I grew up in Puyallup and I live on South Hill now. I went to Puyallup High School and thought it was fine, but Rogers High School is the one on South Hill and I heard, maybe from my mom, that it's supposed to be better than Puyallup High school (in the valley). My son is 4 and in a developmental preschool at Sunrise Elementary School (public and on South Hill), and his teacher is amazing. I went to Waller Road elementary in the puyallup school district and it was good too, but it's closer to tacoma.
My parents live in Eatonville and live on Clear Lake, and my brother went to the Eatonville schools. If you have any questions you want me to ask them, just let me know and I can ask. Graham is nice and woodsy too...I think it's in the Bethel school district. I don't know much about the Bethel school district, but I did have a friend from church who went to that school district and she was very smart and took lots of advanced classes, so I guess they must offer them.
Oh, also, there is always the option of doing Running Start here...where high school students can go to the community college nearby and those credits can count toward college. I did that at PHS and it was great. PHS was really encouraging about it.
And just a warning about South Hill, if you live near Meridian, it's very crowded and traffic is terrible. We try to go on the back roads to get places and that helps a lot.
And really, if you have any questions, feel free to ask me and I can ask around. And if there are certain neighborhoods you're looking at for a house, I can ask around about the safety of those neighborhoods too. I feel really safe where we live, but we lived in Kent before moving here almost four years ago, and Kent was very unsafe.
I hope this helps!