She's a child with limited life experience. She stereotyped that all African Americans have a voice she doesn't like and her mom pointed out an individual that doesn't fit her stereotype. What exactly is your problem with all of this?
- topicHomeschoolingtagged by System, 6/8/12
Related Forum Threads
- Leave Kindergarten mid-year to begin Homeschooling? Last post on Yesterday at 6:55 pm in Learning at Home and Beyond
- But my kids *like* public school. Last post on Yesterday at 10:32 am in Learning at Home and Beyond
- how to find speech therapy Last post on 11/30/13 at 5:44am in Learning at Home and Beyond
- 600-square-foot apartment Last post on 12/3/13 at 6:18am in Learning at Home and Beyond
- Homeschoolers please help me! New baby and homeschooling Last post on 12/2/13 at 3:01pm in Learning at Home and Beyond
Getting Started With Homeschooling
Last edited: 9/24/13
- Our Child's Education: Our Decision To Make, Not YoursLast edited: 8/21/13
- Sustainable Style for Back to School: The Ultimate Guide to Green...Last edited: 8/13/13
- Pens, Pencils and Highlighters Oh My! 6 Eco Options for Back to SchoolLast edited: 8/6/13
- Sustainable, Stylish Notebooks and Binders for Back to SchoolLast edited: 8/6/13
teaching acceptance for diversity - Page 2
Poll Results: Do you meet diverse people in your daily life?
19 Total Votespost #21 of 396/9/12 at 11:15ampost #22 of 396/9/12 at 11:30am
26% (5)We live in a homogenous area, and our own social / homeschooling circle is also homogenous
26% (5)We live in a homogenous area, but our own social / homeschooling circle is more diverse than average for our area.
21% (4)We live in a diverse area and our own social / homeschooling is fairly diverse.
26% (5)We live in a diverse area but our own social / homeschooling is not very diverse.
Yeah, I really think the mother was just identifying remarks born of privilege, I really think, reading her post, that its hard to accuse her of not taking this seriously.
I do think though, having a relatively homogenous circle is an occupational hazard of homeschooling, at least round here. We've done what we can to minimise it, eg sending our kids to a very diverse kindergarten to age 7 before homeschooling. What I think is so important is that kids see other skin colors/cultures as very normal, and as people first and foremost with exactly the same range of needs (eg to often just be quietly accepted) as everyone else-and also that one single person is not a representative of,say, all Africans (its a BIG place!) but one of many people from an enormous, hugely diverse area. But tbh I think its one of the big issues, that kids can actually grow up in a fairly diverse area and yet never have to rub along with everyone. Personally I believe its really important to take steps to mitigate the effects of this, and furthermore I think this needs to be by speaking with people as people, we adults often need to overcome any shyness and get on with it here, I think. I think its far more important to connect with actual people than to learn about them from books, or to have any kind of formal discussion about the importance of equality. I dunno, I think showing kids not to have preconceptions about others is one of the most useful life skills they can have, and I do think sometimes we don't place as much priority on it as we might.
What I'm trying to say I guess is that we need to teach our kids that people with different coloured skin to us are not necessarily different. Skin colour is a really rubbish indicator of whether someone is like you or not, and its really really not a good way of telling whether you are going to get on with them.
Edited by Fillyjonk - 6/9/12 at 11:41ampost #23 of 396/9/12 at 11:32am
The phrase "white privilege" comes from race theory and has a very particular meaning that does not imply that the privileged individual is "above" others. In fact, it doesn't really refer to the individual at all. It is a societal phenomenon. According to Wikipedia White privilege may be defined as the "unearned advantages of being White in a racially stratified society."post #24 of 396/9/12 at 11:40ampost #25 of 396/9/12 at 12:44pmQuote:Yeah, I really think the mother was just identifying remarks born of privilege, I really think, reading her post, that its hard to accuse her of not taking this seriously.
to be clear- I for one did not accuse the mother of not taking this seriously nor did I use the term "white" privilege and in fact there are other forms of privilege regarding prejudice, stereotyping and racismpost #26 of 396/9/12 at 1:16pmQuote:Quote:
No, you didn't accuse her of not taking it seriously, but you clearly took great offence at what she said. A number of readers, myself included, are having difficulty understanding the nature of the offensiveness in that statement. If you construed some other meaning for the word privilege, I'm not getting it, and it's very likely that the original poster didn't intend whatever meaning it is that you have read in.
Mirandapost #27 of 396/9/12 at 1:18pm
This is interesting. We live in a very "white" area of the US. However, the few people that we know (or have run into) that are not white have been in the same/similar socio-economic class as us (or they seem to be). My oldest "discovered" black people when she was five, which I found odd because we knew/hung out with several families that had darker skin. I really don't think she noticed until then. She wasn't scared or weirded out though. Our actual coversation was like this:
dd: "wow, did you know there are black people?"
me: "people come in many different shades"
dd: "have you ever seen a white person?"
me: "honey, we ARE white"
dd: "no we aren't. . . this is white" (she held up paper)
me: "well we are called white"
dd: "that is dumb"
Then we went to the library and found a good book with lots of pictures of children from everywhere. My dd was a bit dismayed to find out that most of the people that were called black, were actually brown. I guess to her, it was like us being "white." She didn't find it a very accurate term. I am assuming that she heard the term somewhere else, because I rarely use a color word to describe someone. I would usually say, darker skin or lighter skin or whatever. I am not good at getting the correct ethnicity and don't want to screw that up. While living in Boston, there were many families that came originally from Haiti. I was told that they don't want to be called "African Americans", yet I couldn't really tell the difference. Also, there were so many blended families. So I took my lead from a wonderful African American person and just used darker/lighter to describe people. Hopefully it doesn't offend.
My kids seem to be wary of homeless people, people who appear drunk, people who are missing a bunch of teeth, etc. In our community, most these people are also white. They are also wary of people who are "in your face" or "too complimentary" or whatever. This crosses all races and class structure. My kids are more reserved I guess. I imagine though, if the only darker people they met were drunk or high, that they may associate the two. I know that in college, there was someone from a country (foreign exchange) that I don't recall now. He was so rude to me, wouldn't let me help him in the computer lab, etc. that I know I started to think poorly of his background. It was explained to me that in his culture, womem have a different roll. I understood that, but it still irked me that he couldn't TRY to accept our culture while he was here. After that, I was automatically wary of others that I thought were from his country. It took me time to get over it. I guess my point is that a first impression (whether or not accurate) can really make an impact. I think some of our children may have first impressions that we aren't aware of and that they may make associations based on it.
Amypost #28 of 396/9/12 at 2:11pm
Privilege (social inequality)
IF you are on par-or feel equal too you would not cling to and or take comfort in privilege you perceive to have-why would you?
here is some on social privilege - http://www.mssresearch.org/?q=Structural_Definition_of_Social_Privilege
if you think of yourself in the context of description of the OP what other type of privilege could be ment? the child feels secure in her privileged life-IMO
I mustn't be the only one here!Quote:Yeah, I really think the mother was just identifying remarks born of privilege,
so do I
clinging to the comfort of being privileged
if you would not understand how the statement sounds how would you be open to understanding what how remarks like this make others feel?post #29 of 396/9/12 at 2:55pmQuote:
I am confused. This is what I am hearing:
You think the daughter (a child) is racist and you are ticked at the mother because she must have learned it from the parents. Am I correct?
In any event, I think the issue is serious, but not one the mother needs to be taken to task for.
I think it is pretty common for people to jump to conclusions about groups of people, particularly if they have little experience with others. It is something we need to guard against, discuss, actively work on, etc… I think moms who come here looking for information on how to help their children be more inclusive need support, not judgement.
As per what to do….I think gradually building up exposure is the way to go. I agree that I would not want playdates and the like to become contrived - she really should play with whomever she wants.
I might start with outside the home activities. One idea might be to try and look for an activity she likes in a diverse neighbourhood. It would be good if many of the people were starting new - so she did not feel odd one out. Swim lesson or summer reading clubs might be good bets for summer. Hopefully she will meet a few people that are different from her and it will stretch her a bit!
Edited by purslaine - 6/9/12 at 3:11pmpost #30 of 396/9/12 at 4:17pmQuote:
And that's exactly how children learn about EVERYTHING. They drop one thing it falls. They drop another and notice a pattern. They assume everything falls when they let go. Then they let go of a helium balloon and notice it does something different. Or they notice girls wear pink and then assume someone wearing pink is a girl. It doesn't mean they are sexist or racist or gravitist.post #31 of 396/9/12 at 4:50pmQuote:
Then they let go of a helium balloon and notice it does something different. Or they notice girls wear pink and then assume someone wearing pink is a girl. It doesn't mean they are sexist or racist or gravitist.
In general (not directed at any one poster)
I am not comfortable calling a child sexist or racist. I think they can make racist or sexist comments, but to actually be racist or sexist? I am not sure that is a label I would pin on a child who is still in the process of sorting things out.post #32 of 396/9/12 at 7:14pm
I found an interesting article that talks about this-- the article is not specifically for the LW, because it is targeted towards white parents trying to teach their kids not to see white as "normal" and everything else as "minority", however I thought this was a helpful quote:Quote:What do I do if my child says something racist? What will others think of me? Will they look over at me, knowing what a horrible mother I am, because my son just came out with something funky about that woman’s hair, her skin, the way she talks? What will people say?This is a big one. A really big one. As soon as we encourage our children to reflect on the world around them, to say what they are thinking and feeling and to invite conversation, well, they start to talk. And they will say things just about everywhere. And in front of just about everyone. And they will ask questions. Why is your hair like that? Did you notice that your skin is really dark? Wow, look, my mom’s arm is really white next to your arm! How come all the Black kids play basketball? Did you know that your grandfather was probably a slave? Your kids will say things that are beyond what you could possibly imagine. And they should say those things. Because this is how they learn. But they are only going to learn if you are open to hearing them. Which means knowing your own s---. Here is what we mean by that: What is going on for you when you hear your kids say something that triggers your “that’s racist” button? What emotions come up? What are you concerned about? What do you do when those emotions come up? We have all seen parents, when reacting to something their child has said, looking quickly around and saying, “shhhh, that’s not a nice thing to say,” or “Stop that! Don’t be rude!!” or any number of other things. We know the feeling in our bellies when we are walking through the world, thinking about our grocery list or the drive back home, when junior says something that immediately makes us feel exposed and visible. As white people. As potentially bad parents. Raising our children to be white is about knowing our reactions and finding ways to NOT shut our children down when they ask those kinds of questions.
The rest of the article is here: http://loveisntenough.com/2011/07/20/white-noise-white-adults-raising-white-children-to-resist-white-supremacy-2/ and it's definitely worth reading, but I highlighted that quote because it touches on why it's hard to talk to kids about race-- they're going to blurt out things that aren't right, and we need to not freak out about it, because all that will do is teach them to keep their opinions to themselves, and then we don't know what we need to teach them.
Clarification: When she says "raising our kids to be white" what she means is raising them to realize that we all have a "color"-- it's not that other people are "colored" and are discriminated against, we all have a race, and it impacts our interactions.
Edited by onatightrope - 6/9/12 at 7:24pmpost #33 of 396/10/12 at 4:40am
Back to the OP, I think what is at issue is more a reaction to being uncomfortable around a different culture than a racial one. I grew up in the American south and was immersed with lots of different races early on. What I found was that not all people of one race have the same culture. Those with cultures/backgrounds similar to mine were easy to get along with; those that were not were difficult because we had very little common experience and lots of cultural-based misunderstandings. I well-remember wishing at age 5 that I could have a classroom of just people that talked and acted like I did because, quite frankly, I could not understand the words used by many of the black children and they often took my things without asking or touched me when I did not want to be touched (this was part of their cultural upbringing). Not all were that way, and, as I said, I was good friends with those who were more in-line with my own culture. Now that I live up north, the African-American culture up here that we interact with is very different and there is less of a cultural divide unless you are in the inner city. I think it's biological and even beneficial to recognize when other people or cultures make you feel uncomfortable. For young children with limited life experience this is especially true. I wouldn't take what your daughter said as a value judgment of the personal worth of people so much as a frank statement that sometimes other people make us uncomfortable by the way they act, which is true for adults and children alike. I am as uncomfortable around uneducated white people as I am around black people who fit that same stereotype. I don't wish them ill, but I certainly don't enjoy interacting with them. I wouldn't worry this into the ground but rather say that when people talk or act differently from us it can feel uncomfortable, but not all people who look alike act alike. I would think this a good opportunity to examine how culture is made and passed down but also acknowledge that it's okay to dislike aspects of other cultures, because it is. I would also try and find out more of what prompted your daughter's feelings--is she having difficulty in a new social situation?--and help her find ways of coping with that.post #34 of 396/10/12 at 5:12am
ah, i'm wondering if I get what you're saying serenbat? I'm wondering if you are objecting to the idea that the OP's child has not actually had to face these issues, has not been educated about these issues? That is, without doubt, a luxury that those who identify as white have, because its an issue we can largely ignore.I totally agree that's a massive issue and it IS a luxury of privilege.
Especially given that the OP does not actually identify as white, and given that, despite our absolute best efforts, all our kids say things that make us stop in our tracks and go "WHERE did this come from?", I just don't think we should read anything into it about the kid's upbrigining. If the OP was on here defending her child's right to have these views, that would be different, but she's not, she's here scratching her head and trying to sort it out.
I do have an issue with parents who prefer to keep their (white) child innocent of prejudice in the belief that its not their problem, and in the belief that racist ideas won't percolate their bubble. They do and they will, but moreover, to not teach about racism, IMO, is to imply that that part of all our history wasn't really that significant and can just be easily brushes away. I think this thinking creates an idea that racism just isn't that important.I do feel though, that its got to be taught in the context of modelling seeing people as varied and interesting people. I think mechanistic anti-racist stuff, while absolutely better than nothing, is not that much better than nothing.
I'm also personally very uncomfortable with suggesting that any differences between "races" beyond obvious fairly minor physical ones are actually biological and so innate. I don't think we have any evidence at all for this, and I think this idea has been used incredibly destructively in the past. I agree that its probably natural for many of us to seek out those who are as like us as possible, because these people are most likely to understand us, but I think its learnt and prejudiced behaviour to assume skin colour is a good indicator of whether someone is "like us". I know, for example, that I click much better with anyone from the city I grew up in (which happens to be an incredibly culturally mixed area)-this is utterly regardless of skin colour, and what it really comes down to is that most Londoners have a certain shared sense of humour. I also think though, its important to model for kids that we need to reach out of our own comfort zones. Once you get chatting with others you do so often realise how alike you are, its a cliche but its true.
Edited by Fillyjonk - 6/10/12 at 5:25ampost #35 of 396/10/12 at 9:17amQuote:"WHERE did this come from?"
we don't know- but we do know that studies have shown children do learn stereotyping, etc and that from a very young age and family/society do play a roll in it
During childhood, our attitudes are molded directly and indirectly by the race, ethnicity, and status of the people around us (i.e. teachers and classmates, parents, colleagues and friends, salesclerks, doctors, nurses, waiters, house cleaners, construction workers, the unemployed, the homeless, etc.). By age twelve we have a complete set of stereotypes about every ethnic, racial, and religious group in our society.post #36 of 396/10/12 at 10:03amQuote:
Well, gee what DON'T children learn about other humans from family or society? Now you're acknowledging maybe everything isn't the parent's fault. Again, what's so offensive about the OP becoming aware of her daughter stereotyping and asking for advice on how to counteract this? So offensive you're compelled to reply that her post is too offensive to even give advice.post #37 of 396/10/12 at 10:16amQuote:
Actually, stereotyping (as in, having a simplified, standardized concept which one applies to a group of similar things) is a natural, albeit somewhat simplistic, organizational strategy of the child's developing mind. Prejudice (an unfavourable opinion formed beforehand) and racism (hatred based on racial prejudices) can evolve from stereotyping depending on social, parental and media influences and on how parents and others react to any negative stereotyping the child expresses.
It's a common myth that "children are colourblind." In fact even very young children are acutely aware of differences in skin colour and do tend to use skin colour and other simplistic cultural attributes as an organizational strategy in making sense of society. My sister Anna, who is black was raised in a white family and a predominantly white community, was at a park at about age 18 months when she started calling "Anna! Anna! Anna!" and pointing across the playground. There was another black child, probably the first black child she'd ever really perceived in her young life. By age 18 months she was already sorting the world into whites, and Annas (i.e. blacks).
Many parents are uncomfortable talking about racial differences, but their children's questions need to be answered in simple direct ways that validate their perception of differences and provide clear honest answers rather than brushing them aside. Otherwise kids can end up confused and worried about issues of differences and taking their cues from the wrong sources.
Mirandapost #38 of 396/10/12 at 12:35pm
we live in a pretty limited area of diversity. only 13 minority. although i wonder if they are including the out of state college students. we have a lot of people from africa here as well. DS1 has learned about slavery and the civil rights movement but i dont really feel the need to teach him about acceptance of diversity beyond respecting other cultural norms. we as parents dont treat other races differently so i think they learn by example.
post #39 of 397/12/12 at 6:05amThread Starter
Hi everyone ... meant to check back in much earlier, then it just slipped.
Thanks for each and every response, even the ones that made me want to say, "but, but ... "
Reading those responses, saying that I had lived too segregated / privileged a life, or must have demonstrated prejudiced attitudes ... it made me feel what my daughter was feeling when she shrank into the couch and said, "I shouldn't have said anything."
And thanks to those of you who understood and offered help and insights. Some of those were very much on target. We have gotten together more with our friends of different backgrounds - it really didn't end up being contrived at all, it just took a phone call and viola, there was a playdate. It will take a lot more than this to explore these feelings and stereotypes, and I am not going to put the burden on the playdates to address these issues. There are issues within issues ... so we will keep thinking about them, but at least in the background of our thinking there will be more diverse everyday life experience than what we seemed to be having earlier.
Anyway, now having thought about all those responses, arranged several playdates, and seeking out diverse representations in books and other media, I want to share some notes from a couple of books I have come across. What I have discovered, and becomes obvious once you are aware of it, is that segregation is operating in hidden ways - it came up in the recent Slate debate about whether homeschooling is in line with liberal values -and Astra Taylor notes that:Quote from Astra Taylor:
"But, truth be told, the minuscule number of secular home learners nationwide is dwarfed by the huge population of liberal parents who do everything in their power to get their kids into the best public schools possible, moving their families to more competitive districts, those desirable zip codes, and perpetuating inequity in the process." (Learning in Freedom)
Now I will quote a book with the suitably embarrassing title: Some of My Best Friends are Black: by Tanner ColbyQuote from Tanner Colby:
When you're white in America, life is a restricted country club by default, engineered in such a way that the problems of race rarely intrude on you personally. During the time of Jim Crow, it took a great deal of terrorism, fear, and deliberate, purposeful discrimination to keep the color line in place. What's curious about America today is that you can be white and enjoy much of the same isolation and exclusivity without having to do anything.
The intentional nature of this phenomenon was thoroughly documented in a book called Sundown Towns by James Loewen.
Some of the topics that Loewen brings up, useful for our introspection are:
Cognitive Dissonance in Martinsville, Indiana (p, 327)
Independent Sundown Towns Limit the Horizons of Their Children (p. 334)
and many others. It is a stunning, shocking book - until you see how painfully obvious it is, or should have been.
No conclusions, still thinking - just coming up for air to share.
- Our Child's Education: Our Decision To Make, Not Yours
- › Thoughts on age differences? 1 minute ago
- › Lead test- is it really needed? 7 minutes ago
- › let's talk about doulas 20 minutes ago
- › 8th grade son just isn't focussing in school 22 minutes ago
- › December Spend-Less Challenge: Let's Fill Our Stockings with... 23 minutes ago
- › ~*~ The TTC ONE Thread ~*~ December 2013 25 minutes ago
- › Morning Sickness at Work 25 minutes ago
- › s/o xdh blackmailing me about my dating life 28 minutes ago
- › December chat - those still hanging around! 30 minutes ago
- › Toys and games 31 minutes ago
- › Diva Cup Diva Cup #2 Post Childbirth, Cup by Taqah
- › GroVia Cloth All In One - Pudge by Taqah
- › North American Bear Company Rosy Cheeks Baby Tan by Taqah
- › Maya Wrap Lightly Padded Baby Sling by Taqah
- › Bamboletta Doll by sleeping mama
- › Melissa & Doug Cutting Food Box by ahilal
- › Prince Lionheart Whirl Balance Scooter, Natural/Pink by Melanie Mayo
- › Elves and Angels Sylvie's Wood Kitchen by Melanie Mayo
- › Natural Earth Paints Face Paint by Melanie Mayo
- › Glob Greeting Card Collage Kit with Seedpaper by Melanie Mayo
- › To Santa or Not To Santa by JillVettel
- › Three Low Cost Holiday Gifts to Make with Kids by Stephafriendly
- › Mothering with Mental Illness: The Natural... by OliviaHinebaugh
- › Vaccinations and George W Bush by Brian Leaf
- › Does Motherhood Matter Anymore? by Melanie Mayo
- › Terms and Conditions: Holiday Cards Giveaway... by Cynthia Mosher
- › Mothering's Natural Toy Guide 2013 by Monica S
- › Top 20 Toy Picks for 2013 | Mothering Natural... by Melanie Mayo
- › 21 Toys Under $21 | Mothering Natural Toy... by Melanie Mayo
- › Toys to Splurge On | Mothering Natural Toy... by Melanie Mayo