or Connect
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Mom › Talk Amongst Ourselves › If you died, would your DP keep up all your crunchy habits?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

If you died, would your DP keep up all your crunchy habits?

post #1 of 60
Thread Starter 

DH and I were discussing this last night. To my sadness, although not surprise, DH admitted than in the event of my absence he'd probably stop composting, start eating boxed cereal for breakfast again, use regular aluminium-containing deodorant, use disposable nappies, buy laundry detergent, and eat supermarket bread. Mostly because he doesn't know how to do stuff like bake bread or garden himself, and doesn't care to learn. Also, although it didn't come up in conversation, I suspect if I died he'd never eat another legume, ever. We have chickpeas, like, once every three months, but he complains every time.... bitterly. :p

 

He did say he'd keep buying free-range eggs, "because it's easy", and that if he remarried he'd make sure his wife was pro-breastfeeding and anti-circ. So that's something, I guess.

 

I felt vaguely insulted at first, but then figured: well, I don't do my "crunchy" stuff for him specifically, but because I think it's healthier/more ethical/tastier/more frugal/more eco-friendly/whatever. And he did say he doesn't mind my crunchy habits (well, he complains about CDing, and he occasionally risks my wrath and buys a block of Nestle chocolate!), and that he likes some of them (homemade bread and homemade ice cream, specifically). So, I guess I can live with the burden of knowledge that if I perish, our household crunchiness will to some extent perish with me. (Dunno what he'd do about meals, though. He's aware of the grossness of takeout and is more anti-MSG than I am, but he also really, really can't cook...)

 

So what about yours? :p

post #2 of 60

I actually think he'd keep it all up....except the bfing....of course ;)  But it would really bug him that our other kids had many years of breastmilk, and the baby didn't. He loves cloth diapering our children, sleeping with them, and slinging them, so I know my kids would still be parented the way we do now. He buys organic whenever he shops. He wouldn't buy paper towels or napkins. He prefers cloth. His meals might not be as "healthy" as mine. But I know he'd  try. :) 

 

 

post #3 of 60

Hmm...I'm not as green as I used to be, and I'm honestly not sure whether dh would keep up even my crappy track record or not. He's okay with me prioritizing certain things (organic from the "dirty dozen", plus carrots, because they taste so much better, and free range, organic eggs and such), but I don't know if he'd be willing to spend the money in the same places. I'm sure he'd stop using borax and baking soda to clean.


With respect to the AP side of things...dh's parenting is a lot different than it would have been if he'd married someone else. I think he'd be somewhat less AP if I died, but far, far more AP than he would have been if he'd never known me, yk? (OTOH, he might even be more AP, because the family would - I HOPE! - pull together in the face of such a loss, yk?)

post #4 of 60

DH tends to be much more adamant about crunchiness than me...although we've never called it crunchiness, just general level of respect of how our actions impact the our environs and a gravitation towards things more natural.  DH is a cycling, reduced-pollution, vegan, cloth-hanky-using fool, and I love him for it.  I use a lot of generic tissues for my sensitive, allergic nose, and I haven't made the leap to hankies.  I  know this has come up a lot on MDC, but often crunchiness is equated with AP, and although I think that AP tends to be crunchy, and don't think that to be crunchy one has to be AP (think child-free crunchy earth-hugging people).  We did AP because it made sense and had an extreme practical side, and I think it our previous earth-hugging attributes had minimal impact on those decisions, since I think of  AP more in terms of parental choices (although AP has a green component).

 

That being said, yes, DH would continue with our current habits because they are so engrained in our daily living.  I just can't see DH living any other way.  He has been more of influence on these choices than me.

 

 

post #5 of 60
Thread Starter 

CatsCradle: Yeah, I did kinda conflate AP and crunchiness/NFL, didn't I? I guess the question applies to both, though, for curiosity purposes...

 

One thing I forgot: I suspect DH would keep using water to wash his hair. His hair got a lot thicker once he stopped using shampoo, and it's cheaper and less hassle, so I doubt he'd go back to the conventional route. (Unless his new wife thought it was gross, of course!)

 

Homeschooling would be an interesting one. Since I met DH I've won him over to the idea, and in fact he's probably more anti-school than I am (having had a pretty lousy time of it with bullying). So I don't think he'd be all "OK, Smokey's dead, I'll just chuck 'em in school"; but I'm not sure he'd actually commit to HSing them himself either. It'd be pretty hard, given that he works (from home, but still...) I imagine he'd struggle with that decision a lot. (And yes, I know HSing isn't strictly about AP or NFL, it's just a parenting thing we're planning to do.)

 

I'm pretty sure he'd at least try to find a source of breastmilk for the baby - probably his sister. And I guess he'd keep cosleeping...

 

Oh, but he'd definitely rush straight out and buy the most toxic, chemically, kill-em-all fly spray he could find. :p In fact, he'd probably do that before I was cold in the ground! He HATES flies and I'm sensitive to the chemicals in nearly all fly sprays, including the "natural" ones.

post #6 of 60

he would keep up the AP stuff, cosleeping (though in a cosleeper), babywearing, GD.

 

he would stop Family cloth, cloth diapering, and wouldn't make laundry detergent or green-clean. and he'd get more processed food. 

 

we're not super NFL, but the more I hang out here and with NFL people in general the more I incorporate into our lives. 

post #7 of 60

I just asked DH and he said "definitely". I believe him. He goes around trying to enlighten people of our AP/NFL ways. (which I think makes him look like a snob!) He wouldn't be BFing although he always says someone should invent a boob a guy can wear to "nurse" a baby....maybe my death would push him to invent something along those lines...


 

post #8 of 60

The AP stuff, sure. Anything else, nope, not a chance. 

post #9 of 60

Homeschooling...I think dh would continue it, if he could figure out how to work it into his schedule.

 

He's also be much greener when it comes to transportation, but not out of personal preference. DH is legally blind, and can't drive. So, I do all the driving in this family. DH gets around (when I'm not with him) by bike and public transit.

post #10 of 60

Dp would probably keep it all up. He'd sleep with the baby, look for donated milk and keep carrying him around :P  As far as NFL, it's equally important to me as to him, so I know he'd keep up with gardening, healthy eating, composting, green cleaning, etc. AP is something he came to through me, but NFL is something we've come to together.

post #11 of 60
Hmm, I'm not sure, this would be an interesting thing to discuss with him!!

I know he'd continue composting, gardening, and recycling, using BS & vinegar for everything, cloth diapering, cloth napkins, etc... I introduced these things but he isn't just 'on board' with them, he really values them.

He'd also probably continue to eat healthy and bake from scratch, though he probably wouldn't remain vegan and wouldn't buy organic etc. He'd probably continue to be frugal but not to the extreme that we are now.

What I'm not sure on is how his parenting would go. He jumps on board with pretty much whatever, basically follows my lead. So I kind of think if I wasn't around, he'd find someone else's lead to follow... maybe his parents, though I know he doesn't want to spank like his parents did. Or maybe our friends would become his role models. I do think there would be a lot more yelling & authoritarian parenting, but I could be wrong there! I don't think he'd prioritize things like breastmilk, babywearing, & cosleeping, though he'd do them if they were convenient. I know he'd want to homeschool, but I don't know how he'd do it as a single parent so that may not be realistic. I think he'd be a lot less free-range. He would probably try to not vax but if it became a hassle he'd just go ahead and do it. I've had a hard time grasping what his parenting style is even now because he just doesn't seem to have a stance on any of it and doesn't have much interest in doing any reading or research... I'm not sure even he knows what his philosophy is, he tends to just ask me what to do, which now that I think of it, is a bit odd...
post #12 of 60


I don't think it's odd! I think some men just value what their wives say and don't feel the need to back it up themselves. DH knows I research EVERYTHING before it is implemented in our parenting/lifestyle and he's always on board with whatever I say pretty much. I encourage him to read up on it, but he doesn't. We always discuss it and I will tell him the valuable reasons as to why I am choosing it and feel it's important. I would say 9x out of 10 he is on board.

 

He trusts I want what's best for all of us and I'm ok with that.

Quote:
Originally Posted by crunchy_mommy View Post

Hmm, I'm not sure, this would be an interesting thing to discuss with him!!

I know he'd continue composting, gardening, and recycling, using BS & vinegar for everything, cloth diapering, cloth napkins, etc... I introduced these things but he isn't just 'on board' with them, he really values them.

He'd also probably continue to eat healthy and bake from scratch, though he probably wouldn't remain vegan and wouldn't buy organic etc. He'd probably continue to be frugal but not to the extreme that we are now.

What I'm not sure on is how his parenting would go. He jumps on board with pretty much whatever, basically follows my lead. So I kind of think if I wasn't around, he'd find someone else's lead to follow... maybe his parents, though I know he doesn't want to spank like his parents did. Or maybe our friends would become his role models. I do think there would be a lot more yelling & authoritarian parenting, but I could be wrong there! I don't think he'd prioritize things like breastmilk, babywearing, & cosleeping, though he'd do them if they were convenient. I know he'd want to homeschool, but I don't know how he'd do it as a single parent so that may not be realistic. I think he'd be a lot less free-range. He would probably try to not vax but if it became a hassle he'd just go ahead and do it. I've had a hard time grasping what his parenting style is even now because he just doesn't seem to have a stance on any of it and doesn't have much interest in doing any reading or research... I'm not sure even he knows what his philosophy is, he tends to just ask me what to do, which now that I think of it, is a bit odd...


 

post #13 of 60
My oldest was around 7yrs when she told me she hopes she dies first if I die, since there will be no one to take car of her.
I guess we both wonder what dh would do if I die.
Co-sleeping, yes. I think the kids and dh would "need" it. But that would only last till a girlfriend comes along.

Considering dh doesn't "do" most of the other stuff, diapering, feeding, shopping, household chores. I think that would just depend on my replacement. As long as dh doesn't have to do anything, he doesn't really care how it is done, just that it is.
post #14 of 60

I don't really follow the thread because I'm not sure where my DH would find the time to do the things that I do on top of his job, and I know that he wouldn't be in a hurry to date/marry. (his mother died when he was a teen, and his father never dated or remarried, and he thinks that was the right thing to do). I'm not saying it would never happen, but that it could be years and years down the line.

 

Anyway, he'd sill need to work his crazy job to pay the bills. Some of the things, like composting, our kids are old enough to do and value. But I fear that if something happened to me, things would really fall apart. Not just about NFL, but about basics like having clean clothes or anyone thinking to clean the bathroom. I fear things would get gross.

 

I'm an reasonably sure that meals would become limited to things he can grill, things that can be purchased at a drive up window, and pasta (cause that's the one food the kids can make on their own).

 

 

post #15 of 60

I don't know what dh would do. It would be difficult for dh to do everything the same as we do now.

I'm pretty sure dd would not be homeschooling if I died today but maybe he would find an alternative to public school. I'd hate for dd to be dealing with grief and have to suddenly transition to a school environment at the same time.

post #16 of 60

Sheepish.gif


Edited by Mulvah - 10/16/11 at 5:54pm
post #17 of 60

i think he would do the best he could, but at times you have to cut corners as a single parent. i wouldn't care about the crunch factor so much that i would hope my kids were loved and supported.

post #18 of 60

DW would not remarry...ever. She would definitely stop doing some babycare things that we do now, like CDing. She also wouldn't look for donated milk, just use formula. But she'd have to go back to work and get a nanny or put DD in daycare. She would practice GD in the future and not co-sleep (we don't now anyway). She would also probably let her cry when she wakes up in the night a little longer than I would like, but not CIO. Plus she fully believes I would haunt the hell out of her if she did practice CIO after I died. ;)

 

As for green and crunchy-ish things. other than babycare, she is the one that does all of that stuff now anyway, so she'd probably continue. Although it wouldn't be that difficult because we don't compost or make our own bread.

 

 

post #19 of 60
If I died, part of me thinks DH would have my kids in a loin cloth running around naked amongst poison ivy and eating foraged food. He is way more crunchy than I am smile.gif

But, part of me also thinks that because he would have to work, he would probably feed them a lot of convenience foods and eat out quite a bit. He probably wouldnt vax or use chemicals to clean our house, but he also probably wouldnt get donated milk or cloth diaper. He buy compostable diapers though smile.gif
post #20 of 60

Mine would keep things up.  Well at least he would try really hard.  He once told me he would have to quit his job and stay home full time to be able to tend to the kids like I do.  So that was a nice compliment.  I'm hoping if I do kick off it's closer to when they head off to college.  My sweetie is great in a sprint, but marathons are overwhelming to him.  ;)

 

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Talk Amongst Ourselves
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Mom › Talk Amongst Ourselves › If you died, would your DP keep up all your crunchy habits?