Some friends of mine were talking about "painful experiences"; one of them said that he once had minor surgery without any kind of anesthetic. I then said "lots of American males (but luckily not me) have"; it took him a minute to figure out what I was talking about (circumcision). It seems that circ is so regular that many don't even consider it surgery.
Related Forum Threads
- What do they teach in Medical School? Last post on Today at 4:26 am in Circumcision
- Wife went and got son cut.. Last post on 5/21/13 at 6:59pm in Circumcision
- J Kellogg and his little-known alternative to stop boys from 'self-abuse'. This is not... Last post on 5/15/13 at 8:10pm in Circumcision
- Uncircumcised infant Last post on 5/6/13 at 8:43pm in Circumcision
- I have to say... Last post on Yesterday at 7:45 pm in Circumcision
Protect Your Uncircumcised Son: Expert Medical Advice for Parents
Edited on 11/2/12
- Cutting KidsEdited on 9/21/12
- Marilyn Milos Discusses Circumcision
Discussion with friends - brought up painful experiences and circpost #1 of 82/22/12 at 12:20pmThread Starterpost #2 of 83/3/12 at 5:05am
You are correct that in North American culture circumcision is not considered surgery, or painful, or as having any long term ramifications. How bizarre is that line of thinking? A few weeks ago, I had an interesting conversation with a woman who makes her living as both a therapist and a birth educator. We were discussing how, and to what extent, do early traumatic life experiences affect one's brain. She related how her daughter had required an intravenous needle at the age of 7 months, and the nurse was having so much trouble finding a suitable vein that she ended up putting the needle in the baby's scalp. Fast forward to age 17, and the girl is getting an intravenous needle and suffers a panic attack. The nurse asked her if she had had a bad experience in the past. She replied that she had never had an intravenous before. So you see, although she did not consciously remember the first one, her brain sure did. This lady stated that every experience from birth, and even before, leaves a trace on our brain.post #3 of 83/3/12 at 8:34pm
Scalp IVs are very, very common for young children. In fact, they are often a preferred place for IVs in newborns. There are fewer nerve endings in the scalp (as opposed to other areas such as the hand) so it should be less painful during insertion and they get bumped less after insertion. Scalp veins are often more visable than peripheral ones, so they are more likely to be successful on the first try--thus eliminating other needle sticks. Also, because the IVs are not exposed to the movement of joints (such as those in a wrist or ankle) they tend to last longer than other sites.
I've seen lots of people who are scared of having an IV inserted, or having blood drawn, or having a pap smear, or of getting an EKG, or any other of a myriad of health-related discomforts. It isn't necessarily because they have some psychic remembrance of the event happening before, it is because they have heard stories, or they realize that sharp things inflict pain, or they are anxious about the healthcare environment, or they are nervous about the results.
I don't support circs, but it's not because I think the babies will remember it.post #4 of 83/4/12 at 6:24amQuote:
Are you aware of the study (not sure it was a study, but I'll call it that because I think it was a study studying something else) that was done that found that boys who'd had been circ'd had a bigger negative response to vaccinations (not sure of the details, as it's been a long time since I read about it)? What do you think babies remember?
Suspost #5 of 83/4/12 at 8:14am
Also of interest, and related, is: www.cirp.org/library/psych/ which also references quite a large number of papers, one of the most interesting of which is: www.norm_uk.org/circumcision_psychological_effects.htmlpost #6 of 83/4/12 at 8:23am
Let's try the last one again: www.norm-uk.org/circumcision_psychological_effects.html written by Janet Menage.post #7 of 83/4/12 at 9:22am
The 15 year old study you are referencing used two methods of pain relief for circumcision--one, nothing, and two, a topical cream (EMLA). In their study, they found that EMLA cream did not seem to make a difference in later pain response vs. using nothing for pain relief. However, the study really is not all that applicable because most circumcisions performed on infants today (at least in my area of the country) do not use either of those pain control methods and the study authors even state that the pain relief offered to infants in the study was possibly insufficient. There is better pain control available today.
What I have seen used in a combination of dorsal penile nerve block, sucrose and pacifier sucking during the procedure, and Tylenol and liberal breastfeeding afterwards. The authors of the study you cited state, "Insufficient afferent blockade during circumcision and the days that follow surgery may have contributed to central sensitisation in both treated and untreated circumcision groups. Study of the vaccination pain response of infants who had received more effective circumcision pain management (ie, dorsal penile nerve block and adequate postoperative pain management) would be interesting."
So, while the study you cited sparks interesting ideas, it really needs to be updated and used to investigate later pain response when more effective pain relief is used during the circumcision procedure. Following their study results, it seems to be logical that more effective pain relief at the time of circumcision would mean less of a negative response at a later time.post #8 of 83/4/12 at 11:12am
Or we could just stop cutting boys and then we wouldn't need to re-do the study or any other research
Anyway, there have been recent studies that show very little drs follow the AAP guidelines for pain management for circumcision.
- Discussion with friends - brought up painful experiences and circ
- Cutting Kids
- › What do they teach in Medical School? 11 seconds ago
- › Queer, Pregnant, & Parenting - April & May 2013! 1 minute ago
- › Look how cute the May 2013 DDC babies are! 5 minutes ago
- › Belly pic threads on breastfeeding forum? 6 minutes ago
- › Anybody here planning a homebirth? 6 minutes ago
- › What is a Clean Penis? 10 minutes ago
- › starting Kindergarten 18 minutes ago
- › 52 Project Challenge, 2013 19 minutes ago
- › A Saner TTC-The Pink Moon 22 minutes ago
- › ~+~+~+~+~ May 2013 Chat *~*~*~*~* 26 minutes ago
- › Lansinoh 20265 Disposable Nursing Pads, 60-pack by KaliShanti
- › Boppy Nursing Pillow with Slipcover by earobb
- › Medela Nightime Nursing Sleep Bra by earobb
- › Motherhood Wireless Full Coverage Nursing Bra by earobb
- › NUK Ultra Thin Nursing Pads, 60 Pack by earobb
- › The First Years Breastflow BPA Free Bottle, 5 Ounce by KaliShanti
- › Simple Wishes Hands-Free Breastpump Bra, XS/S/M by KaliShanti
- › Seal N Go Breast Milk Freezer Disposable Liners - 25 / Pack by KaliShanti
- › Medela Quick Clean Micro-Steam Bags by KaliShanti
- › Lansinoh 20435 Breastmilk Storage Bags, 25-Count Boxes (Pack of 3) by KaliShanti
- › My Heart Growing Fonder by Melanie Mayo
- › Happy Simple Baby Love by Melanie Mayo
- › Buying Pot for my 11-Year-Old by momofnatasha
- › Making the Grade by Melanie Mayo
- › Homeopathy -- A Lifesaver For Your Summer... by Melanie Mayo
- › Relax. Parenting Is Supposed to Be Messy,... by Brian Leaf
- › Managing Mom Stress: Sharing Tips and Trying... by Melanie Mayo
- › Who Wants to Sleep Alone? by Cynthia Mosher
- › Should I Train My Child....Like a Dog?! by Sarah Clark
- › Mothering Articles by Melanie Mayo