Originally Posted by ian'smommaya
and the garbage pail kids, the cards stank so much! I think that was kinda the point tho.
You mean they actually had an odor? I don't remember that -- gross! My mom wouldn't let us have those but I saw them at school. Some were really morbid -- I didn't like them either.
All clown stuff scared me as a kid. Also, this wasn't a scary toy but I had one of those clip-on koala bears clipped to my bedpost, and I used to think it moved at night so that it was looking at me when I woke up in the morning, which freaked me out. (But not enough to move it or throw it away, so I think I was just freaking myself out over nothing for the thrill of it.)
I can't really think of any other scary toys, but my friends and I used to do Bloody Mary in the bathroom, and games like "light as a feather/stiff as a board," and ouija boards and the like.