Edited by 1love4ever - 3/29/14 at 1:31am
The motherlove one has alcohol in it.. which I think would sting. So I would go with the other one. Or just make your own.. that's what I do. It's mostly just witch hazel and essential oils. A friend of mine swears by equal parts coconut oil and peppermint oil too. I did that but it was only really comfortable after my tears sealed up.