My 2-month-old DD had her well child check today and the pediatrician played the 'dead baby' card with us when we explained we would not be vaccinating today. (He basically said, "Are you prepared for your child to DIE from a preventable illness?") I was a bit flummoxed as I never ran into this reaction before with my other DD. I forget what I said in response, honestly. Have any of you moms experienced this? How did you handle it?
- topicVaccinationstagged by System, 12/7/12
Related Forum Threads
- Sometimes I get so appalled with society Last post on Today at 6:47 am in I'm Not Vaccinating
- Please help a girl out... Last post on Today at 6:52 am in I'm Not Vaccinating
- This is predictable ... Last post on Today at 6:54 am in I'm Not Vaccinating
- Former Merck doctor - Gardasil will be the biggest scandal in medical history Last post on Today at 5:21 am in I'm Not Vaccinating
- Editorial on parental vaccine choice Last post on Yesterday at 12:48 pm in I'm Not Vaccinating
My Vaccine Info
Last edited: 3/4/13
- Vaccinations: Why All the Fuss?Last edited: 12/26/13
- Resources for Non-vaccinating FamiliesLast edited: 1/18/13
- Frontline's War on Selectively Vaccinating ParentsLast edited: 3/14/13
- In Britain 12-Year-Olds Vaccinated Without Parental ConsentLast edited: 3/8/13
Offensive remarks from a pedi-- how to deal?post #1 of 2312/7/12 at 2:08pmThread Starterpost #2 of 2312/7/12 at 2:12pmpost #3 of 2312/7/12 at 2:57pmpost #4 of 2312/7/12 at 3:09pmpost #5 of 2312/7/12 at 3:36pmpost #6 of 2312/7/12 at 4:36pm
First of all, it seems like there is a better title for this thread. There are a lot of moms (myself included) who have lost children here at MDC and it's a bit jarring to see the title in New Posts. It's your thread- just my opinion.
That being said, I agree with PP's- run, far far away. This ped has no respect for you. I remember when DD was born and the hospital ped told me that she was way more likely to die in a car accident on the way home from the hospital than she was from the Hep B vaccine that I was declining. I never saw him again. Whether or not you choose to vax, I think it's important to have a doctor that respects your ability to make healthcare decisions for your children.
As for the card the ped is pulling, no matter what happens a mom will always wonder what she could have done to prevent her child's death. There will always be some self-blame to deal with, no matter which decisions you make. And, as for the question itself, I might respond with, "well, Im not prepared to wonder for the rest of my life whether or not a vaccine was what caused my child to die either." Decisions, decisions- no matter which ones you make they dont ensure safety.post #7 of 2312/7/12 at 9:38pmThis happened to me with DD1, not over vax but over my asking questions about medications a doctor was prescribing for her asthma. It was our first time seeing him after an insurance change- to state children's health ins- got us assigned to him as our pcp, and he prescribed several new meds right off the bat. I wanted to know what the were and why, and he just lost it. He yelled at me, in front of my kid, asking if I wanted her to die, and calling me "mom" the whole time. I've had some terrible experiences with doctors, but this guy was one of the rudest and most despicable people. He proceeded to grill me after that about my marital status and occupation, etc (I was a very young, divorced mom of 2, in school and working), and lecture me about life- completely inappropriate. I'm sure he was picking on me because of his perception of my family's SES based on our insurance card. I was like a deer in the headlights, too stunned to storm out like I wish I had.
When i got home I wrote a detailed report and submitted it to the insurance company per their instructions. Years later it still makes me sick to think about that horrible, condescending jerk and all the people he's probably treated that way over time.post #8 of 2312/8/12 at 12:13ampost #10 of 2312/8/12 at 4:25ampost #11 of 2312/8/12 at 4:38ampost #12 of 2312/8/12 at 8:02ampost #13 of 2312/8/12 at 8:30amAdaline'sMama, I'm profoundly sorry for your loss. I think that cases like yours are what make the doctor's behavior in the OP so despicable. S/he's casually and callously referring to a dead baby to guilt and scare the OP into vaccinating...even for diseases for which her baby has little to no quantifiable risk of catching and dying from. Infant deaths are a serious, horrific problem. Even for the deadlier vaccine-avoidable diseases, I think it's grossly inappropriate for doctors to use such hysterical language. They can just as easily have a calm, rational discussion about risks and benefits. Emotional maturity in a provider is not too much to ask.post #14 of 2312/8/12 at 8:49ampost #15 of 2312/8/12 at 9:29amQuote:Mod note: quoted post was removed due to violation of the forum guidelines
All the deaths must have been in Germany then, from official Australian statistics:Quote:
Severe morbidity and mortality
For the period July 2005 to June 2007, 57 hospital bed days were recorded for patients with an ICD-10-AM code for rubella. Of the 18 hospital separations, 9 (50%) had a principal diagnosis of rubella (average annual rate 0.02 per 100,000). The median length of stay in hospital was 2 days for all hospitalisations and 1 day for those with a principal diagnosis of rubella (Table 3.14.1). There were no deaths with rubella recorded as the underlying cause in 2005 or 2006.post #16 of 2312/8/12 at 9:34ampost #17 of 2312/8/12 at 9:56ampost #18 of 2312/8/12 at 10:03am
I think mods often take the weekend off. Darn mods wanting a life!! This is a bit of a trend I am noticing.
Perhaps we are better off just flagging instead of engaging newbies or fighters with agendas who do not know where to post? (even when others tell them fairly nicely that they are out of line here)
Edited by kathymuggle - 12/8/12 at 11:08ampost #20 of 2312/8/12 at 10:30am
I'm reviewing this thread and will be removing posts that are in violations of the forum guidelines and/or User Agreement and issuing warnings/infractions for posts in violation of the forum guidelines and/or User Agreement.
As a reminder, this is a support-only forum; please refer to the forum guidelines for more information about what this means. If you have questions about the guidelines, please PM a moderator. We mods don't take the weekends off, but we aren't able to be online all the time and we appreciate everyone's understanding of that. As was suggested eloquently earlier in the thread, please just flag/report a post that you find that violates the guidelines rather than responding to those posts. We'll respond as quickly as we can!
Last but not least, micromama, would you kindly edit the title of this thread (please PM me if you have any difficulty doing that)? The content of your post is fine, but in sensitivity to and support of families that have experienced the death of a baby (for any reason), an edited thread title would be appreciated as the thread titles are seen by all posters, even those not visiting the vaccination forums. I join the other posters here in sending my hugs and support to those of you who have lost a child.
Let's continue to keep the discussion going about how to deal with the challenge the OP and others are facing with doctors' comments about not vaccinating. My support to all of you!
- Vaccinations: Why All the Fuss?
- › Why Is Jenny McCarthy Dangerous? 35 seconds ago
- › Risperidone for a young child? 2 minutes ago
- › The Official 2014 Treasure Map 6 minutes ago
- › Wine In Labor 6 minutes ago
- › ~*~The TTC ONE Thread~*~April 2014 7 minutes ago
- › Why are we so worried about vax vs non-vax? 8 minutes ago
- › hi! 8 minutes ago
- › fun thread - let's make a list 8 minutes ago
- › Lupus, OB Care and Epidurals 10 minutes ago
- › Wanting But Waiting 2014 12 minutes ago
- › Epibi Nursing Pads by SparkleMaman
- › By Marie Winn - The Plug-In Drug: Television, Computers, and Family... by Catholic Mama
- › Vaccine: The Controversial Story of Medicine's Greatest Lifesaver by ss834
- › Pyur Diaper Balm by MimiPilla
- › Burt's Bees Mama Bee Belly Balm, Fragrance Free, by KatelynRose
- › Summer Infant Best View Handheld Color Video Monitor with 2.5"... by thebessmartinfo
- › Happy Heiny's One Size Cloth Diapers by SquirmyWorm
- › Homesteader's Kitchen, The: Recipes from Farm to Table by Monica S
- › Rainbow Light Just Once Prenatal One Multivitamin, 90 Tablets by glwilson22
- › Bear Stays Up for Christmas by rosemarievpaulson
- › Ten Tips for Surviving Two Under Two by Melanie Mayo
- › The Worry and Wonderment of Parenting by Melanie Mayo
- › 5 Surprising Benefits to Making a Pet a Part... by Melanie Mayo
- › Mining Joy from the Muck of Daily Mothering by Marcy Axness
- › Interview with Blair Lee, author by SavvyHomeschool
- › Mayim Bialik Opens Up About Her Breastfeeding... by Melanie Mayo
- › Freedom Together: Mothering Mavens Try Out... by Melanie Mayo
- › Magic Under the Table by BrainChild
- › So Precious It Hurts by Sheryl Paul
- › Is Your Child Ready to Read? A Checklist by Melanie Mayo