Wy do you think that there are so many similarities in religious myths? So many have creation stories, flood stories, virigin births, etc? I understand that there are eternal truths to be taught be ech society, but I am mystified by te fact that the details are so similar.
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Spirituality › Religious Studies › Common threads in religious myths and stories.
Join Now
Be a part of the community.
It's free, join today!
Recent Reviews
-
My mom gave me this for Christmas and I absolutely love it. Gorgeous illustrations and very sweet ideas inside. Plus it's just structured enough so that I can be creative about what I include...
-
This is the prettiest carrier, and fit my shoulders and figure (at 5'6") much better than the Ergo. I got it when my daughter was about nine months, two years ago - it doesn't appear to have...
-
This potty is great - excellent value & performance! (plus it's cute!) My 9 month old DS took to it right away. He is a big boy (30 in. tall - feet not quite on floor - & 27 lbs.) and this is...
-
This book feels good in your hands. The paper is heavyweight, and the illustrations flow perfectly.
-
To anyone looking for a carrier, BECO is the brand! I recently had purchased the Gemini, great carrier! It has everything you will ever need and want, its ergonomic, comfy, organic, made...
Common threads in religious myths and stories.
post #2 of 3
4/18/04 at 7:13pm
- captain optimism
- Trader Feedback: 0
- Hurrah for the Pirate Queen
-
- offline
- 7,058 Posts. Joined 1/2003
- Location: Good Ship Lollipop
- Select All Posts By This User
This is an excellent question!
I think because there are some human experiences that are universal. I don't know if I agree with the universal truths premise, but what I think is I guess close enough to make no difference.
I also think that there has been a lot more contact between civilizations than we previously supposed.
I think because there are some human experiences that are universal. I don't know if I agree with the universal truths premise, but what I think is I guess close enough to make no difference.
I also think that there has been a lot more contact between civilizations than we previously supposed.
post #3 of 3
4/18/04 at 9:41pm
Arggggh! I just erased a very good start to my reply!
Here it goes again, albeit more abbreviated.
You should definitely look into the works of Joseph Campbell. He is the leading specialist on comparative mythology and spent most of his career analyzing recurrent threads in different culture's mythologies. His books can be a bit academic, so a good place to start would be his PBS video interviews with Bill Moyers, they are available at many Blockbusters, most libraries (try university's) and I've seen them a couple of times on PBS. His most famous work is Hero with a Thousand Faces that traces the cyclical path of the hero as he undergoes lesson-filled adventures that lead to an enlightenment that benefits both himself and his group. It's interesting to see how this can be applied to modern movies as well(ie: Matrix, Star Wars.)
That being said, I've given a lot of thought to your question and come up with a few different thoughts. One idea (not mine) is the concept of the collective subconscious. That there is a commanality to symbolic truths that is recognized by all people. That's the more psycological perspective.
The more esoteric one would be this: I believe that essentially, eveything in every universe is just a microcosm of the collective whole. We are vibrations of energy and collections of matter that operate in different visible ways at different wavelengths, but that all resonate back to the same source. And because we are from the same source, we are all one (corny I know). If we are just different views of the same thing, then it makes sense that we share thoughts, explanations. Everything is different, but only as light appears different when refracted through a spectrum.
And I don't think that is limited to our physical natures. I guess it does lead back to the collective subconscious but on a more spiritual level. We tell the same stories and we understand the same truths because it does not matter the distance and time b/t peoples, the truth remains essentially the same. And these stories of virgin births and floods, are such strongly ingrained allegories that have been vital to human's explanations of themselvs and their universe, that they transcend personal ideology and apply as universal truths.
The great flood is the great spring. Renewal of the entire earth. This one I think could even date back to a common remembrance of an actual flood that has been explained in every tradition at different times. Perhaps even our planet's beginning as water plays a part and our collective unconscious remembers "the great flood" more as the great beginning of life forms on our planet.
The virgin birth is a physical application of a god's otherworldly, divine status. He/She is not tainted by things of the body, does not cause pain (Buddha was born of his mother's side), and is born more of the thought/design of the gods than as a physical consequence.
As for creation stories, they are absolutely necessary for a culture's understanding of themselves and their origins.
You will find that genres such as creation stories, trickster tales, explanantions of natural phenomenon, etc are found in every culture because those are the things that early people needed to understand why the sky thunders, why some people act in trecherous ways, why in fact we are standing here, on this spot of earth able to ask these questions.
Here it goes again, albeit more abbreviated.
You should definitely look into the works of Joseph Campbell. He is the leading specialist on comparative mythology and spent most of his career analyzing recurrent threads in different culture's mythologies. His books can be a bit academic, so a good place to start would be his PBS video interviews with Bill Moyers, they are available at many Blockbusters, most libraries (try university's) and I've seen them a couple of times on PBS. His most famous work is Hero with a Thousand Faces that traces the cyclical path of the hero as he undergoes lesson-filled adventures that lead to an enlightenment that benefits both himself and his group. It's interesting to see how this can be applied to modern movies as well(ie: Matrix, Star Wars.)
That being said, I've given a lot of thought to your question and come up with a few different thoughts. One idea (not mine) is the concept of the collective subconscious. That there is a commanality to symbolic truths that is recognized by all people. That's the more psycological perspective.
The more esoteric one would be this: I believe that essentially, eveything in every universe is just a microcosm of the collective whole. We are vibrations of energy and collections of matter that operate in different visible ways at different wavelengths, but that all resonate back to the same source. And because we are from the same source, we are all one (corny I know). If we are just different views of the same thing, then it makes sense that we share thoughts, explanations. Everything is different, but only as light appears different when refracted through a spectrum.
And I don't think that is limited to our physical natures. I guess it does lead back to the collective subconscious but on a more spiritual level. We tell the same stories and we understand the same truths because it does not matter the distance and time b/t peoples, the truth remains essentially the same. And these stories of virgin births and floods, are such strongly ingrained allegories that have been vital to human's explanations of themselvs and their universe, that they transcend personal ideology and apply as universal truths.
The great flood is the great spring. Renewal of the entire earth. This one I think could even date back to a common remembrance of an actual flood that has been explained in every tradition at different times. Perhaps even our planet's beginning as water plays a part and our collective unconscious remembers "the great flood" more as the great beginning of life forms on our planet.
The virgin birth is a physical application of a god's otherworldly, divine status. He/She is not tainted by things of the body, does not cause pain (Buddha was born of his mother's side), and is born more of the thought/design of the gods than as a physical consequence.
As for creation stories, they are absolutely necessary for a culture's understanding of themselves and their origins.
You will find that genres such as creation stories, trickster tales, explanantions of natural phenomenon, etc are found in every culture because those are the things that early people needed to understand why the sky thunders, why some people act in trecherous ways, why in fact we are standing here, on this spot of earth able to ask these questions.
Return Home
Back to Forum: Religious Studies
This thread is locked
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Spirituality › Religious Studies › Common threads in religious myths and stories.
Currently, there are 1674 Active Users
(235 Members and 1439 Guests)
Recent Discussions
- › need to vent 0 ago
- › CRAVINGS!!! 9 seconds ago
- › Planning a UC for first baby 2 minutes ago
- › Weekly chat Feb 6-13 3 minutes ago
- › The short but sweet birth of Kathrine Leanne... 3 minutes ago
- › Plus Size Maternity Photos 5 minutes ago
- › Fun with Stretchmarks 6 minutes ago
- › Flat temps luteal phase only 6 minutes ago
- › Progesterone levels and LPD - Need Advice Please 7 minutes ago
- › Does anyone know the most current promo code for the FREE Seven Sling? 7 minutes ago
View: New Posts | All Discussions
Recent Reviews
- › The First 1000 Days: A Baby Journal by MrsKatie
- › Beco Butterfly II Carrier by capucine
- › Fisher-Price Precious Planet Froggy Friend Potty by pickle18
- › Embrace: A Pregnancy Journal by mama kk
- › Beco Baby Carrier Gemini by 2jmama
- › Bummis Super Whisper Wrap by sweetBBkendall
- › BabyHawk Oh SNAP! Baby Carrier by 2jmama
- › Raising Abel by lauren
- › Keter 115-gallon Capacity Super Composter by MonarchMom
- › Gaiam Pencil Skirt by Melanie Mayo
View: More Reviews
Recent Articles
- › Contest Terms and Conditions -... by Cynthia Mosher
- › Contest Terms and Conditions - Sasquatch... by JenniO11
- › Teach Your Children Spanish With Little Pim by John Martin
- › How to Start a Social Group by Cynthia Mosher
- › Boba Carrier 3G Giveaway Contest Rules by MDCLurker
- › Best of Mothering 2011 Official Rules by MDCLurker
- › Babywearing Basics by Peggy O'Mara
- › Groups Guidelines by Cynthia Mosher
- › Sex Talk Forum by almadianna
- › Nfp Or Fam Methods While Breastfeeding by JMJ
View: Recent Articles | All Articles
Home | Reviews & More | Forums | Articles | My Profile
About Mothering | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2012 Mothering is powered by Huddler Families | FAQ | Support | Privacy/TOS | Site Map
About Mothering | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2012 Mothering is powered by Huddler Families | FAQ | Support | Privacy/TOS | Site Map






