- topicVaccinationstagged by System, 5/2/12
Related Forum Threads
- Heidi Stevenson has passed away Last post on Yesterday at 12:14 pm in I'm Not Vaccinating
- Do you think Change is going to come to Canada? Last post on Yesterday at 7:59 am in I'm Not Vaccinating
- help..when partners disagree on vaxing Last post on Yesterday at 1:48 pm in I'm Not Vaccinating
- Autism Daily Newscast author is clueless about vaccine ingredients Last post on Today at 1:15 am in I'm Not Vaccinating
- Vaccines Are Not Money Makers Last post on 3/11/14 at 11:09am in I'm Not Vaccinating
My Vaccine Info
Last edited: 3/4/13
- Vaccinations: Why All the Fuss?Last edited: 12/26/13
- Resources for Non-vaccinating FamiliesLast edited: 1/18/13
- Frontline's War on Selectively Vaccinating ParentsLast edited: 3/14/13
- In Britain 12-Year-Olds Vaccinated Without Parental ConsentLast edited: 3/8/13
Vaccine Safety Curriculum for Medical Residents - American Academy of Pediatrics - Page 5post #82 of 2475/3/12 at 3:19pmQuote:Quote:
Except that the population did not increase 4 fold between 1920 and 1950, it went from 100 million to 150 million.
Yeah, I don't know about that. Post polio. I was just interested in the numbers of incidence instead a chart showing deaths.post #83 of 2475/3/12 at 3:20pmpost #84 of 2475/3/12 at 3:23pmpost #85 of 2475/3/12 at 3:36pmpost #86 of 2475/3/12 at 3:46pmFairly irrelevant for most diseases. People will still breathing and coughing and spitting and there was no Lysol.
I don't know why the increase, for sure, but I think it's not reasonable to think the vaccine had nothing to do with the sudden decrease, and more importantly with the fact that we have no polio in this country today.post #87 of 2475/3/12 at 3:54pmpost #88 of 2475/3/12 at 5:16pmpost #89 of 2475/3/12 at 5:26pmI thought he went off the rails after awhile, which is kind of typical for that website, but made some interesting points.
The thing is they did a randomized controlled double blind while nine yards study of the polio vaccine and it worked!
I have a hard time with things that deny the whole germ theory of illness and substitute it with toxins and nutrition. I think toxins and nutrition are important, but I just don't think we've had the science that wrong all these years.post #90 of 2475/3/12 at 6:27pmpost #91 of 2475/3/12 at 7:12pm
Rachel, I suspect you are using the words "conspiracy theory" in an attempt to discredit posters (non-vaxxers). As you have said elsewhere, let it be about the ideas, not the people. Conspiracy theory is a slur deliberately used by some pro-vaxxers to dismiss non-vaxxers, and I don't think it has any place in a discussion.
Moreover, I read Taxi's post and she did not say "that there is a conspiracy to conceal cases of vaccine preventable diseases by calling them something else." (your words). She said that the diagnosis of polio changed and made it difficult to ascertain the real numbers of polio. Heck, you said something very similar last week on autism - that diagnostic change could make it seems like there were more cases than there were. You cannot have it both ways. Diagnostic change - particularly if it happens at the same time a vax is introduced, is relevant when we are looking at numbers.post #92 of 2475/3/12 at 7:15pmI may have misinterpreted her post. I interpreted it to mean she was saying the polio rate fell because we just call polio something else now (a theory I've seen plenty of places, but may have wrongly attributed here). That is in fact a conspiracy theory. Sorry, but words mean what they mean. If I wanted to discredit her I would have called her a conspiracy theorist.post #93 of 2475/3/12 at 7:17pmAnd I have already acknowledged (three or four times now) the diagnostic change probably played a role, but unless someone can show me some numbers that say we have 30-40k more of those other diseases being diagnosed now than then, or that they suddenly went up in 56-60, I don't think you can use that to justify the entire drop (or even most of it), and you certainly can't use it to justify the fact that the polio rate is now ZERO. That is thanks to the vaccine!post #94 of 2475/3/12 at 7:25pmpost #95 of 2475/3/12 at 7:27pmpost #96 of 2475/3/12 at 7:44pmQuote:Originally Posted by Rrrrrachel
And I have already acknowledged (three or four times now) the diagnostic change probably played a role, but unless someone can show me some numbers that say we have 30-40k more of those other diseases being diagnosed now than then, or that they suddenly went up in 56-60, I don't think you can use that to justify the entire drop (or even most of it), and you certainly can't use it to justify the fact that the polio rate is now ZERO. That is thanks to the vaccine!
I am not trying to justify it.
I was trying to point out that Taximom did not say anything conspiracy-like and that what you were saying was inflammatory.
On topic: I do think vaccines played a role in the reduction of polio.
Some vaccines helped lower the chances of some diseases - and some diseases are scary and some are not. Really, if I could discount the possibility of vaccine reactions, the selective and delayed crowd has it right in my book.
Back to the OP - I scanned the initial link. I am not sure what to think of it. It look like "arguing with parents 101". It is not the model of health care I like, or seek out. I want a doctor who can answer my questions, give me lots of info, and does not pressure me to do something I am uncomfortable with.post #97 of 2475/3/12 at 7:48pmpost #98 of 2475/3/12 at 7:55pmQuote:Originally Posted by Rrrrrachel
It is a conspiracy theory, you can take it as pejorative if you want, but that's what it is. It's a theory that there is a conspiracy to conceal cases of vaccine preventable diseases by calling them something else. It's not worth responding to further, because the nature of conspiracy theories is that all evidence to the contrary is part of the conspiracy.
There is a lab test that can distinguish between polio related afp and non polio afp, by the way. I learned that when I was doing some reading as a result of the thread about India.
By your definition, pointing out that Merck buried negative evidence and distorted the safety/efficacy trials of Vioxx would actually be a conspiracy theory.
Furthermore, your asserting that "the nature of the conspiracy theory is that all evidence to the contrary is part of the conspiracy" is just a nasty little logic game. Whoever comes up with that definition first traps the opponent, because no matter what the truth is, there is no way out. It's like going first in TicTacToe. It would be like saying, "You're a liar, and I can prove it because if you say you are not, you are lying and therefore proving my point."
Sorry, we're not buying that garbage here.
As for the lab test for polio, that was my point--the test was not used after widespread introduction of the polio vaccine, because all cases in those who were vaccinated were assumed to be something other than polio, and all cases in those who were not vaccinated were assumed to be polio.post #99 of 2475/3/12 at 7:57pmpost #100 of 2475/3/12 at 7:59pm
- Vaccinations: Why All the Fuss?
- › ~*~ The TTC ONE Thread~*~ March 2014 5 minutes ago
- › Libido and Pregnancy 16 minutes ago
- › Anyone else have a kid who just wont keep their hands to themselves? 23 minutes ago
- › Christian moms March '14 32 minutes ago
- › General Chat 49 minutes ago
- › Retractable 8y.o. Does he need to dry it?? 54 minutes ago
- › 2014 Project challenge 52 weeks 52 projects 55 minutes ago
- › March Chat/Vent 1 hour ago
- › Queer, Pregnant & Parenting January, February & March 2014 1 hour, 21 minutes ago
- › Any reason not to do the hearing test? 1 hour, 28 minutes ago
- › Vaccine: The Controversial Story of Medicine's Greatest Lifesaver by ss834
- › Pyur Diaper Balm by MimiPilla
- › Burt's Bees Mama Bee Belly Balm, Fragrance Free, by KatelynRose
- › Summer Infant Best View Handheld Color Video Monitor with 2.5"... by thebessmartinfo
- › Happy Heiny's One Size Cloth Diapers by SquirmyWorm
- › Homesteader's Kitchen, The: Recipes from Farm to Table by Monica S
- › Rainbow Light Just Once Prenatal One Multivitamin, 90 Tablets by glwilson22
- › Bear Stays Up for Christmas by rosemarievpaulson
- › The Night Before Christmas by rjdoghouse
- › The Polar Express by sassyfirechick
- › The Debate Over Handheld Devices for Babies... by Marcy Axness
- › Preparing your Child to Attend a... by OliviaHinebaugh
- › Am I A Bad Mother or Has Africa Run Out of... by BrainChild
- › Your Two-Year-Old Knows Squatting is Better by Melanie Mayo
- › Okay to Leave Kids in the Car While Popping... by Melanie Mayo
- › Laundry Zen by Laura Grace Weldon
- › High Needs Mother by BrainChild
- › Homebirth Forum Guidelines by Cynthia Mosher
- › Disclaimer by Cynthia Mosher
- › Does Siri Thwart Social Intelligence? by Melanie Mayo