Mothering › Mothering Discussion Forums › Parenting › Life as a Parent › Single Parenting › Husband left--but now will try again?
New Posts  All Forums:
 

Husband left--but now will try again?

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 

I'm new here, although I've been a lurker for about a year. I'm looking for advice.

 

Last week, my husband of two years, partner of five years, told me he was leaving. We have a 4 year old and a baby. My husband left the house screaming at me that he hated me, called his parents to say our marriage was over, and then told me all this over the phone. He has, apparently, been miserable for months and has been planning a future without me. While our marriage has been very rocky for the last year, it did seem like things had settled down. He has stopped smashing in the walls and doors when he gets angry (and I do mean literally smashing), and we have not had big blow-up arguments for a long time. He says that he has been detaching himself emotionally for months. He also blames all of his unhappiness and depression on me and on our relationship--which is frustrating and unfair, because there are many external factors (him not being able to get a  job in his field after many years studying; his alcohol problem; the very pronounced financial difficulties we've had for the last two years; us being far from our family support systems; etc.). He says that things have been really bad for four years--ie, most of our relationship--and that he has a lot of anger towards me for the way our relationship has been. I am not being naive but I genuinely don't know what he's angry about. He won't say.

 

After huge amounts of begging on my part he finally agreed that we could try "one last time" to make this work. We have just started in therapy, and he has just been to his own therapist for the first time in 18 months (I have been begging him to go for about a year now). He does sound committed to trying to make it work--although I know from an email I saw (oops) that he had told his parents that it was a question of when, not if, our marriage ended. He wrote this after he'd repeatedly promised me otherwise.

 

At this stage, I'm trying hard to believe that we can save this. I love him, despite the hurt, anger, and betrayal I'm feeling, and I don't believe we've tried hard enough for long enough. But I'm finding it hard to trust that he won't just walk out again. I'm really just waiting for him to say, once more, that he's had enough. Moreover, separating would be exceedingly complicated in terms of the kids and custody, as neither he nor I share the same citizenship (and neither of us are citizens here, although we are here legally.) I can't help but think he's changed his mind because he doesn't want to lose the kids, which doesn't necessarily bode well for us changing our relationship and its dynamics.

 

My questions are these. 1) I think he's already made up his mind to leave, even though he's now said he's committed to trying again. Can marriages really come back from someone having decided to leave and then changed their mind? 2) Any suggestions for how to get through the fear and lack of trust I have right now, so that maybe our marriage might stand a chance of repair? Thanks!

 

[I do know that my problems might seem small, as he hasn't, in fact, left. But right now this all feels huge, and I'm trying to a) get through the day-to-day so I can care for my children even as I work full-time (agh!) and b) protect myself and my kids.]

post #2 of 6

I can tell you may situation. STBX left 2 years ago. Completely out of the blue. He said he had been unhappy for a while. After three months of separation he agreed to try again. We started spending time together alone and as a family on the weekend. This went on for about a year. We were talking about moving back in together and looking at houses (he had been living at his parents during this whole time). Then he went told me he still needed some time and space. I think this was when he met his GF to be honest. Anyway, it didn't work for us, but then I think he never really tried. BUT on the up side, I am now dating a seriously wonderful man who is everything I've ever wanted. I am so glad that STBX left and I'm glad it played out the way it did because I know that I did everything I could to make my marriage work and to try and keep my family intact for my kids.

 

Oh, and my boys were 4yo and 15mo when STBX left.

 

If you have any questions, feel free to ask.

post #3 of 6

No words of advice just hugs.

post #4 of 6

I want to recommend a book called Uncoupling.  I don't know the author, but it is a very good explanation of the process people go through, and gives lots of reasons why it's unlikely that your attempts to save your marriage will work.  Likely they will prolong a process that would be easier if it was kept as short as possible. I'm so sorry.  It sounds certain that your DH has made up his mind about ending your marriage and already moved on in his vision for himself.  Now you have no choice but to catch up to where he is at and get to a place where you are ready to be done with your marriage, too.

 

I hate to say that - believe me.  I was blindsided when my XH wanted divorce and I'm still trying to "catch up" (8 months later).  But I know I don't want to be married to anyone who doesn't want to be married to me.  And once a girlfriend entered the picture - just a couple of weeks after he told me he wanted a divorce - that was a dealbreaker, for me.  Does your DH have a girlfriend or past issues of infidelity?  Honestly, mine was unfaithful years ago and our marriage never fully recovered from the fear and betrayal, even though at the time we both committed to moving past it.
 

Your problems do not sound 'small' (insignificant) to me.  I asked my XH to stay for six months while we sorted things out, and that time helped me make a gradual transition to single motherhood instead of an abrupt one.  But with your DH's rage, anger, substance abuse issues, depression, etc, that doesn't sound like a good idea in your case.  It sounds like you tolerate a lot of crap from him that nobody should have to tolerate.  I know that doesn't make it easy to think about changing your life with a broken marriage, but you are worth a life free of that kind of treatment, in any case.

 

Do you have a counselor for yourself?  If you don't, I hope you will find one who can help you sort out how to navigate whatever lies ahead (while being as fair to yourself and kids, and healthy, as possible).  I found a good one for myself by calling the local women's crisis center - they know which counselors are experienced with this sort of situation.

 

{{{{{hugs}}}}}}  Hang in there.  It will be horrible, as I'm sure it already is, but it will also get better in time, and it is worth it.

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by MumAbroad View Post

 

My questions are these. 1) I think he's already made up his mind to leave, even though he's now said he's committed to trying again. Can marriages really come back from someone having decided to leave and then changed their mind? 2) Any suggestions for how to get through the fear and lack of trust I have right now, so that maybe our marriage might stand a chance of repair? Thanks!

 

[I do know that my problems might seem small, as he hasn't, in fact, left. But right now this all feels huge, and I'm trying to a) get through the day-to-day so I can care for my children even as I work full-time (agh!) and b) protect myself and my kids.]



 

post #5 of 6

I'm sorry. This is so painful.

 

Don't have a lot of time at the moment so I'm afraid what I'm about to say won't be as diplomatic as it ought to be:

 

I do think your husband has already made up his mind to leave. I've seen many similar situations. My guess is he's telling you he'll try again to either help ease his guilt, or because he thinks you'll get the message better if he says what he's been saying in the therapy setting.

 

Sounds to me like a separation would be best. Honestly I think that has more hope of "saving" the marriage than trying again does at this point.

post #6 of 6
Thread Starter 

Thank you all for your kind, thoughtful, and honest words. Really. I agree that it really doesn't seem promising for us. The fact that he has made up his mind to leave, even if he has now apparently changed his mind, doesn't bode well for the future. I can't really believe that all the things that made him prepared to leave in the first place are really going to change enough for him to stay in the long-term.

 

That said, I can't imagine telling him that we should separate now that he's agreed to try (and I had begged!). He insists that he is fully committed to making this work. Obviously I find this hard to believe...! But that is what he has said repeatedly. For all that it might be foolish, it seems stupid not to try. I love him, and hadn't seen this coming, for all that I knew there were things we needed to work on. I'm just so sad that we have got here.

 

Moreover, I said before that child custody would be difficult, and there is this to think about, too. If we separate, I'm pretty sure he'd want shared custody. However, if we separate he can't stay here (the US), as he's here as my dependent, officially. We can't go to his home country because I have no status there--and while we had actually been planning to move there in January, I think it would be a very bad idea for us to move there now (because I wouldn't be able to work for at least 6 months, would be dependent upon him financially etc, and would have limited support networks). We could go to my home country, as he could get citizenship through his mother, but even then it would be a huge and costly upheaval, and it would carry its own complications. All of which is to say that it is probably better for our children if we try to the bitter end to make our marriage work, even though I would not usually say that in other circumstances. Things are strangely settled right now, and are actually much calmer than they had been a few months ago, so at least the boys have some stability.

 

Your questions: I'm pretty sure my DH doesn't have a girlfriend. I do have a counselor of my own, and I have started seeing her again about this. She is wonderful. I'll also check out the book suggestion: thanks.

 

I feel strangely detached from my emotions in all this. I had felt devastated; right now, I feel rather numb. It's all I think about, and I really, really don't want us to separate. At the same time, it feels peculiar to want to live with someone who has so much anger about me and so much sadness about our marriage. So it goes!

 

Thanks again: it's a huge help to hear your input and have your support.

New Posts  All Forums:
 
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Single Parenting
Mothering › Mothering Discussion Forums › Parenting › Life as a Parent › Single Parenting › Husband left--but now will try again?