It looks like your post might have been missed, so I wanted to bump it up for attention. Anyone have a recommendation to share? mamarea, you might also want to post in our Illinois forum to get more input from moms from your area.
Have you checked out Raising Natural Kids on facebook? If you like their page you can look through their photo albums. I know they have one for vaccines where their members can post the name of their anti-vax doctor and state that they live in. Also- check out The Vaccine Machine on facebook. That is an excellent page for non-vaxers and I believe you can private message the admin asking for recommendation of an anti-vax doctor and they'll repost it for their followers to see and give you a recommendation.