With my first child, my water breaking was my first sign of labor. Contractions started about 30 minutes later. Just from reading some threads around here, I've gathered that it's not ideal for your water to break first/early in labor. Does anyone know why? Are there things you can do to keep that from happening? Just curious as I've never heard this before.
Water breaking first
My water has broken all 3 times while pushing so have I never experienced water breaking first. I'm guessing that maybe some people don't like that because if your water breaks and you don't go into labor soon after some caregivers will get nervous/anxious about the baby? Someone else will chime in that knows more :)
Yeah, that and risk of infection are two reasons I could think of. I was reading one particular thread about nutrition, though, and I saw this idea mentioned a few times. People were mentioning a correlation between really nutritious diets during pregnancy with lots of protein, calcium, etc. and their water breaking at the very end. So, I was wondering if water breaking first was a sign of weaker membranes or something caused from a deficiency of some sort? Couldn't really find anything with Google though!
My first two labors started by my water breaking (1st lead to an induced labor with an epidural, second one my water broke and then labor started a few hours later). 3rd labor water broke right before DS was born. I didn't notice less pain or anything with the third labor (actually, I felt like it was more intense). I did eat so many oranges that pregnancy and not much else changed, so I think the vitamin C thing has some truth....
As others have said, the concern is related to risk of infection. The baby also needs that fluid to have a nice cushion during the stress of labor and to be able to spin around easily and maintain or find good positions; but I don't know if water breaking early would definitely take away enough of your amniotic fluid to cause a problem.
Water can break early because of a weak sac, but other things can cause it too, like your baby being in a posterior position and their head puts extra pressure in the wrong places. I speculate but don't actually know that your water can break first when your baby is really not quite ready to come out and that can lead to a long, slow to progress labor or induction.
My first was posterior and my water broke first, my contractions started out very gentle and my birth center midwives put me on the clock to be sent to the hospital if I didn't get a certain ways into active labor by a certain time. They told me to drink castor oil, etc etc. My contractions increased and eventually baby was born at the birth center but it was stressful to do that under pressure.
Before getting pregnant this time I heard that it can be related to nutrition so this pregnancy I ate a ton of citrus with the white part still on (bioflavinoids), and forgot to take but meant to take a lot of zinc (and vit e?). I also spent a LOT of time on SpinningBabies.com positions and exercises to avoid a posterior baby (due to the awful pain I had from back labor the first time), as well as chiropractic and other exercises designed to open the pelvis at the very end when baby seemed to be turning posterior, because some pelvis shapes (android) are supposedly prone to posterior babies and I felt mine might be.
Thankfully this baby did end up "left occiput transverse" - a good position - and my water did not break until I was at the brink of pushing. Yay! Can't prove it was due to my efforts but I felt pretty proud.
I do wonder about depleted nutrients bein the cause of weak membranes. I had terrible hyperemesis with the two whose water broke early in labour.
I don't think water breaking prior to labour starting is necessarily a bad thing or sign of a problem. That's how my labour started, water broke, contractions started about 30 min-1 hr later (I'd have to check the midwife's notes), and DD was born after only 8 hrs from the start - and that was a first baby for me and her head was badly positioned. I think there are some things that can go wrong (which are more likely if water is artificially ruptured IMO) but it can also be just a variation of normal.
I gave birth to my son within 5.5 hours after my water broke, contractions were close and intense from the time they started, so I wasn't really worried about infection or pressure to induce. Baby's position makes sense, but my son wasn't posterior. I just got really curious after reading about nutrition and wondered if there was a connection. I want to do what I can to strengthen the membranes this time around, because I don't want that risk if my labor isn't as quick! Thanks for all the input. Better go eat an orange!