Mothering › Mothering Discussion Forums › Parenting › Poll: "Child"/ "Family"/ or "Parent"-centered households
New Posts  All Forums:
 

Poll: "Child"/ "Family"/ or "Parent"-centered households - Page 2

Poll Results: Which best describes your house?

This is a multiple choice poll
  • 15% (9)
    I consider my home to be "child-centered"
  • 81% (48)
    I consider my home to be "family-cenetered"
  • 3% (2)
    I consider my home to be "parent-centered"
  • 5% (3)
    I grew up in a child-centered house
  • 33% (20)
    I grew up in a family centered house
  • 50% (30)
    I grew up in a parent-centered house
59 Total Votes  
post #21 of 24
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by kblackstone444 View Post

 

 

Do you have a friend who lives the "opposite" way, and if so, does it grate?  Or are you OK with it as long as it isn't *your* house?

 

My fiance is more parent oriented, though not as bad as my Mom was, thank God!  Of course, that was his upbringning.  I'm more along "change the environment to fit the two year old's needs" and he's more "tell the two year old not to touch the nicknacks or maybe we should put him in a playpen".  We're working on a compromise- more family oriented- before we marry.  

 

Oooooh!  There's a question that was missed!  

 

What about spouses/partners?  Do they have different styles?

 

 

 

 

And I keep thinking about this comment from kathymuggle:

Quote:
Family centered does not seem like an in-between term to me, it sound like a different one - more where the wants and needs of most of the family members are considered.

 

post #22 of 24

I'm keeping it short because my only child is 6 months old - we're definitely still figuring things out! But I'm interested to read other responses.

 

I chose "family-centered" more because that is my ideal. In reality, we are pretty child-centric at the moment simply because we have a difficult and young baby who requires a lot of time. As he is getting older and (in some ways) less demanding, we are working to reclaim some parent-space for ourselves. In my mind, "family-centered" means that the majority of decisions are based on what is best for the family as a unit, and it's not a parents-vs-kids situation. Neither is more important, and neither is UNimportant. Just due to the nature of adults vs kids, I expect that my husband and I will make more sacrifices to benefit the children than vice versa, but I do expect that our child(ren) will ultimately end up spending less time with us/getting less stuff/etc. than they might want because we have needs, too. Like the fact that I am already planning a trip to Disneyworld next year for my birthday without my son, because I want some time alone with my husband, and I've never been and want to go and have fun. I think family-centered living is all about balance, and balance is NOT going to mean equal time/means split between parents and kids. It does mean that neither side should feel like they are always "losing", or even like we are on different sides.

post #23 of 24

What sounds like the closest description to your house?  like others said today it is family centered. but when dd was younger of course it was child centered. 

 

If you feel in-between-y, why did you choose the description you did?  What kept you from identifying with another term?

however for us family centered means sometimes child centered, sometimes mommy centered (single parent here). as dd has grown i have gotten more of my needs met. but now that dd is hitting puberty i find it is kinda going back more towards child centered than mommy centered. esp. when she is having a hard day. i feel in our house we switch roles. somedays dd is the child and i am the mother. other times its me who is beign taken cared of when i am exhausted. both of us having hormone issues - mine menopause and dd puberty - has made us empathise each others situation. we both cant seem to help being a b**** sometimes. now that dd is going through the emotional aspect of puberty she understands how i feel sometimes too. 

 

Would other people describe your house the same way?  (For example, you might consider yourself "family-centered", whereas your zero-rules friend might see it as "parent centered".)

AH. most people think i do way too much child centered. that i spoil dd too much. my house should be a parent centered house. 

 

What are the good things you like about doing it this way?

dunno about good or bad. switching between parent centered and child centered keeps harmony, peace and love in our house. 

 

What are the drawbacks?  

 

If you attribute problems to your lifestyle, how do you deal with the negative aspects?  

no problems because our lifestyle evolved. i never thought of ok from tomorrow on it will be a family centered household. what really happened was that being a single mom i could not handle not getting my time. 

 

Do you have any regrets?

nope!!! though i wont really have them till dd is an adult and tells me of what her experience of childhood was, and how different it is from my memory. 

 

Why did you start living this way?  Philosophy?  Personality?  Response to immediate needs?  Rebelling against how your parents did it?

it really began with response to immediate need. dd was high needs and she taught me how to be her mother. i wanted to be her mother, not a mother. i have always loved children. i am fascinated with dd and i always try to write an instructions manual. just my curiosity towards this squirmy thing is what made me parent the way i do. plus as an anthropology student and seeing child rearing all around teh world it is so important to have a family centered hh. 

 

Is this different from how you grew up?

yes. mainly parent centered in my house but not in a v. drastic way. parents had last say, but they did try to be family centered. 

 

Do you have a friend who lives the "opposite" way, and if so, does it grate?  Or are you OK with it as long as it isn't *your* house?

ugh. it GRATES. coz its dd's dad's place. and it does a number on her when it isnt family centered. 

 

Do you consider your children to be flexible when they visit households with different expectations?  

yes absolutely. in fact dd has known since a toddler that every house has their own rules. 

 

Do you know how other people view your children?

yes i do. some think she is the cat's miaow. some think she is way too opinionated and should behave like a child. overall they do think she is well mannered and very respectful. and yes i do think living in two different households has definitely helped being able to stay open to others points of view. 

post #24 of 24
Quote:
Originally Posted by SweetSilver View Post

What sounds like the closest description to your house?  Family Centered, I think.  Although, after reading some descriptions, I'm not sure?  To me this means we work together as a family to solve problems.  We take the children's feelings into account when making decisions but in the same token, they need to respect our needs and feelings as well.  We all need chores around the house and admit we all have problems keeping our rooms clean or picking up our stuff from around the house.  To me being family centered means that sometimes the wants of the parents trumps the wants of the child and vice versa but we have all discussed it and are all on the same page about it.  As you can probably tell... we discuss and talk about things a LOT in our household. 

 

If you feel in-between-y, why did you choose the description you did?  What kept you from identifying with another term?  Chose it because it implied that everyone worked together to achieve a common goal- whether it be keeping the house clean or choosing the movie to watch.

 

Would other people describe your house the same way?  (For example, you might consider yourself "family-centered", whereas your zero-rules friend might see it as "parent centered".)  Some people would say I was more child centered, I think.  Especially when the kids were younger. 

 

What are the good things you like about doing it this way?  I like how much we talk together.  I like that I feel like we're "in this together" if we have a problem or need to find common ground on something.  I like that parents aren't always right in our house, if that makes any sense.  But it doesn't mean I never get tired and say to them "Look, please just do this because I'm feeling too tired to argue with you today!"

 

What are the drawbacks?  I have trouble pursuing my own things sometimes because I will miss my family.  I do, however, go out regularly with my husband for dinners, dancing, etc.

 

If you attribute problems to your lifestyle, how do you deal with the negative aspects?  There is what some people would call "an attitude" or "backtalk".  My son especially, and it's probably the age, will roll his eyes or get sarcastic.  I ignore a lot of stuff other parents might see as a problem.

 

Do you have any regrets?  Since I fell into this naturally and it feels instinctive to me, I don't think I would have regrets. 

 

Why did you start living this way?  Philosophy?  Personality?  Response to immediate needs?  Rebelling against how your parents did it?  Attachment parenting, unconditional parenting, How to Talk... all those books really just felt right to me.  They validated what I already felt about parenting in general.  As my children got past the baby stage, we went from more child centered to more family centered. 

 

Is this different from how you grew up? 

 

Do you have a friend who lives the "opposite" way, and if so, does it grate?  Or are you OK with it as long as it isn't *your* house?  If it grated on me, I probably wouldn't go there in the first place but I'm pretty laid back.  I don't punish my children- we definitely follow a more natural consequences route (or logical if I'm unwilling to deal with natural consequences- like I'd rather help an unwilling child with homework everyday than let them fail if their teacher tells me they're struggling in a class).  but I get frustrated when a child's friend is grounded for the weekend or is being punished in a way that prevents them from seeing my kids because it ends up punishing my child as well. 

 

Do you consider your children to be flexible when they visit households with different expectations?  Yes.  I will probably hear about it later, though.  whistling.gif

 

Do you know how other people view your children?  I have been told I have polite, adaptable, easy going children.  I think I do, too! I think personality plays a role in this as well as parenting style, though. 

 

 

I'm excited to hear your responses, and look forward to the conversation, but please

 

Keep it sweet! blowkiss.gif

New Posts  All Forums:
 
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Parenting
Mothering › Mothering Discussion Forums › Parenting › Poll: "Child"/ "Family"/ or "Parent"-centered households