Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › Devine Secrets of the Ya-Ya Sisterhood
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Devine Secrets of the Ya-Ya Sisterhood  

post #1 of 10
Thread Starter 
Has anyone seen this? What did you think? I was a little disturbed. It made me wonder if i was a horrible mother. How my children would judge my parenting and if that judgement would be based on reality and if so whose.

I really liked it but I haven't read the book and wasn't prepared for such a depressing movie.
post #2 of 10
i am not going to see the movie, as i have read and enjoyed the book several times and frankly i think the movie looks like crap.
as an adult child of abusive parents and a survivor of a seriously dysfunctional family, i identified with much of the book. one of the things i came away with after reading it is that mothers are human. they make mistakes, they may even be shitty mothers, but you only get one mother and if there's a way to forgive her, do it.
of course our kids will judge us as parents, doesn't everyone look back at their life and pass judgment on what our parents did and didn't do? kids only have their reality to judge parents by, but as they grow and possibly become parents themselves, they can sometimes see their parents' realities, and judge less harshly.
without getting into too much personal detail, it's only been in the past year that i am able to even contemplate the pain my mother has lived with and what caused her to act the way she did. she was certainly not the mother i wanted, but she is the one i got and now that i am a mommy, i was able to find a way to let go of some of that pain.
anyway, i don't know if you would even want to read the book now, but it is quite good, especially if you are drawn to dysfunctional families. rebecca wells' first book "little altars everywhere" showcases that same family in a different way. i think it's more of a character study than a novel, but it's enjoyable nonetheless. it's darker than ya-ya's, though, so it may depress you even more!
post #3 of 10
i thought of something else!
it really bugged me to see the trailer showing the ya-yas "inducting" siddalee. it's a closed group, no new people. period. one of the other things i took away from the book was the importance of female friendship and how it has changed through generations. throughout the book, siddalee envies her mother's closeness with these women who know her so intimately. sidda has no friends like that.
it just bothered me that the movie would so pervert one of the enduring themes of the original work. it bothered me so much, it was in my dream last night!
post #4 of 10
What's up with all the "yaya" stuff in the trailers for this movie? To my recollection of the book and of "Little Altars Everywhere" the phrase "yaya" wasn't used as a soundbite. Have I forgotten something? I loved the books and wouldn't object to seeing the movie if it were true to the spirit of the book. I suspect, however, that it's been changed, so I think I'll save my $6.75 and spend it on another movie, any suggestions gratefully received. Calgal
post #5 of 10
I loved the book and can't wait to see the movie. It's been long enough that this mommy brain doesn't remember particulars to make me nitpicky watching and I think it looks funny. I like to see any movie that has strong women characrters in the lead roles (especially if it promotes the kinship of women as this one does) because I like to think that it send a message to Hollywood that the public wants to see more of these.
post #6 of 10
Thread Starter 
I think I will read the book. I can read a book watch a movie, watch a re-make and come out not hating anybody. I love a good story no matter how it is told and regardless of inaccuracies.

The movie wasn't horrible. My friend just led me to believe it was a light hearted comedey about mothersdaughters and good friends. Huh! I grew up in an abusive home but my mom was pretty transparent so there was no real mystery but the movie did bring up a lot of crud. If I had been prepared I would have had a better experiance. I just couldn't feel too sorry for her mom. Although I must say her fathers character was amazing and I really enjoy when hollywood shows a good man/husband/father.
post #7 of 10
I just saw it last night and thought it was really good. The one problem I had was the way mental illness was treated- I mean yes, this mother had problems and things she needed to take responsibility for, but she also had a mental breakdown and was hospitalized for 6 months (due mostly to the medications she was prescribed). I would have liked someone to have said "Hey, that wasn't all your fault" I don't know, I gues that's just the way that mental illness is looked at in our society.
post #8 of 10
Exceptional read, yes! I'm seeing the movie tomorrow w/ the group I read the book with...so excited!

Shoshannas mom: Are you my sister? Anyhoooo, I think it's wonderful that you were able to bond w/ your mom in spite of the history. Unfortunately, my mom tried to carry the abuse into our adult relations and I had to let her go. I envy women who were able to work it out. That was one of the things that really got me thinking, when I read the book: Sidda's way of looking at her mom after finding out all the history and different perspectives. It made me think and cry A LOT. I agree the movie looks like crap, but it's one movie I'll see in spite of that...
post #9 of 10
I liked the movie for most of what it was...a movie. It was also very upsetting to me and I found myself crying for about 10 minutes straight during certain parts and I guess it probably has to do with the neglect that I felt from my own mother as a child and this movie stirred it up. I think that if you don't have big issues with your mother, this movie is great! LOL

Erin
post #10 of 10
Well, saw the movie. It's nothing like the book. So now I can like both! (Kinda like w/ Chocolat) I also cried for a good solid 10 minutes. No one else around me was, and I was kinda skocked. That movie has some very sad scenes.

Anyway, 2 thumbs up!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Books, Music and Other Media
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Natural Family Living › Books, Music and Other Media › Devine Secrets of the Ya-Ya Sisterhood