or Connect
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Mom › Parenting › Stay at Home Parents › Pool at MIL's house - wwyd?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Pool at MIL's house - wwyd?

Poll Results: Would you leave your toddler at a relative's house with an un-fenced pool?

 
  • 4% (2)
    Yes, absolutely. What's the problem?? My toddler would NEVER go near a pool!
  • 20% (10)
    Yes, with restrictions. I'd ask MIL to have them only play INDOORS, nowhere near the pool.
  • 75% (36)
    No way in hell. Drowning statistics don't lie: "Children younger than 5 represent nearly 75% of pool and spa deaths"
48 Total Votes  
post #1 of 27
Thread Starter 

I'm in need of some serious perspective or at least a venue in which to vent. MIL has complained to DH that I don't let her watch our kids at her home. I mean, I would let my 7 yo but not my 2 yo. The reason? She has a gigantic pool in her backyard that is not fenced. When DS was born years ago, I asked her about putting up a fence to keep DS out (because when he was super little he would go right up to the pool) and she said no because it wouldn't "look right" with her garden design.... banghead.gif   So.... I didn't really leave him with her at her home alone until he knew how to swim.

 

Fast forward to today. She's still peeved that I won't drop the kids off at her house, but she won't come to our house to watch them either. DH says it's because she has a huge house with a huge yard and why would she want to slum it in our teeny tiny 2 bedroom house??

 

Anyway, I guess I'm just venting, but I really am feeling resentful that DH is pissed at me because I won't do it. Am I being too paranoid here?? I have no qualms about hanging out WITH them at her house, because I'd watch my toddler like a hawk, but I'm not 100% sure MIL would do the same on her own (she is in her 70s and has a HUGE home, lots of places for the kids to explore/get lost in). Plus, if I do go over there to visit, I'm sure she'd just see it as me not trusting her to watch them, when the truth is I trust her fine, I don't trust my TODDLER not to go near the pool, and everyone knows how toddlers tend to wander!!

 

Sorry, I'm starting to rant and rave. Perspective, please. WWYD?

post #2 of 27
I wouldn't unless she child proofed it some how. Are there covers strong enough for a toddler not to fall through that they wouldn't be able to remove? I'm totally clueless about pool equipment.

I can sympathise. My MIL lives in a 4th story condo and has furniture right by the railing of her balcony my toddler loves to climb on. She complains when I move it and doesn't understand why I won 't let her watch him there. I just flat out told her it's not happening unless she gets a childproof lock on the door to the balcony. I'm sure she's not happy with me, but that's OK.
post #3 of 27

(I will laugh if I see any clicks on the "Well MY toddler would never...")

 

Nope. I couldn't. I just wouldn't feel safe. Luckily I have yet to be put in that situation and hope to never be but there are just certain things you have to look out for

post #4 of 27
NOPE.

I'm generally laid back about things, but an older woman, huge house ad her blasé attitude tell me this is a bad idea. No way she'd be able to police it well enough.
post #5 of 27

If your MIL cannot understand your concern, that's a problem. I'm sure she is a responsible person, but at 70 years old, she just simply isn't fast enough to grab a toddler if she is more than an arms reach away. She needs to realize this and understand that it is not a criticism. It is a fact. A tragedy can happen in a split second. You are doing the right thing.

post #6 of 27
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by CuddleBug'sMama View Post

I wouldn't unless she child proofed it some how. Are there covers strong enough for a toddler not to fall through that they wouldn't be able to remove? I'm totally clueless about pool equipment.

I can sympathise. My MIL lives in a 4th story condo and has furniture right by the railing of her balcony my toddler loves to climb on. She complains when I move it and doesn't understand why I won 't let her watch him there. I just flat out told her it's not happening unless she gets a childproof lock on the door to the balcony. I'm sure she's not happy with me, but that's OK.

Yikes, the 4th story condo with furniture by the railing would freak me out, too. I don't know what it is... why can't they understand we're just trying to keep our kids safe???

post #7 of 27
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by erinmattsmom88 View Post
 

"...at 70 years old, she just simply isn't fast enough to grab a toddler if she is more than an arms reach away."

YES! I have seen her in action with my niece, who is 3 yrs old. She gets distracted and flustered easily when she loses track of her. And, AND... this niece of mine FELL INTO THE POOL with FIVE adults around. Luckily, her daddy saved her. Just goes to show how easily accidents can happen! But it's just turned into a "oh, you're just a hover mother and you don't play nice with MIL, and it's you being anti-social.... blah blah blah" I can't stand it!!!!!!!!!!!!

post #8 of 27

So, I voted before reading the post.  Not sure if I can change my post to "hell no" but I would.  For one thing, she isn't even willing to make some minor changes (childproofing in some way whether it be door alarms or a childproof pool fence) in order to make you feel more comfortable.  Second, she is old enough that a little one could very easily get away from her.  When I was married to my first husband, we had a pool (& a pond and a creek) in our old house.  I don't think there was one minute that I didn't worry about one of the kids getting out a door, window or away from me and getting in.  My DH now lost a son at age three.  He drowned in their brand new in-ground pool that had not had the childproof cover put on yet.  They had door alarms, but they were off.  There were 3 adults and 8 children in the house.  My point is, my DH is a super responsible parent.  A child can get away from you at any time.  It simply can happen to anyone.  I would not take the risk, especially when she is so reluctant to do anything to protect them.

post #9 of 27

No. You can't be that casual about little kids around water. I'm not sure I'd even be okay with the 7 year old being there without me! Being able to swim a bit is almost as bad as not being able to swim at all... they will go on the diving board over and over and not realize how tired they're getting, and all of a sudden they can't make it to the edge. Then what if they panic instead of flipping on their back to float until they get their energy back? Some 7 year olds are probably great swimmers, my kids still needed direct supervision at that age. They didn't have enough experience in the water yet, and my son in particular had a bunch of confidence without the skills to back it up.

 

We had a situation here where my husband didn't agree with what I considered to be an obvious precaution we needed to take, and the solution was eventually to just not talk about it anymore. It was important enough to me to lay down the law and let him be bent out of shape and it was no longer up for discussion because we were going in circles. I'm not going to budge on it so it was just causing bad feelings over and over. It sounds like in your situation, there's a few things that could change to make you okay with the kids being at the grandmas house, so I'd re-open the conversation only if/when those things were happening. If she decides to put a fence in, or have the house alarm on while the kids are there so they can't get out without her knowing immediately, etc. that would change things. The kids will both eventually be old enough to stay at her place, that would change things, too. But as long as the disagreement has stagnated there is no point in rehashing it all the time, it might be best to just NOT engage in the conversation.

post #10 of 27

Honestly, even with door alarms I wouldn't leave my toddler...as another poster said, door alarms only work if they're on.  We're traveling with my mother and mother-in-law and staying at a house with an unfenced pool, and I've already told DH that our kids can't be there without me or him present.....my mother is slow and his mother is distracted so I can't assure their safety.  Don't budge on this...you'll never forgive yourself if something terrible happened.

post #11 of 27
Thread Starter 

Thanks so much for the sympathy and feedback mamas... I'm feeling a tad more justified in my stubborness not to give in here!!

 

DH just pointed out to me that MIL had *some* removable fences put in (they slide in and out or can be easily detached). They are not "to code" pool fences, rather, they are like short gates that block the main walkways to the pool. (There are garden beds that can be crawled through that still can allow access to the pool. Her fences are jerry-rig things that "look" more visually appealing than the standard 5 ft high pool fence.) 

 

Question is, am I comfortable enough with these cobbled together gates to leave kiddos alone with her? Or should I still be worried???? Argghhhh.... why can't she just put up a regular pool fence that follows the law?? It drives me crazy!


Edited by JustSo - 1/8/14 at 3:25pm
post #12 of 27
Quote:
Originally Posted by JustSo View Post
 

YES! I have seen her in action with my niece, who is 3 yrs old. She gets distracted and flustered easily when she loses track of her. And, AND... this niece of mine FELL INTO THE POOL with FIVE adults around. Luckily, her daddy saved her. Just goes to show how easily accidents can happen! But it's just turned into a "oh, you're just a hover mother and you don't play nice with MIL, and it's you being anti-social.... blah blah blah" I can't stand it!!!!!!!!!!!!

This right here makes it a "Hell no". Her granddaughter fell into the pool, needed to be rescued by an able bodied adult (is she fast enough and strong enough to rescue the child?) and she still doesn't see the concern? I wonder if she's not willing to accept that she's aged and isn't as able as she used to be? I know that my dad has a very hard time accepting his limits. She may want to believe that she's still fast enough to catch a toddler and definitely strong enough to be able to save a child who's fallen in, that doesn't mean she is.

 

Quote:
Originally Posted by JustSo View Post

Question is, am I comfortable enough with these cobbled together gates to leave kiddos alone with her? Or should I still be worried???? Argghhhh.... why can't she just put up a regular pool fence that follows the law?? It drives me crazy!

Is she breaking the law by not having a fenced in pool, or would she be breaking the law if she had children? (I know that the law can be stricter about children's bedrooms and such) If she's actually breaking the law by not having the fence- yeesh.

 

 

It sounds like you already have your answer, though- you aren't confident that these gates would keep your child out. If you knew that they would, that'd be one thing. The only reason you're considering it is because of pressure. It's really unfortunate that your husband doesn't realize the very real danger. :(

post #13 of 27
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by sillysapling View Post
 

This right here makes it a "Hell no". Her granddaughter fell into the pool, needed to be rescued by an able bodied adult (is she fast enough and strong enough to rescue the child?) and she still doesn't see the concern? I wonder if she's not willing to accept that she's aged and isn't as able as she used to be? I know that my dad has a very hard time accepting his limits. She may want to believe that she's still fast enough to catch a toddler and definitely strong enough to be able to save a child who's fallen in, that doesn't mean she is.

 

Is she breaking the law by not having a fenced in pool, or would she be breaking the law if she had children? (I know that the law can be stricter about children's bedrooms and such) If she's actually breaking the law by not having the fence- yeesh.

 

 

It sounds like you already have your answer, though- you aren't confident that these gates would keep your child out. If you knew that they would, that'd be one thing. The only reason you're considering it is because of pressure. It's really unfortunate that your husband doesn't realize the very real danger. :(

Damn straight it's a very real danger. I have just come to the conclusion that I will not bend on this issue. *I* am the mom and I'll continue to follow my "mother's instinct" with this situation, as I do for all other situations. If she doesn't like it, it's not my problem. It's hers.

post #14 of 27

Maybe cause im in az but not even with a fence no pool without me no way 

post #15 of 27
Wow, I can't believe she hasn't been called on that by her city or homeowners insurance! Here even wading pools over a certain gallon capacity have to be fenced, and we don't even live in a hot area where most houses have them.

To answer your question- not just no but HELL NO. If she doesn't see the danger there, especially after a near tragedy right there in front of her, I would question her judgement in other things. If she really wants to babysit it won't hurt her to hang out in a house with 'only' two bedrooms for awhile. I'm sorry your DH isn't on board. We have a similar situation; MIL is not allowed to babysit either, but thankfully Dh is in complete agreement. I'm quite jealous of people who have Grandparents that can and will babysit!
post #16 of 27
Quote:
Originally Posted by JustSo View Post
 

YES! I have seen her in action with my niece, who is 3 yrs old. She gets distracted and flustered easily when she loses track of her. And, AND... this niece of mine FELL INTO THE POOL with FIVE adults around. Luckily, her daddy saved her. Just goes to show how easily accidents can happen! But it's just turned into a "oh, you're just a hover mother and you don't play nice with MIL, and it's you being anti-social.... blah blah blah" I can't stand it!!!!!!!!!!!!


Stick to your guns mama!  If all mothers were "hover mothers" we wouldn't have to read about so many tragedies in the papers!

Me: proud hover mother!:rotflmao

post #17 of 27
Quote:
Originally Posted by gardendweller View Post
 


Stick to your guns mama!  If all mothers were "hover mothers" we wouldn't have to read about so many tragedies in the papers!

Me: proud hover mother!:rotflmao

 

You dont have to be a hover mother to have enough common sense to not let your child go to a house with a pool that has no childproofing. 

post #18 of 27
This happened to me! My husbands mom
Has a pool with no fence or gate around it. My three year at the time could very easily walk right up the ladder and jump in. My MIL did not supervise her two other grandchildren who were 3 and 6 and just let them play out back by themselves. Granted she lives in the middle if nowhere on 20 acres the whole situation made me nervous. There is also a creek on her property. Nope I would not leave my daughter with her in the summer when the pools up. I still think I will not and she's 5 now! She knows she can't go in.the water without an adult but she's 5!!! She may think she's a super swimmer and do it anyway.
post #19 of 27

About 30 years ago, my husband and his siblings were playing in the pool at their home in Florida. His niece, then a baby, managed to get into the pool area and slipped into the pool without anyone seeing. Her mother saw her and got her out and saved her life.

 

This was with a pool full of people! It was not willful negligence. A child had forgotten to close the gate to the pool area. This happened within a minute or so of time.

 

Your husband can go kick rocks. Why does he care more about MIL and her fee fees than your child and her safety? Does a tragic event need to happen?

post #20 of 27

The pool issue is a scary and you have to trust your gut. I can see the mil getting defensive though and bitter but without you being there, it's just too much of a risk. We live in a home that has a pool in the backyard and not much play space. My mil owns the home and we rent from her. When she moved out and we moved in I asked for a fence but I lost that battle between her and my husband because of the "aesthetics". I feel my kids are safe though because the doors are locked and they can't reach the safety features. However, if it was switched and I was dropping the kids off here, I probably would not do it. She just came to visit last week and she left the kids outside in the sandbox, luckily I was around to notice and went out there. Accidents happen! My 6 year old can swim but 3 year old, no way! I can just picture him falling in and the oldest jumping in to save him and uhh tragic thought.

 

 If it's a few hours she watching them couldn't they go on an outing or something? I think the kids would much rather go to a park or museum, zoo anything. But then again there is that safety risk too.

New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Stay at Home Parents
Mothering › Mothering Forums › Mom › Parenting › Stay at Home Parents › Pool at MIL's house - wwyd?