or Connect
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Welcome to Mothering! › Site Help › Kudos, Thumbs-up, or...?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Kudos, Thumbs-up, or...? - Page 3

Poll Results: What should we name the Reputation feature?

 
  • 29% (25)
    Kudos
  • 59% (51)
    Thumbs-up
  • 11% (10)
    Other (please post your suggestion)
86 Total Votes  
post #41 of 65
Quote:
Originally Posted by prescottchels View Post

I liked "a like" until it was mentioned that it wouldn't be grammatically correct in other instances on the site so I'm back to "thumbs up" as I've never been a fan of the word "kudos" I don't know what it is about that word that just makes me want to scream shy.gif

Yeah, something about the word "kudos," despite the definition listed upthread, feels too much like a pat on the head, as in, "Congrats for having that thought!" lol.gif

I think "likes" could work, as in, "Limabean gave you likes for your post in Parenting," but thumbs-up or props work for me too.

Of course, even better would be to eliminate the extra words and have it just be, "Limabean likes your post in Parenting," but it sounds like the phrasing is written in e-stone?
Edited by limabean - 6/30/13 at 9:51am
post #42 of 65
How about applause?
post #43 of 65
Quote:
Originally Posted by SweetSilver View Post

Except the term "cookies" already has a specific meaning on the internet.

Brownies then? yummy.gif

post #44 of 65
Another forum I'm on that has a similar thing calls it "thanks."
post #45 of 65

How about Hugs? Sometimes that's what I want to give someone when I push that. Though isn't that what another parenting site uses? I wish there was a Hug and a Like both, because sometimes I don't want to hug, just like.... So thumbs up might be better?

post #46 of 65
Hugs is more of a sympathy response isn't it? Generally when I see someone start their reply with "Hugs, mama" it is because the OP is having a hard time.
post #47 of 65
So I just got some "reputation" today. orngbiggrin.gif

I think that something that clearly connotes "I liked this post because it was awesome and the community needs to see its awesomeness" type of thing would be best, because I got some reputation just this morning, and when I went to my post, the little thing says "See who found this helpful."
post #48 of 65
Appreciation? It's the same type of word as reputation, doesn't make me feel like I'm bestowing gold stars on people but lets people simply know I like their posts.
post #49 of 65
I like "mad props." Or even just "props" would be cool.
Quote:
Originally Posted by SweetSilver View Post

Mad props makes me laugh.  But I'm not sure I would understand it out of context.  And it's short for...?

I know Cynthia already gave a definition, but just for a little more info, "props" is short for "propers" or "proper respect." As in, Aretha Franklin's Respect:

"I'm about to give you all of my money / And all I'm askin' in return, honey / Is to give me my propers / When you get home"

(Oddly, several lyrics pages that I found online said "give me my profits," which is incorrect and doesn't even make sense.)

"Mad" just means "very" or "a lot." Urban Dictionary compared it to "hella" from California, or "wicked" from Boston. (In case you can't tell, I love language!)
post #50 of 65
Quote:
Originally Posted by michelleepotter View Post

I like "mad props." Or even just "props" would be cool.
I know Cynthia already gave a definition, but just for a little more info, "props" is short for "propers" or "proper respect." As in, Aretha Franklin's Respect:

"I'm about to give you all of my money / And all I'm askin' in return, honey / Is to give me my propers / When you get home"

(Oddly, several lyrics pages that I found online said "give me my profits," which is incorrect and doesn't even make sense.)

It always sounded like "problems" to me, LOL.
post #51 of 65

My vote is for "props" or "mad props,"  but "a like" will do. 

post #52 of 65

If you don't like the connotations around "Thumbs-up", how about "High-Five"?

 

I also like "kudos." 

post #53 of 65
"Kudos" makes me think of that candy bar or granola bar or whatever it was that we ate alot as kids. I don't like it at all for this purpose. Besides, "thumbs up" has such a cute little icon already. What would the icon be for "kudos"?

I vote for mad props. Seriously. And I'm gonna give kudos to the person who suggested it!
post #54 of 65
Quote:
Originally Posted by blessedwithboys View Post

What would the icon be for "kudos"?
A dessert-ish granola bar, of course. lol.gif:
post #55 of 65

I like Mad Props or Props

Kudos is also nice

Like is good too.

 

 

Really, I like all the suggestions, so that isn't terribly helpful is it?

post #56 of 65
i actually really like the current "reputation" b/c it connotes that you are reputable, which is far different from being popular, snarky, or any things that are normally used on other sites (where mob mentality can frequently sort rudeness to the top). i like that we want to encourage people to post things that are wise, helpful, compassionate, etc. (which makes this site sit far above pretty much any other forum site i've ever been a part of), and that we consider someone reputable who does this. it is an evaluation of the quality of their comment, as opposed to being randomly congratulatory. it just really struck me as yet another way that mothering rises above the rest of the chatter online, and "like", "kudos", and "thumbs up" all feel generic, and would not set give that same feeling of setting a higher bar. well, that's my two cents!
post #57 of 65
Quote:
Originally Posted by filamentary View Post

i actually really like the current "reputation" b/c it connotes that you are reputable, which is far different from being popular, snarky, or any things that are normally used on other sites (where mob mentality can frequently sort rudeness to the top). i like that we want to encourage people to post things that are wise, helpful, compassionate, etc. (which makes this site sit far above pretty much any other forum site i've ever been a part of), and that we consider someone reputable who does this.

That's an interesting take on it. I agree that the word carries that connotation, but I'm not sure it plays out that way in practice. People tend to click the thumbs up icon just to indicate that they agree with a post, even if they only agree because it was a particularly eloquent way of snarking at another poster, you know?
post #58 of 65

I vote for mad props. I also like cred.

post #59 of 65
on first inspection, i like "cred", b/c it carries the same connotation as "reputation". to have, for instance, "street cred" means that you have a good reputation. but "cred" is short for "credentials", and that's far more formal-sounding than "reputation". if they just put "cred", though, they'll inevitably have to explain to some people that it doesn't stand for "credit", that it's not a redeemable unit of credit or anything like that. and even beyond that, it is imprecise. we've earned credentials? of what variety? reputation, on the other hand, is exactly what we are saying. the more times someone clicks the icon after something you've said, the more highly reputed you are. and likewise, the more reputable a given comment you make in another thread (where perhaps folks aren't familiar with you) can be considered to be.

if we wanna get away from all this formality stuff, though, how bout something ridiculously cute like "bump", (cute the eye rolls please!) b/c it brings to mind both fist bumps and baby bumps? orngbiggrin.gif
post #60 of 65
Quote:
Originally Posted by filamentary View Post

if we wanna get away from all this formality stuff, though, how bout something ridiculously cute like "bump", (cute the eye rolls please!) b/c it brings to mind both fist bumps and baby bumps? orngbiggrin.gif

Clever! It also brings to mind bumping a thread to the top. smile.gif

ETA: I thought "cred" was short for credibility. You're right that mods would have to explain it.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Site Help
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Welcome to Mothering! › Site Help › Kudos, Thumbs-up, or...?