Are car seat vests safe? Can I use them on a plane? - Page 3
- DahliaRW
- Trader Feedback: +19
-
- offline
- 6,578 Posts. Joined 4/2005
- Location: Near the beautiful Cascades!
- Select All Posts By This User

I'm starting to think I won't be able to bring a car seat at all because of our car. It's a Beetle. The rear-facing convertible has to be short enough to fit in the back seat and almost nothing does. Most infant seats wont' even fit. I will look, but I really don't think I will be able to find one that will both RF and fit my 5 yo on the plane. It will be too tall and I wont' be able to sit in the front seat because it won't fold back. I can't put an extra empty car seat in the Beetle. One would fit in the trunk, but that's all that would fit, no suitcase. There is no middle seat in our car. It's sooooo tiny! I'm probably stuck with borrowing a seat for the baby when we get there and renting one for him in OR and putting DD on the plane in either just a lap belt or a CARES harness. :( On the bright side, I won't have to carry a car seat, I guess. Having to rent a car seat for one week won't be that bad, I hope.
For the drive to the airport, put the baby in the car seat you are bringing with you. Uninstall when you get there and take it. It's a pain, but it gives you the space you need. Same with your 5yo, put in the booster/seat you're taking with you on the trip for the trip to the airport in the beetle.
- chel
- Trader Feedback: 0
-
- offline
- 4,207 Posts. Joined 7/2004
- Location: lost in a cornfield
- Select All Posts By This User
- brigala
- Trader Feedback: 0
-
- offline
- 183 Posts. Joined 4/2010
- Location: Pacific Northwest
- Select All Posts By This User
If you do make it to Oregon without a car seat, I can probably loan you one. I'd hate to see you renting a car seat. Yuck.
There's a local discount chain here called BiMart that carries the Cosco Apt for $44. Maybe one of your relatives could pick that up for you. There are BiMart stores all over the place here, and usually they all carry the same stuff so it should be readily accessible. I'm assuming you're flying into Portland since there aren't that many airports in this state, and flying into any of the other ones is usually very expensive. The lightrail goes right to the airport here, so you wouldn't *necessarily* have to use the car seat immediately. In theory, with some careful planning, you could take lightrail to a location where you could pick up a car seat.
- amberskyfire
- Trader Feedback: 0
-
- offline
- 2,203 Posts. Joined 9/2007
- Location: Hawaii
- Select All Posts By This User

If you do make it to Oregon without a car seat, I can probably loan you one. I'd hate to see you renting a car seat. Yuck.
There's a local discount chain here called BiMart that carries the Cosco Apt for $44. Maybe one of your relatives could pick that up for you. There are BiMart stores all over the place here, and usually they all carry the same stuff so it should be readily accessible. I'm assuming you're flying into Portland since there aren't that many airports in this state, and flying into any of the other ones is usually very expensive. The lightrail goes right to the airport here, so you wouldn't *necessarily* have to use the car seat immediately. In theory, with some careful planning, you could take lightrail to a location where you could pick up a car seat.
My grandmother cannot get the car seat for me. She doesn't drive or leave her home, really and she lives alone. She is our only family in OR. I'd be grateful to borrow yours, but it wouldn't be feasible at all. You'd have to meet us at the airport when our flight arrives before we rent our car. It could be the middle of the night for all I know. I think we may have figured it out, though. :)
But I'd need car seats to put the kids in to get them in the car to go to a store to buy car seats.

For the drive to the airport, put the baby in the car seat you are bringing with you. Uninstall when you get there and take it. It's a pain, but it gives you the space you need. Same with your 5yo, put in the booster/seat you're taking with you on the trip for the trip to the airport in the beetle.
That's what I was trying to explain. I don't think I can. Because the baby would have to be rear-facing and I can't rear-face in a Beetle a car seat that is tall enough to fit a 5 y/o. I can't take a car seat in my car that she would fit in on a plane. She's too tall.
Actually, I could probably put her in that car seat in our car FF and then put her in it on the plane and then use it for the baby RF when we get where we are going. Hmm...now I just need to find a car seat that will fit a very tall 5 y/o that will also RF a 1 yo. We could leave the baby's car seat in the car and just pack her booster in carry-on, deflated.
- amberskyfire
- Trader Feedback: 0
-
- offline
- 2,203 Posts. Joined 9/2007
- Location: Hawaii
- Select All Posts By This User
Is there a car seat that will fit a very tall (95th percentile) 5 yo that is lightweight enough to carry and will also RF a 1 yo?
- DahliaRW
- Trader Feedback: +19
-
- offline
- 6,578 Posts. Joined 4/2005
- Location: Near the beautiful Cascades!
- Select All Posts By This User

That's what I was trying to explain. I don't think I can. Because the baby would have to be rear-facing and I can't rear-face in a Beetle a car seat that is tall enough to fit a 5 y/o. I can't take a car seat in my car that she would fit in on a plane. She's too tall.
Actually, I could probably put her in that car seat in our car FF and then put her in it on the plane and then use it for the baby RF when we get where we are going. Hmm...now I just need to find a car seat that will fit a very tall 5 y/o that will also RF a 1 yo. We could leave the baby's car seat in the car and just pack her booster in carry-on, deflated.
No, not the same seat for the 5yo. Whatever seat you are using for the baby on the trip and then the booster for the 5yo. I would not worry at all about a 5 yo in a lap belt on the plane, it's safter statistically then being in a harnessed seat in a car.
- DahliaRW
- Trader Feedback: +19
-
- offline
- 6,578 Posts. Joined 4/2005
- Location: Near the beautiful Cascades!
- Select All Posts By This User
Safety First Complete Air may work. It fit my very long torsoed ds at 6yo, barely. Has a tall shell, but you can install it more upright which may help it fit in your beetle.
- chel
- Trader Feedback: 0
-
- offline
- 4,207 Posts. Joined 7/2004
- Location: lost in a cornfield
- Select All Posts By This User
It sounded like you were not, and staying with people that would pick you up and lend you seats. If so, you can buy carseats online and have them shipped to where you are staying and then use for just the OR part of the trip.
- amberskyfire
- Trader Feedback: 0
-
- offline
- 2,203 Posts. Joined 9/2007
- Location: Hawaii
- Select All Posts By This User

Are you renting a car for theTX part of your trip?
It sounded like you were not, and staying with people that would pick you up and lend you seats. If so, you can buy carseats online and have them shipped to where you are staying and then use for just the OR part of the trip.
No, family will be picking us up in TX and my SIL can loan me one of her extra seats. She has 5 kids and 2 cars, so lots of extras.
I can't take it if the 5 yo won't be sitting in it on the plane because I won't gate check the seat and won't have a seat on the plane for the baby.
- brigala
- Trader Feedback: 0
-
- offline
- 183 Posts. Joined 4/2010
- Location: Pacific Northwest
- Select All Posts By This User
What is your 5 year old's torso height? (Sit the 5 year old the floor against a wall, and measure the distance from the floor to the top of the child's shoulder).
- amberskyfire
- Trader Feedback: 0
-
- offline
- 2,203 Posts. Joined 9/2007
- Location: Hawaii
- Select All Posts By This User
No, the booster would be packed, not used on the plane. We are talking about using the car seat on the plane. The booster is just for the car.
I'm not sure how tall she will be then. It will be in March or June, so I'll have to measure then. I was just wondering if there were any for tall children.
- brigala
- Trader Feedback: 0
-
- offline
- 183 Posts. Joined 4/2010
- Location: Pacific Northwest
- Select All Posts By This User
That depends on how tall is tall.
If you measure her now, it could at least rule out a lot of car seats. Of course you'd need to measure again as you get closer.
The Evenflo SureRide might be more widely available by then. It's hard to find right now because it's super new. It has a RF height limit of only 37" which is relatively short, but it is the second-tallest forward facing car seat on the market. I'd be really shocked to find a 5 year old who wouldn't fit in it. It will accommodate a torso height of up to 19". It is supposed to retail for around $90-$100.
What are you planning on using for your baby at home when she outgrows the infant seat? You'll need to find *some* rear-facing car seat to fit in the Beatle.
- DahliaRW
- Trader Feedback: +19
-
- offline
- 6,578 Posts. Joined 4/2005
- Location: Near the beautiful Cascades!
- Select All Posts By This User
And what I am saying is bring 1 car seat for the baby, and whatever car seat the will be in you can use in the car on the way to the airport and uninstall to take it with you and bring 1 booster for the 5yo that you put in the overhead bin while your 5yo just sits in the plane lapbelt.
- amberskyfire
- Trader Feedback: 0
-
- offline
- 2,203 Posts. Joined 9/2007
- Location: Hawaii
- Select All Posts By This User

And what I am saying is bring 1 car seat for the baby, and whatever car seat the will be in you can use in the car on the way to the airport and uninstall to take it with you and bring 1 booster for the 5yo that you put in the overhead bin while your 5yo just sits in the plane lapbelt.
The baby will, very unfortunately, not have a seat of his own. :(
Just a thought but how important it it for the seat to fit the 5 year old correctly if it's being used on a plane?
I mean obviously they have to be comfortable in in but my kids were still comfortable their car seats when they were a bit too tall (i.e. harness was below their shoulders). I would not have want to use a seat that didn't fit in the car but I would personally be tempted to use a too small seat on a plane rather than have the kids climbing around.
- DahliaRW
- Trader Feedback: +19
-
- offline
- 6,578 Posts. Joined 4/2005
- Location: Near the beautiful Cascades!
- Select All Posts By This User
Ah, gotcha. Then the best method to get the baby's seat to your destination if the 5yo can't use it safely is to check it in the original box it was shipped in (or bought in from the store) as luggage rather than gate checking it unprotected.

Just a thought but how important it it for the seat to fit the 5 year old correctly if it's being used on a plane?
I mean obviously they have to be comfortable in in but my kids were still comfortable their car seats when they were a bit too tall (i.e. harness was below their shoulders). I would not have want to use a seat that didn't fit in the car but I would personally be tempted to use a too small seat on a plane rather than have the kids climbing around.
I agree with this. The forces aren't going to be the same on an airplane, and the seat isn't going to provide the same sort of protection it does in the car, whether it fits or not. So I think it's less about if it "fits properly" for the 5 year old and more about how to get both kid and seat there safest. If it's comfortable enough to sit in, I wouldn't worry about height etc. on an airplane.
- amberskyfire
- Trader Feedback: 0
-
- offline
- 2,203 Posts. Joined 9/2007
- Location: Hawaii
- Select All Posts By This User
That is a really good question! My main concern would be the strength of the seat. If the 5 y/o is too tall for it, that might not be a huge deal, but what if she's too heavy? If the buckles, straps or plastic back of the seat are only strong enough up to 35 lbs and she weighs, say 50 (just making that up, I have no idea how much she weighs), then the seat might break in a crash whereas the lap belt would hold.
- Are car seat vests safe? Can I use them on a plane?
Recent Discussions
- › Welcome 6 minutes ago
- › Changing words in books when reading aloud to children? 8 minutes ago
- › Getting Out of Debt - June 2013 9 minutes ago
- › Dingoes running into the summer sunshine -- June! 9 minutes ago
- › The Saner TTC-Flower Moon 10 minutes ago
- › toy sharing between siblings - time limit or "until she's finished... 12 minutes ago
- › Alternative / Vaccine friendly Pediatrician Mountain Brook /... 15 minutes ago
- › Toddler Behavior Changes Related to Pregnancy? 18 minutes ago
- › Are you a Midwife? PLEASE HELP!! 20 minutes ago
- › What are "dealbreakers" when it comes to your kids' friends' home... 23 minutes ago
Recent Reviews
- › Earth Mama-Angel Baby Organic Angel Baby Shampoo & Body Wash,... by hmiller
- › Shea Moisture Raw Shea Butter Baby Head-to-Toe Wash & Shampoo -... by hmiller
- › Angel Baby Bottom Balm - 2oz by hmiller
- › Badger Baby Oil 4oz Glass Bottle by fayebond
- › Burt's Bees Baby Bee SPF 30 Sunscreen Stick, 0.7 Ounce by fayebond
- › LuSa Organics Hey You. Shoo. by fayebond
- › Nurture My Body Natural Baby Shampoo and Body Wash Fragrance Free by fayebond
- › Baby Bee Fragrance Free Shampoo and Wash - 12 oz - Liquid by fayebond
- › Calendula Cream 2oz by Anires Relheo
- › SAFETY 1ST 10435 NAIL CLIPPERS by Anires Relheo
New Articles
- › Homeopathic Help for Post-Partum Mothers: a... by Melanie Mayo
- › Adding the Second Child by Sarah Clark
- › 5 Steps for Managing Stress and Anxiety by Melanie Mayo
- › What Marketers Don't Understand About... by Melanie Mayo
- › For the Dads by Rachel Wolf
- › What Happened When This Bereaved Mom Sought A... by momofnatasha
- › More About Soothing Small Tummies from... by Melanie Mayo
- › Get Ready To Read By Playing by Melanie Mayo
- › "Do You Trust Me?" by SantoshaMama
- › Terms and Conditions - Mothering Bath and... by Cynthia Mosher
About Mothering | Join the Community | Advertise
© 2013 Mothering is powered by Huddler Families | FAQ | Support | Privacy/TOS | Site Map
Follow Mothering