- topicGentle Disciplinetagged by mamazee, 9/2/13
Related Forum Threads
- "Gentle discipline breeds wild kids." Last post on 11/22/13 at 1:50pm in Gentle Discipline
- Help with Tantrums and Crying Fits in 6 Year Old? Last post on 10/21/13 at 12:14am in Gentle Discipline
- Help, four year old hitting me and throwing things at me when angry Last post on 10/10/13 at 9:12am in Gentle Discipline
- Do you agree with taking away video games and computer for not turning in homework assignments... Last post on 11/4/13 at 3:57pm in Preteens and Teens
- My Emotional 5 YO DD Has Me at a Loss Last post on 9/24/13 at 9:18am in Parenting
Time Out from Time Out
Last edited: 11/14/13
- Kids in the House: the New Video Resource for FamiliesLast edited: 9/26/13
- Teaching Kids to Love and Trust ThemselvesLast edited: 7/23/13
- Agreeing to Disagree: Gentle Parenting Despite Criticism from Loved...Last edited: 7/16/13
- Pizza and Big EmotionsLast edited: 7/8/13
What does 'gentle discipline' mean to you?post #1 of 59/2/13 at 8:04amThread Starterpost #2 of 59/2/13 at 9:59amI don't use time outs but I definitely think they can be done gently. The only things I don't consider part of gentle discipline are things that involve physical punishment and anything involving something emotionally destructive like humiliation. Human beings have a variety of emotions so I don't think someone who loses his/her temper and yells occasionally is not practicing gentle discipline so long as they aren't destructive and apologize for losing their temper and take responsibility for it. I try to get myself somewhere I can calm down before I reach that point but I am sure I yell out of frustration occasionally. If I do, I apologize and say I lost my temper - not that my child made me yell. To blame the child for it would be destructive. But screaming or yelling at your child as a discipline technique is not gentle.
My kids are 11 and 4 and it's working out well. There are obviously frustrations but I don't see more with my kids than with kids parented with other discipline styles.
I decided not to use time outs largely because they weren't gentle for us specifically due to my daughter's temperament. She would get very physical in resisting being put in or staying in time out, and it would have been more physical and violent than a spanking in that situation, so I had to work things out without them.
I do like the idea of "time in" where a parent and a child sit together somewhere quiet to let the child calm down better than time out, but that might not work well for some kids just like time outs wouldn't with my spirited kid. My younger kid would probably sit in time out but I'm not used to dealing with things in that way at this point.post #3 of 59/2/13 at 1:26pm
our boys are 4y.o and 18months old.
GD for us is working/living with the kids, not against them.
our relationship with the kids is our tool for discipline.
I beleive that kids are always ''good'', they never want to be mean, they strive to please us and learn from us.
all we have to do for discipline is : maintaining a good and conncted relationship with our kids, model the behavior we want to teach and fill their physical and emotional needs.
They do the rest!post #4 of 59/2/13 at 7:52pm
I don't think gd is a check off list of not doing something or always doing something (with the exception of not spanking and not using verbally or emotionally abusive techniques), it is more a process of taking into account the child's needs and desires along with our own boundaries and being reflective in how you parent and the effect of my actions on the child as a whole person.
I lean a lot towards Alfie Kohn's work and love his framework on being reflective when deciding on the boundaries we decide are necessary for our families. I also like Myrna Shure's work and the book How to Talk so Kids Will Listen and Listen so Kids Will Talk. I also like some of the Love and Logic approach because it helped me to be more laid back about letting my dd know what I was willing to do and not do then letting her make her own choices from there without constant nagging about the possible consequences.
In actual practice most of what I do with my dd is listen actively, support her as she makes different plans and discovers her growing interests, observe, reflect, talk, give her a lot of one on one time, and slowly let up on some the boundaries that make up our lives. She is ten and this has worked very well for us so far with some bumps at a few stages where she made enormous developmental jumps.post #5 of 59/3/13 at 3:00am
Well I think it means listening to your kids, looking at your kids, seeing what they need.
I also think that if you love your kids, think about your relationship with them, take enough care of yourself and apologise, and try to work out how not to do it again, when you screw up, then you are probably going to be doing as well as anyway. (obviously if you are hitting your kids or yelling dreadful stuff it might be time to get some help).
Of course it looks different at different ages. I think to send a 10 year old to their room for being monstrously rude to everyone else for the seventh time that day is an entirely different event to making a two year old sit with an egg timer on a step.
I also think a kid who is loved, who has confident, happy parents who genuinely, for the most part, like to have them in their lives, who is part of a family that works things out but also knows when to stop overanalysing, is not likely to have such fragile self esteem that they can't cope when their parents yell occasionally or whatever. And if they do-either becaue they are just like that or because of other factors-, I think they are well placed to recover that self esteem.
- Kids in the House: the New Video Resource for Families
- › Welcome Babies! 1 minute ago
- › Enter the Hyland's Holiday Challenge! 5 minutes ago
- › 7 m.o. Vampire. Ouch. 19 minutes ago
- › We lost the baby 20 minutes ago
- › December chat - those still hanging around! 21 minutes ago
- › how to handle child favoring one parent over the other? 29 minutes ago
- › How long were your labors? 30 minutes ago
- › Possibly a stupid question from a newbie about cloth stash 31 minutes ago
- › Weight gain 31 minutes ago
- › The Fertility Challenged One Thread 37 minutes ago
- › Bear Stays Up for Christmas by rosemarievpaulson
- › The Night Before Christmas by rjdoghouse
- › The Polar Express by sassyfirechick
- › Polar Express by Melanie Mayo
- › The Return of the Light: Twelve Tales from Around the World for the... by Terry Stafford
- › The Shortest Day: Celebrating the Winter Solstice by Terry Stafford
- › The Diaper-Free Baby: The Natural Toilet Training Alternative by Fembot
- › The Snow Queen by Astraia
- › The Snowy Day by janonia
- › Christmas in the Big Woods by Melanie Mayo
- › Five Free, Festive Ways to Have Fun at Christmas by Monica S
- › Cosleeping in a Coca-Cola Commercial by Brian Leaf
- › Terms and Conditions: BabyKicks and The... by Cynthia Mosher
- › Should You Care About the Photo of Gisele... by Monica S
- › Christmas Through Their Eyes by AmandaK
- › 6 Mistakes People Make When a Friend's... by momofnatasha
- › Hyland's Holiday Challenge Mothering... by JenniO11
- › Lead in Christmas Lights, Toxic Decorations... by Amy Serotkin
- › Can Attachment Parents Put Their Own... by KidsInTheHouse
- › Phases of a Nursling by OliviaHinebaugh