When I was younger I thought the more gold and diamonds the better. But my entire family is that way. My mom is always complaining that her wedding ring isn't big enough. Then my own dad, grandpa and brother wear pinky rings... with diamonds. So sad. I was passed down my grandmothers wedding ring. It's 5 ks in the shape of an S. It's gaudy and ridiculous. I have that put away. My brother asked for it recently he actually wants to give it to his fiance... To each their own.
Mine I never wear anymore. I dislike wearing jewelry now. I destroy it all anyway. It's amazing the amount of broken rings, necklaces and such I have in a box in my safe.
That being said if we were to exchange vows again or just recommit in someway I'd be fine with a tattoo, I can't think of anything I would wear and not destroy or wear and feel good about.