Not a suggestion, but this is how we came to our decision:
I guess my husband was pro-circ once, never came up...then I made him watch the Penn and Teller episode on it, and I think that's what lead to him becoming very anti-circ. Had he pushed for pro, I would have gone back on birth control and made him wear condoms for the rest of our marriage (or until he would change his mind). No husband of mine is going to put my kid through unnecessary surgery! If I can't trust him not to let random people cut my child up, how can I trust him to ever care for a child?
So after he saw the episode and he told me how mad it made him, I gave him a hug and told him I'm glad I don't have to go back on BC and can continue TTC. I think he was proud of me for that.
I think talking to your husband is going to depend entirely on why he wants it done. Cosmetic? Religion? Misinformation about hygiene or disease? Perhaps you could ask him about his background with the subject, ask about his feelings. Be sure the setting is very relaxed for that conversation, somewhere private, comfortable and safe. If he's circ'd himself, hearing about the neg affects might make him insecure about his body, his sex life, etc. If he's not circ'd, he could be haunted with memories of being bullied for it (which is not a reason to circ, since kids can be cruel, and can find something to make fun of in even the most average looking child, but those kinds of memories are hard to see past sometimes), or old fears that he wouldn't find a girl who liked him (which is BS of course, but you might not know from watching television).
Those are my thoughts anyway. He may require more gentleness than you'd think. There could be all kinds of trauma and fear in there keeping him away from making good decisions.
Edited by objet_trouve - 7/5/11 at 2:26am