Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Life as a Parent › Single Parenting › What would you do if the best thing for one child was worst for other?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

What would you do if the best thing for one child was worst for other?

post #1 of 8
Thread Starter 
DS is 5 and DD is 2. I have 50/50 join custody of DS and DD is from my current relationship.
DS has been in counseling for a long time now and he is violent toward his sister, completely defiant, destructive of household property. I feel like some of this stems from the fact that at his father's house he has no rules, expectations, etc. If he disobeys he is essentially bribed with a new toy, video game, etc. At my home, there are clear exectations, rules and while I provide for my children's needs, I absolutely refuse to be materialistic like his father. My children get new toys maybe once a year. Toys that are meaningfl and last. We don't do video games or TV. Anyway, i feel like his dad is a huge contributing factor. I have NO chance at getting full custody. XH got joint custody even with an active dvo for abusing me. My city is fathers rights to EXCESS. I am unemployed, and due to bad circumstances have moved numerous times in my son's life. I fully recognize this probaly contributes to his behavior but I am becoming more stable. He has worked the same job for years, never moved, and makes good money.
So this is very badly affecting my daughter. She is a very easygoing and rarely cries when her brother isn't home. The minute he comes home, he is constantly hurting her (even with constant supervision) and she is constantly in distress. As soon as he leaves, she is at ease again.
I have been struggling for weeks with this. I do not feel like it is in my daughters best interest to be around her brother at this point. It is also exceptionally taxing on dp and I. However, I feel like if I let DS' dad have him more often (but him still coming to my house) it mightmake matters worse.
I am at a complete loss. The therapist does agree that two households is causing ds considerable stress, but cant ofer a solution.
Any ideas?
post #2 of 8

Don't do it.  Holy heck I was just talking about this with my brother.  Same situation when we were growing up.  My mom basically let my dad have him completely because of all the problems.  Dad was abusive brother became abusive.  However he's grown up and no longer speaks to our mother because he felt she abandoned him and picked her new life over him.  Dad was abusive to him as well and the hard part was she still picked her new life over my brother.  If your XH was abusive towards you, you may be the only one to know if/when he's abusive towards your son. 

post #3 of 8

At the risk of maybe sounding obvious...a friend was recently telling me that her older brother always resented her because he felt like she had caused the parents to divorce (slightly different situation than yours, but the feelings might be similar), and that the parents didn't do much to help him. Maybe what he needs is some time with just you? It sounds like a vicious cycle where he acts out and beats on his sister (something kids do to smaller kids when someone is bullying them) and gets reprimanded, and then probably feels even worse...I'm sure you know this. Can you arrange any babysitting for your daughter so that you get some quality alone time with your son to just hang out and show him he is special, even just a couple of hours? It might go a long way to really focus on the positive with him for a while. 

 

 

post #4 of 8

it does sound like a very difficult situation for all involved, but I have to agree it wouldn't be worse for your son to spend more time with his dad.

post #5 of 8

Mama- I think about this all the time. My son is violent with my dd and I just think maybe they need to live seperate- I can't seem to control my 8yo son.... You are not alone but I don't think you should give him to his dad more- I think you should continue in counseling.

post #6 of 8

I think you need to figure out what is best for the greater good of the whole. My brother who is now 15 has always had behavioral problems. He was the youngest until he was 7 or 8 and then when my youngest brother and sister were born he started lashing out towards them as well. He still does it at 15. It's something that my mom said would "get better" and it never has. She now has a very strained relationship with him and resents him most of the time. He has caused problems with her current husband because of his actions with their kids together, the way he treats the people around him, etc.

 

This is a tough spot for you to be in. It would break my heart to watch my dd go through that knowing that if it doesn't stop it will only get worse with age. The problem seems to be with his father, but since you can't control that, what else can you do? How long are you willing to allow this to happen? (not saying your not trying to stop it, but how long is this okay until you do something different?) Have you talked to DS about it, about why he is that way? Is he acting out because he wants to live with his dad? Do you think compromising on your household rules would change the behavior? I know that sounds like a bribe, but your poor DD.. something has got to give somewhere. It sounds like there's nothing you can do to stop the way the dad acts/responds, so what can you do to help the situation?

post #7 of 8

Giving up on him, sorry but that's what it seems would happen if she gave dad more time is the worst you can do.  Their actions and behaviors are things that they themselves don't always understand.  How to behave in a manner that is respectful to all is something we as parents need to help our kids with. 

post #8 of 8

My brother beat me from the time I was very young and my parents always blamed me for it.

He was uncontrollable. Now I have a son with a very similar temperment.

It makes me crazy to watch them fight and my son to mistreat his sister. We have a no tolerance policy but it just does not seem to work. He calls her names makes fun of her and hits her.  He thinks he is like the dad at our house and he is not!!!  He is 8. I am terrified about what will happen if he does not get better.

But honestly- It has got better.

He needs a lot of attention from me and will do whatever it takes to get me to pay attention. Which I struggle with.( I have add) So paying attention I get distracted etc.

So this week I am working on attention for my kids where I am not on computer- we are not watching tv. we are just together.

 

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Single Parenting
Mothering › Forums › Parenting › Life as a Parent › Single Parenting › What would you do if the best thing for one child was worst for other?