Yes, I suppose it is -- this shouldn't become a debate specifically about sample size but where relevant to trust it's ok.
Related Forum Threads
- Unvaccinated Kids with Autism Spectrum Disorders Last post on 2/28/14 at 9:06pm in Vaccinations Debate
- Debate this meme Last post on 10/21/13 at 5:29am in Vaccinations Debate
- Observations about pertussis and vaccines from a peds RN Last post on 2/16/14 at 9:59pm in Vaccinating on Schedule
- U.S measles cases in 2013 may be most in 17 years Last post on 9/20/13 at 4:59pm in Vaccinations Debate
- New study confirms unvaccinated children are at higher risk of contracting whooping cough Last post on 9/17/13 at 1:51pm in Vaccinations Debate
My Vaccine Info
Last edited: 3/4/13
- Vaccinations: Why All the Fuss?Last edited: 12/26/13
- Resources for Non-vaccinating FamiliesLast edited: 1/18/13
- Frontline's War on Selectively Vaccinating ParentsLast edited: 3/14/13
- The Right to RefuseLast edited: 3/20/13
Why Do People Follow Medical Authorities? - Page 7post #122 of 19811/29/12 at 4:43pmQuote:
I don't understand. Why is this an unreasonable, off topic issue? The topic of the thread is why people follow medical authorities. I think it's very relevant to clarify if people are making decisions based on one bad or good experience versus some kind of systemic issue.post #123 of 19811/29/12 at 5:20pm
Sample size relevant to the issue of trust is relevant so long as it is discussed in the spirit of trying to understand another's point of view. Derailing the thread to the point where we are only debating sample size is OT. Feel free to PM me for more information.post #124 of 19811/29/12 at 5:22pmpost #125 of 19811/29/12 at 6:37pmQuote:
I tend to conclude that they generally give bad advice on certain subjects based on not only my experiences but the experiences of people I know (many who belong to a local AP/natural parenting group).
I don't think they necessarily need to do extra studying in breastfeeding or co-sleeping to be good in their field; however it would be nice if they didn't give bad advice as "experts" to parents who don't know any better.post #126 of 19811/29/12 at 6:46pmI take doctors, likes people, on a case by case basis. I've known good ones and bad ones. I probably tend to give them the benefit of the doubt, though, because I've known,ore good than bad. I was just talking to my mom today about a medical resident who saved my right leg. While I generally think orthopedic surgeons are kind of arrogant, I'll always be grateful for that one and his expertise.post #127 of 19811/29/12 at 7:04pmpost #128 of 19811/29/12 at 7:07pmpost #129 of 19811/29/12 at 7:37pmThread StarterQuote:Originally Posted by pek64
My other problem is with doctors believing themselves to be parenting or feeding (nutrition) experts with minimal or no training. If they were honest about their limitations, and refer me to better trained individuals, I'd have more respect. I had no less than three separate doctors tell me I needed to put my baby on IsomilDF (spelling may be wrong) for a diarrhea caused by a virus. I kept repeating that I was breastfeeding, and they repeated themselves AS IF I HADN'T SPOKEN. It wouldn't have bothered me so much if they had at least acknowledged my words, but they didn't give any indication that I would be able to return to breastfeeding. In the end, I got my advice from a breastfeeding counselor (lactation consultat in training) who assured me that continuing to breastfeed was best. She was right. Twenty four hours later he was fine. Was it a risk? Yes. But if I hadn't taken that risk he might have been switched to formula at 14 weeks.
I have had a similar experience. At 9 months my eldest (breast fed) DD had a gastrointestinal virus and went the whole night without wetting her diaper. I was worried about dehydration so took her to the ER at a teaching hospital in Hong Kong. The resident told me to stop nursing her and give her congee (rice porridge). I knew better so ignored his advice, continued nursing her and she got better in a couple of days.post #130 of 19811/29/12 at 7:50pm
One of my nephews had jaundice, and my sister's doctor told her not to nurse him and to give formula instead. Thank goodness she ignored her and kept on breastfeeding.
Currently she's in the south and says that a lactation consultant neighbor of hers can't wait to move out of the area because it's virtually impossible to get medical personnel on board with encouraging nursing.post #132 of 19811/29/12 at 7:54pmpost #133 of 19811/29/12 at 8:05pm
Between the constant doctor bashing and making huge stereotypes about people who live in my part of the country, it's just so offensive that I cant take this seriously.
Seriously, all Im hearing about is how all the doctors that you all know have all given bad advice and been terrible to you. What about all the doctors who save lives, heal people, help people, and spend a huge part of their lives learning how to do it? Most doctors dont get into the business of being a doctor so that they can patronize you and tell you how stupid you are.
And as far as mountian dew goes, people all over the country make terrible parenting decisions. Let's not start picking on the south. There are people in rural Illinois that I know have done the same thing. "There are areas" all over the country that make bad decisions. And fwiw, there are at least two huge medical teaching hospitals that I know of in the south that are currently working to promote breastfeeding in hospitals and at health departments.post #135 of 19811/29/12 at 8:14pmStereotyping people by geography is offensive no matter how specifically vague you're being. People all over the country do stupid stuff. It is about those people and individual decisions they made, not where they live, so why brim that into it? If I made a similar comment involving race ("there are SOME purple people who . . .") it would be undeniably offensive. This is no different. Stop stereotyping people.post #137 of 19811/29/12 at 8:19pmpost #138 of 19811/29/12 at 8:22pm
I was being vague about my sister's location because I didn't want to reveal her personal information. She's an MDC member but very busy and so doesn't post much; hopefully someday she can talk about what happened herself.post #139 of 19811/29/12 at 8:33pmQuote:
This thread is about trusting doctors. It is hardly surprising that some people are going to come on and tell us why they do not trust doctors.
Edited by kathymuggle - 11/30/12 at 5:09ampost #140 of 19811/29/12 at 11:30pmQuote:Originally Posted by Rrrrrachel
I take doctors, likes people, on a case by case basis. I've known good ones and bad ones. I probably tend to give them the benefit of the doubt, though, because I've known,ore good than bad. I was just talking to my mom today about a medical resident who saved my right leg. While I generally think orthopedic surgeons are kind of arrogant, I'll always be grateful for that one and his expertise.
I'm glad that you've known more good than bad. That explains why you give doctors the benefit of the doubt. I've known more bad than good, by at least a two thirds to one third ratio. That explains why I take what a doctor says with caution. We both are reasonable.
This thread is locked
- Why Do People Follow Medical Authorities?
- Vaccinations: Why All the Fuss?
- › Georgiana's Birth: a planned unassisted homebirth 5 minutes ago
- › Georgiana's Birth: A planned, unassisted homebirth en caul 8 minutes ago
- › Georgiana is born! 10 minutes ago
- › Easy-to-remove canning labels? 17 minutes ago
- › ~*~ The TTC ONE Thread~*~ March 2014 23 minutes ago
- › Name 23 minutes ago
- › Welcome! Roll call! Introduce yourself please! 33 minutes ago
- › General Chat 35 minutes ago
- › Dreamy lighting and baby belly 42 minutes ago
- › March Chat! 42 minutes ago
- › Vaccine: The Controversial Story of Medicine's Greatest Lifesaver by ss834
- › Pyur Diaper Balm by MimiPilla
- › Burt's Bees Mama Bee Belly Balm, Fragrance Free, by KatelynRose
- › Summer Infant Best View Handheld Color Video Monitor with 2.5"... by thebessmartinfo
- › Happy Heiny's One Size Cloth Diapers by SquirmyWorm
- › Homesteader's Kitchen, The: Recipes from Farm to Table by Monica S
- › Rainbow Light Just Once Prenatal One Multivitamin, 90 Tablets by glwilson22
- › Bear Stays Up for Christmas by rosemarievpaulson
- › The Night Before Christmas by rjdoghouse
- › The Polar Express by sassyfirechick
- › Okay to Leave Kids in the Car While Popping... by Brian Leaf
- › Laundry Zen by Laura Grace Weldon
- › High Needs Mother by BrainChild
- › Homebirth Forum Guidelines by Cynthia Mosher
- › Disclaimer by Cynthia Mosher
- › Does Siri Thwart Social Intelligence? by Marcy Axness
- › Homeschooling with YouTube by SavvyHomeschool
- › Closing the Door On Childbearing by Melanie Mayo
- › A Journey Through Childhood with Seuss by Melanie Mayo
- › Belly Binding for Prenatal Comfort and... by Kristen Tea