The two "standard" homebirth choices in central Ohio are CHOICE and BORN. Both do waterbirths. CHOICE has been around forever and BORN is a relatively new spinoff with former CHOICE midwives. I believe each does a free consultation where they will just it and talk to you about your birth options, answer questions etc.
The biggest problem I think you'll find is that if you opt against a homebirth your OB choices are just about zero :( Every single friend of mine, without exception, has been induced and they all used different docs. Stay away from Riverside hospital whatever you do. They are a baby factory and their c-section rate is really high (so is OSU's) :( There are also the midwives at OSU. I know nothing about them so cannot comment, but maybe someone else on the forum can help you.
I am 1 1/2 hrs from Cols. I do births in Cols. from time to time when CHOICE gets busy. I have kids & grandkids living there, so am there frequently anyway.
Last month I transported a mom to Grant. Well she had a vaginal birth, but the docs technique was atrocious, IMHO, She pulled & tugged on the head as soon as it was out, w/o waiting for the restitution to happen with the next ctx, causing a really bad 3rd degree tear! It made me sick to see how rough she was on the poor baby & mom. So I wouldn't recommend Grant. Didn't get the docs name, but she was the on call resident, so just gets who walks through the door, but doesn't yet have a private practice. There were 3 docs in the room. The resident who did the birth, a student (who she was teaching! agh!) and the head guy who watched it all to make sure she was doing it "right" (gag!). Mt Carmel/St Anne's was pretty nice to my dd when she showed up 9cms in labor at 35 wks with twins, & had not seen anyone but me for prenatal care. She managed to have a natural birth in spite of the fact one of the twins was transverse (doc brought him out by the feet as soon as the 1st one was born). They stayed in her room for the 3 days they were there, Never needed NICU, & only went to the nursery briefly, for vitals, shots (ugh!) & a "car seat test" which they do on all preemie babies before they let them go home. My other dd used that hosp as well, & was very pleased with her care.
I am also using the midwives at Carepoint Gahanna. We'll see how it goes--I've heard great things about them.
I would offer just a small counter to Pinkyfinx: my last birth, I used Dr. Kathryn Pool of Olentangy OB-GYN. I wouldn't call her crunchy by any means, but she was open minded and sensitive to my concerns when it came to my desire for a more natural birth. She was willing to let me go 10 days past my due date before induction. Not perfect, perhaps, but good for an OB. She acknowledged that it was a little beyond her comfort zone but she recognized it was important to me. I went into labor a couple days before my due date, so it was a non-issue, but I appreciated that she was open to hearing my concerns and explaining her perspective to me at the same time. Her c-section rate is 10%. My current midwives and doula have all said they really respect her practice (she works with Dr. Paige Turner), and when the midwife option opened up this time around (they weren't covered by my insurance before), Dr. Pool said "That's a great practice, you should feel good about transferring to them." (She actually tried to convince me to go to Dayton for a birth center birth before, but I didn't want to change practices late in the game.)
There is also an OB in Delaware who is supposedly very supportive of natural birth practices. I forget his name--maybe starts with an H? My doula said he was fantastic, but said the catch was he had a very busy practice and if he happened to be unavailable when you went into labor, you didn't know who you would get.
I delivered at OSU and had a very positive experience. A couple of the nurses were going through midwife training (through OSU's program) and everyone was very respectful of my birth plan and requests for privacy and quiet. They had a lactation consultant who was really helpful after the birth and are supportive of rooming-in/kangaroo care. The only thing that sucked was the round-the-clock interruptions after the birth to check blood pressure, etc.--very hard to rest, but that's just hospitals. I did end up getting an epidural, and was glad I did (had been up all night and was really struggling with exhaustion but couldn't rest because of pain), but this time I'm excited to see how far I get with the waterbirth option.
I don't know what OSU's c-section rate is--I would think it has more to do with the doctor than the hospital--but if it is high, maybe it's because they handle all the high risk transfers for the region?
The midwives at Carepoint Gahanna are awesome. I saw them at the previous location as well, so I've been with one of them for about 5 years now. They come to the hospital as soon as you're admitted and stay the whole time you're in labor. They're the only group in the area that offers waterbirth at the hospital. Their standard care is low-intervention. I didn't love delivering at OSU, but it was well worth it to be with them. I really can't say enough good about them. Here's a couple of their websites.
Becky was on call when I was in labor. You do just get who ever is on call, but they're all great. My last labor (and this too) was very fast, so she actually left right after I phoned her and arrived at the hospital as soon as I did. She was there the minute I stepped into the triage room. My biggest disclaimer is that I didn't get to actually utilize their help that much. But the 15 minutes that she helped me during labor was still totally different than my last 15 minute hospital labor initially with a resident and then a very laid-back OB. I had absolutely no interventions and pushed standing up until about the last 2 contractions when she wanted me on my side because we were in a hurry at that point due to low heart tones. The nurses gave the baby a bit of oxygen and had her on a warming table for a while to get her going, but Becky kept checking on her numbers and saying it sounded like she was ready for skin-to-skin -- in other words, I felt like she had my back.
They do all the normal, standard things that OBs do at prenatals, but I think when you talk to them about philosophy and how they do birth, you'll see a huge difference. It's HUGE that they come right away. I think that the other big advantage is that low intervention is their standard. You don't have to fight for anything at the hospital, because they just do it that way. Pat gave me a sample birth plan which was very crunchy -- eating and drinking during labor, no pain meds, delayed cord clamping, breastfeeding, anti-circ -- the whole bit. Cassandra recommend spinning babies and was going to refer me to a chiropractor if my baby stayed breech for one more appointment. They don't check you cervix before labor starts unless you ask. They're also big on informed choice; if you want to talk about not doing something, or doing it differently it's fine. My only complaints are occasional long wait times for appointments, and I prefer a less noisy, less busy hospital. Best wishes!