we were expecting. I think if I had ACTUALLY SAID "WE ARE SO EXCITED, as we are expecting our 4th..." it might have been different. We are definately keeping the possibility open to have a very large family. As Orthodox Jews, there is actually a lot of support for this in our community, though none of our families are religious so the feeling isn't shared by those most close to us.
But I'm not sure that, while it certainly is an issue, this is limited to those of us with "large families" (can I even consider myself a "larger family with 4?!"). When I was pg with my first, I had all sorts of negative comments from various people that I ran into. For example, I ws a student (and married) and we were asked everything from if we wanted assistance with birth control to "was this an "oopsie" to an assumption that we would want an abortion. :(
1. On the "so, is a congratulations appropriate?" Why wouldn't one just assume that congratulations ARE appropriate? How much better to err on the side of "congratulations" when the baby wasn't as welcomed as it could have been than on the side of "I'm so sorry" when someone is truly happy? Where else in our culture is it appropriate to be so rude and nosy about such an intimate topic? I'm sorry that your family member (especially knowing that you wanted a large family) was so callous!
2. YES - a way larger family in our current culture!
3. My sister is a psychologist. She is in her late 30s and has been in this career for about 6 years. She and her husband have a 2.5 yo and an 11mo. When they announced that they were expecting #2 (logical - since she's in her late 30s... And they had told all of us that they wanted their 2-3 children close together in age as her husband is a SAHD and then, once they were all in school he would re-enter the work-outside-force...) they had negative feedback - kind of like how this was going to really slow down her career, etc... I just do not know why anyone thinks the size of another person's family is any business of their's whatsoever unless it is truly impacting them.
3. Religious community support for larger families... We are very involved in our church but the denomination in which dh has worshipped all his life and I have worshipped in the last 19 years just doesn't have many folks like us. We have rarely met homeschoolers in our denomination over the past 19 years, no homebirthers, no attachment parents to my knowledge and NO families who allow God to plan their family size. While I have awesome cyber support, I would give my eye teeth to have a "real life" friend who thinks like we do - or at least that shares some of our ideals. On the other hand, we have awesome opportunities to challenge the status quo and give people a different perspective than what they're used to!
Follow Mothering