these people do sound hard on boats. There is no way they burn out so many boats so quickly without some user error.
I think it was unwise to sign over the title. Or to let them take it without full payment but what is done is done. However getting your money and/or boat just may be more difficult now.
I do not think what you are asking is unreasonable. However a court might. If you can get your boat back, fix it and be done with them that might be enough. The problem is, payment or not the boat is pretty much theirs now. Unless the contract was notarized it is pretty meaningless.
Follow Mothering