That's really not what I see happening in this thread. Here's my Cliff Notes version of how the discussion has gone:
"Here's a great book I found. Discussion?"
"Sounds awesome. Doubt it would work for my kids, though."
"I think it might work. Maybe you're misunderstanding the approach..."
"Oh, thanks for the clarification. Interesting. Still not sure it will work, but I definitely plan to draw on some of the ideas."
"Let us know how it works out."
ETA: My youngest was toying with the possibility of doing a 1-to-2 week trial of school this spring, to see if she'd like to attend next year. Ultimately she decided not to bother with the trial, because after she got out of her late-winter funk she was almost certain she'd want to continue unschooling next year.