As I work in Maternity and hear it all and absolutely love the subject of baby names, I have to say you ladies are excellent baby namers!!!! I love them all! I knew my names really, really early.
Alas, I am going with somewhat boring names but I have good reasons.
I am naming this baby all by myself and I have to admit, I like that end of it ;)
Anna Catherine, rock solid, not budging from this name
Anna for a number of reasons, No Anna in my family at all :) Part of our names make Anna too, shANNon, NAthAN, AustiN, brendAN, Does that make sense to everyone? I am so goofy like that, LOL. Ties us all together and I think it is beautiful and classic. She will be Anna, no ANNIE unless she so chooses as she gets older. Nathan is Nathan to us but Nate at school, he prefers that we call him Nathan :) Catherine was my beloved Grandmother who is the reason I am the woman I am. And she would have two half sisters (from dad), Emma and Sara. Anna goes so nicely with their names.
Evan Edward or Evan David, pretty darn sure anyway
Edward is the father of my baby and if he changes his mind at all about being involved, Edward will be the middle name. If he is definitely not going to be involved, David after my uncle who is also my Godfather.
Evan because all of our names end in N and I do not want this little boy to sound adopted into the family but I want him to feel connected especially since he will be 14 years younger than his next oldest brother. Evan is the only boy name ending in N that I like and can imagine having in my arms. I have liked it for a bunch of years.