Posting in sympathy. I struggle with this. A lot.
I managed to get my book-buying habit under control by using the public library extensively. I rarely buy books anymore. Magazines are a different story for a few reasons. We participate in subscriptions sales for a fundraiser for the school. The school receives a donation for every subscription you buy, so we always take out at least a couple of subscriptions. I also like to receive a couple of overseas publications for sentimental reasons. They remind me of previous homes we've had and help me stay in touch. I'm always tempted to buy a magazine as a little treat for myself.
So my first suggestion, which I should follow myself but will have difficulty with, is to not buy magazines in the first place.
I do go through my stash from time to time, cut out the recipes and articles, and donate what's left to the local kindergarten (if most of the magazine is in good shape) or recycle. For recipes, instead of binders I use multi-pocket expanding file folders, similar to this one. Eg. One is for baking, and I use a separate pockets for cookies and bars, muffins and quick breads, yeast breads, pies and tarts, ice cream desserts, custards and puddings, and cakes. Another is for mains - seafood, chicken, pork, lamb, beef, meatless, soups and stews, salads. Etc. I find it's quicker and easier and more compact than binders. It does take a little time to fish out a specific recipe from the all of the clippings in a particular pocket though.
I will suggest that before you start ripping up old magazines, you check on-line for re-sale value. A few years ago, when we were decluttering for an overseas transfer, I decided it was time to purge my stash. I ripped through my hoard of 12 years' worth of Victoria magazine, saving a few recipes and articles but trashing the rest. I later found out that each issue sells on average for $10 to $12 and some of them for much, much more. Aside from a desire to look through the old copies (it was such a beautiful magazine!), it hurts to think how much money I threw away. It's one of the few decluttering episodes I truly regret.
I am happy that I managed to get rid of many other magazines that I don't miss at all, such as old copies of fashion and shelter magazines, a few years' worth of the Economist, a bunch of old news magazines. That stuff gets out-of-date quickly so I'm okay with letting it go.
Follow Mothering