Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › The origins of no bfing
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

The origins of no bfing - Page 2  

post #21 of 26
My great-grandmother fed her children canned reconstituted evaporated milk, starting with my grandmother in 1900. Don't ask me why, but it might have been because she was decended from European aristocrats and it wouldn't have been "proper" for her to breastfeed. She was also raised by people who did not believe in striking children, but married a man who wholeheartedly believed in corporal punishment (not to mention that women should stay at home, not drive, and be compliant...not sure how she stood him. She lived to the age of 95 and never did learn to drive...but I am serously digressing).

I don't believe, for her, that it was any kind of enamorment with technology. She had her babies at home and would not take them to the hospital when they were sick, prefering to care for them at home. She thought hospitals were filthy, dirty places that you go to if you want to die. My Great Aunt Clara got pnemonia and was nursed back to health at home. The girl next door was taken to the hospital and died. That just stregnthen great-grandmas convictions.

My grandmother had her children between 1928-1940, and I believe fed them formula of some kind. My Aunt who had kids starting in 1952 fed them formula and rice cereal from 3 months on (I've seen the home movies...my cousin couldn't even sit up properly in the high chair).

My mother FINALLY saw the light and when my eldest sister was born in 1961, she was breastfed, as were the rest of us, the last having been born in 1976. My two sister and I have breastfed our children, as have my female cousins. So, at least in my family the insanity has ended.
post #22 of 26
Bumping my own thread about Breastfeeding in the 1920s and 30s:
http://www.mothering.com/discussions...36#post1686736

My mother was told, if she insisted on doing something as nasty as breastfeeding, that after every feed she MUST offer a bottle to prevent the baby from starving.
She did it because my father believed the doctor.
After about 6 weeks, she decided that sterilizing bottles and water was a PITA and stopped.
post #23 of 26
I second AmyWillow's rec. to read "Milk,Money Madness". It's an awesome book.

BTW, Amywillow, I *love* your sig- that is SO my DD.

My stepmother was so interested in me nursing DD and would ask questions about it and say "good for you". She said she was told to FF and given meds to dry her up before she left the hospital : and told to start pablum (dry cereal that looked like fish food flakes!) and orange juice at a couple months old, because the formula was so deficient.

She said she never propped the bottle but always fed my stepsister in arms. I can tell that she would have been a really awesome nursing mom and had the AP frame of mind and would have enjoyed nursing. I feel so sad for her. She also had to quit her job and get rehired because she was pregnant but that's another issue. I *thank God* I wasn't born a generation ago. I don't know how I'd have dealt with all that BS!

I guess with being told a woman's place was in the home for so long, some women found liberation in bottle feeding and being able to get "sexy" again and go back to work but I think it went to far in the opposite direction. I don't think my mom ever even entertained the idea of nursing me in the early 70's...
post #24 of 26
Another book to read is "Don't Kill Your Baby" by Jackie Wolf (I haven't read it).

The author posted a little bit of the history to Lactnet, you can read it here:
http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/scripts/...&P=R12205&I=-3


Here's another post by Jackie, talking about "formula":

Much of my book (Don't Kill Your Baby: Public Health and the Decline of
Breastfeeding in the 19th and 20th Centuries, Ohio State University Press,
2001) is on that very topic [information regarding the introduction of infant formula into our society. Or some anthropological information regarding use of artificial baby milk through the centuries or decades].

The word "formula" in relation to infant feeding stems from the 1890s. A
prominent Harvard University pediatrician, Thomas Rotch, had a theory (known as percentage feeding or The American Method) that if a chemist could tweak the content of cows' milk ever so slightly given the needs of each individual baby the "feeding problem" could be solved. So Rotch became
involved in opening what were dubbed "milk laboratories" in major urban
areas and the chemists at these laboratories would alter the protein, milk
sugar, and fat in cows' milk based on the mathematical formulas provided
them by physicians. Hence the word---formula. The mathematical formulas were indescribably complicated and, frankly, incomprehensible by any standard. But an entire urban industry, albeit a small one, burgeoned based on this theory. Hospitals, in fact, opened their own milk laboratories which
survived well into the 1930s. Formula writing in order to ostensibly produce
a food precisely suited for a particular baby based on height, weight,
physical condition, color of stools, odor of stools, texture of stools,
etc., etc. was taught in medical schools for decades. Medical students
complained that it was like learning higher astronomy. Thus the "science of
infant feeding" was born.

Hope this helps.

Jackie Wolf





Janice
post #25 of 26
This is another good history lesson from Lactnet:

http://peach.ease.lsoft.com/scripts/...&P=R10204&I=-3

Janice
post #26 of 26
I don't know, but my feeling is also think that man wants to believe their creation is better than nature's creation (God's creation for me, nature's for others) anyway, I really think they want to artificial everything. But like my signature says.. in my opinion, only God knows the formula for breastmilk.

Maybe it's also a cultural thing? It happens that the most "advanced" countries (usa and countries and europe) are the ones with lower bf'ing rates, I personally don't consider that very "advanced" I'm surprised civilized and modern countries such as this one, which so much "power and money" can't even educate women about breastfeeding. very, very sad.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Lactivism
This thread is locked  
Mothering › Forums › Breastfeeding › Lactivism › The origins of no bfing